The Best Man: A Book About Male Friendship Dynamics

The Best Man is a book by Richard Peck about a boy named Archer Magill and his journey through elementary school, from first to sixth grade. Archer has several role models in his life, including his dad, his uncle, his grandpa, and his teacher, Mr. McLeod. The book starts and ends with weddings, the first of which is a hilarious story of Archer's ill-fated turn as a ring bearer, and the second is a family wedding in which Archer has a deeper understanding of life and love. Throughout the book, Archer navigates the confusing world of his schoolmates and teachers, and slowly starts to understand more about the world of adults. He also learns about important topics such as friendships, love, death, same-sex marriage, and bullying.

Archer Magill's journey into middle school

Archer has four role models in his life: his dad, his uncle, his grandfather, and his teacher, Mr. McLeod. He learns some life lessons and discovers that maturing is about more than growing taller and getting a deeper voice. Archer's friendship with Lynette, a girl, could spark discussion about how boys and girls navigate friendships with each other.

The book touches on important topics such as friendships, love, death, same-sex marriage, and bullying. There are a few scenes of violence, but nothing graphic. The content is tame overall, with no swearing, drinking, or drug use.

Archer's journey from first grade through sixth grade and the situations he encounters are fun to follow. He goes from not understanding what's going on around him to eventually keying in on conversations and social nuances. It is nice to see a book show this aspect of maturing into a young adult. Much of the book centers on Archer's relationships with his male role models. They all bring something different to his life and help him grow into a good young man.

The story is funny, poignant, and heartwarming. It'll give younger readers a lot to think about while also entertaining them.

Archer's family life

Archer Magill is a young boy with a loving family. He has three role models in his life: his dad, who restores vintage cars; his grandpa, an architect; and his Uncle Paul, who is "just plain great". Archer also has a sister, Holly, who is seven years older than him. Archer's family is supportive and caring, and they often spend time together. For example, Archer's dad and grandpa share a passion for cars, and his grandpa built the two houses that the Magill family lives in. Archer's dad also lovingly cares for his ailing father.

Archer's mom is a marriage counsellor who works from home. She has a complicated relationship with her mother-in-law, Archer's grandma, whom she describes as a "commanding" figure. Despite their differences, the Magill family is close-knit and supportive of one another. Archer's uncle, Paul, is a significant part of their lives and often spends time with them, especially on Fridays.

Archer's family plays an important role in his life and helps shape his values and outlook. They provide him with love, guidance, and a sense of security as he navigates the challenges of growing up.

The male role models in Archer's life

The Best Man is a book by Richard Peck that explores the life of a young man named Archer Magill and the important male role models who shape his life. Archer, a thoughtful and observant boy, grows up surrounded by a cast of unique and memorable men who each leave their mark on him. Here is a look at the male role models in Archer's life and how they influence his journey:

Firstly, we have Archer's grandfather, Hiram Magill. Hiram is a larger-than-life character, a self-made man who built a successful plumbing business from scratch. He is a strong and stoic figure, a man of few words but deep wisdom. Hiram teaches Archer about hard work, resilience, and the value of a job well done. He impounds in Archer a sense of practicality and a respect for the trades, offering a counterpoint to the academic pursuits that Archer's parents value. Hiram's influence gives Archer a sense of stability and a connection to the "real world" beyond the sometimes-rarefied atmosphere of his parents' intellectual circles.

Then there is Miss Gertrude, Archer's great-uncle. Miss Gertrude is a refined and educated gentleman, a retired English professor who introduces Archer to the world of literature and critical thinking. He encourages Archer's love of reading and stimulates his intellectual curiosity. Miss Gertrude is a contrast to Hiram, representing the world of academia and the arts. He exposes Archer to Shakespeare, poetry, and the power of language, expanding his horizons and fostering a love of learning. Miss Gertrude's influence shapes Archer's intellectual development and encourages him to pursue a different path from the more traditional masculine roles embodied by his grandfather.

Another important figure is Archer's father, James Magill. James is a psychologist and a gentle, thoughtful man. He embodies a more modern conception of masculinity, one that values emotional intelligence and sensitivity. James teaches Archer about empathy and understanding, encouraging him to explore his feelings and express himself openly. His relationship with Archer is based on mutual respect and honest communication, offering a model of positive father-son dynamics. James' influence helps Archer develop his emotional intelligence and navigate the complexities of adolescence with a strong sense of self-awareness.

Lastly, we have Jerry, Archer's uncle and James' brother. Jerry is a free spirit, a man who marches to the beat of his own drum. He is adventurous and spontaneous, bringing a sense of excitement and unpredictability into Archer's life. Jerry teaches Archer about taking risks, embracing new experiences, and living life on your terms. He represents a different aspect of masculinity, one that challenges social norms and embraces individuality. His influence encourages Archer to think beyond conventional paths and explore his unique passions and interests.

Through these four male role models, Archer experiences a rich tapestry of masculine identities and learns valuable lessons about life, work, and personal growth. Each man offers something unique, shaping Archer's character and providing him with a diverse set of role models to draw from as he navigates his own path to manhood. The book, therefore, becomes a thoughtful exploration of the various influences that shape a young man's life and the power of positive role models in fostering a healthy sense of self and masculinity.

Friendships and love

Archer's role models include his father, grandfather, Uncle Paul, and his student teacher, Mr. McLeod. He looks up to these men and wants to emulate them. Uncle Paul and Mr. McLeod's relationship is a significant part of the story, as it explores the theme of same-sex marriage through a child's perspective. Archer's understanding of their romance develops gradually, and he eventually plays a role in bringing them together.

Archer also forms a close friendship with Lynette Stanley, a girl he meets at the first wedding. Their relationship challenges the notion that boys and girls cannot be friends and highlights the importance of platonic relationships. Archer and Lynette support each other through the ups and downs of elementary school, providing a sense of stability and camaraderie.

The novel also touches on the theme of self-love and acceptance. Archer is on a journey to understand himself and the kind of person he wants to become. He learns that growing up is about more than physical changes; it's also about emotional maturity and discovering your true self.

"The Best Man" celebrates diverse relationships and presents a heartwarming portrayal of love and friendship through the eyes of a young boy. It showcases the importance of positive role models and the impact they can have on a child's life.

Bullying

Archer's school experiences bullying first-hand, and we see the impact this has on him. In one scene, a fellow first-grader pulls a knife on him in the bathroom. We also see the aftermath of a schoolyard fight, and Archer's school is briefly put on lockdown over a false alarm. In another scene, a boy is shown after being tied to a sink in the boys' bathroom.

The book also explores the broader issue of how to respond to bullying. Archer's teacher, Mr. McLeod, bravely confronts school bullies. And when Archer sees bullying, he learns an important lesson: "It is never OK to bully anyone, and you should act when you see bullying."

Frequently asked questions