Catholics Attending Weddings: Divorce And Catholic Conundrum

Catholics are not excommunicated for getting divorced, and divorced people are encouraged to participate in church activities. However, if a Catholic wishes to remarry after a divorce, the Church requires them to go through the tribunal process to determine whether to apply a declaration of nullity to the end of the relationship. If the tribunal process does not grant a declaration of nullity, the Catholic cannot remarry in a Catholic Church.

If a Catholic attends the wedding of a divorced person, they may be condoning an invalid marriage. However, it is not always easy to determine whether a marriage is invalid. For example, a Catholic may attend any wedding held in a Catholic Church, but if the wedding is held in a non-Catholic setting, they may have serious reservations about attending.

Catholics can attend a wedding in a Catholic Church

In the case of a divorced Catholic who wishes to remarry in the Catholic Church, an annulment is required. An annulment is a declaration by the Church that the previous marriage was invalid from the beginning, essentially confirming that a sacramental marriage never took place. This can be a complex process, and individuals seeking an annulment should speak to their pastors for guidance.

Now, regarding the attendance of a Catholic at a wedding in a Catholic Church, there are a few scenarios to consider:

Case 1: Catholic Wedding in a Catholic Church

In this scenario, all Catholics are permitted to attend without reservations. This includes weddings between a Catholic and a non-Catholic that take place in a Catholic Church. The assumption is that both spouses are free to marry, as any canonical impediments would have been addressed through prenuptial forms and questionnaires.

Case 2: Catholic Wedding in a Non-Catholic Setting

If a Catholic wishes to marry a non-Catholic in a non-Catholic church or setting, they must obtain a dispensation from their bishop. Once the dispensation is granted and the marriage is recorded in the Catholic parish, all Catholics may attend the wedding but with some reservations. It is important to note that Catholics cannot receive communion in a non-Catholic ceremony.

Case 3: Non-Canonical Form Marriage of a Catholic

This case involves a Catholic who chooses to marry outside of the Catholic Church without the bishop's dispensation. While this is considered a sin, the "Catholic" spouse may be poorly instructed or unaware that it is a sin. In this case, Catholics may attend the wedding if their presence might encourage the "Catholic" spouse to bring their marriage into the Church and put Christ at the center of their relationship.

Case 4: Remarriage of a Divorced Person Without Annulment

This scenario involves the attempted remarriage of a divorced person without obtaining an annulment. According to the teachings of Jesus, a practicing Catholic should not attend such a wedding, as it would be considered an invalid marriage. However, some priests advise that passive presence may be legitimate to maintain a relationship with a relative, especially if one's intention is to keep lines of communication open.

In conclusion, while Catholics can attend weddings in a Catholic Church, they should consider the specific circumstances surrounding the marriage. The Church's teachings on divorce and remarriage should be respected, and the decision to attend should be made with careful consideration of one's conscience and the guidance provided by the Church.

Catholics can attend a Catholic wedding in a non-Catholic setting, but with reservations

In the case of a Catholic wedding in a non-Catholic setting, the publication advises that Catholics may attend with reservations. This scenario involves a practising Catholic who falls in love with a non-Catholic person and wishes to marry outside of the Catholic Church. For example, the non-Catholic partner's father may be the minister of a Protestant congregation, and the couple wants to get married there. In this case, the Catholic partner must request dispensation from their bishop. If the dispensation is granted, the marriage can take place but must still be recorded in the Catholic parish. Additionally, the Catholic partner must inform the non-Catholic partner of their intention to raise their children as Catholics.

If the Catholic partner has obtained the bishop's dispensation to marry in a non-Catholic ceremony, and both spouses are free to marry, then any Catholic may attend the wedding. However, if there is a communion service during the ceremony, Catholics should not receive communion in a non-Catholic ceremony. This case also covers Catholics attending weddings of any non-Catholic couple in any non-Catholic ceremony. Catholics may attend in good conscience if the spouses are free to marry and not already married.

This scenario highlights the complexities that may arise when a Catholic wedding takes place outside of the traditional Catholic Church setting. It is important for Catholics to consider the specific circumstances and make informed decisions about their participation in such weddings.

In summary, while Catholics can attend a Catholic wedding in a non-Catholic setting, they should do so with reservations and ensure that the appropriate dispensations and intentions are in place. These considerations are essential to maintaining their standing in the Catholic Church and respecting the sacred nature of marriage.

Catholics can attend a non-canonical form marriage of a Catholic, but with serious reservations

Catholics can attend the non-canonical form marriage of another Catholic, but with serious reservations. This scenario involves two individuals who are free to marry, with one or both having been baptised as Catholic and not having formally defected from the Catholic Church. They may be "cultural Catholics" who do not actively practice the faith. The couple chooses to marry outside of a Catholic Church and without the bishop's dispensation from canonical form, opting for a non-Catholic ceremony or a secular setting.

While this type of marriage is potentially valid if both parties are free to marry and intend to uphold the properties of unity and indissolubility, it does not fulfil canon law. The absence of the canonical form, which includes marriage in the presence of a parish priest and two witnesses, constitutes a defect. This defect can be easily remedied, and if the individuals involved were poorly instructed or unaware that marrying outside the Church is considered a sin, their marriage can be blessed in the Church post-wedding.

Catholics facing this situation may grapple with the decision to attend. On the one hand, they may want to show support for their family or friends. On the other hand, they also want to remain faithful to Christ and His teachings on marriage. It is important to remember that Catholics are never obliged to attend any wedding. If attending a wedding would push the Catholic individual(s) involved farther away from the Catholic Church, it is advisable to refrain from attending. However, if your presence could help bring them closer to the Church, attendance may be considered, provided that you also encourage them to get their marriage blessed in the Church and centre their relationship around Christ.

Ultimately, the decision to attend a non-canonical form marriage of a Catholic rests on one's conscience and the potential impact on the relationship of the individuals involved with the Church. While it is a serious matter that requires thoughtful consideration, it is also an opportunity to extend love, support, and guidance to those who may be struggling to reconcile their choices with their faith.

Catholics should not attend a remarriage of a divorced person without annulment

Catholics should not attend the remarriage of a divorced person without an annulment. This is because the Catholic Church does not recognise civil divorce, and considers individuals to be still married in church law. The Church believes that God established marriage as a permanent union, and that Jesus taught marriage to be indissoluble. Therefore, a divorced Catholic who wishes to remarry in the Catholic Church must first obtain an annulment, which confirms that the previous marriage bond was never properly contracted.

The Church's stance on this issue is clear: a Catholic may attend any wedding held in a Catholic Church, but when it comes to the remarriage of a divorced person outside of the Church and without an annulment, practicing Catholics should not attend. This is because their attendance would seem to condone an invalid marriage, and they would thus be "partly culpable for the sin".

However, this is a complex issue, and some priests with pastoral experience suggest that there may be legitimate reasons for passive attendance at the wedding ceremony, especially to maintain a relationship with a relative. In such cases, the principle of double effect may apply: the action of attending is neither good nor bad, but the intention is good (to keep lines of communication open with the relative), and the good effect is not a consequence of the evil effect. Nevertheless, it may be advisable to attend the ceremony and not the reception, and to indicate disapproval of the union.

Ultimately, the decision to attend or not attend such a wedding is a personal one, and Catholics must weigh up their desire to support family and friends with their desire to remain faithful to Christ and His teachings on marriage.

Catholics should not attend a wedding of a divorced person who has remarried without an annulment

The Catholic Church does not recognise civil divorce, as it considers marriage to be an unbreakable and permanent union. However, divorced people are still considered full members of the Church and are welcome to participate in its activities.

Divorced Catholics can receive Holy Communion, but only if they have not remarried or have remarried following an annulment. If a divorced Catholic wishes to remarry in the Catholic Church, they must first obtain an annulment of their previous marriage. An annulment is a declaration of nullity, confirming that the marriage bond was never properly contracted in the first place.

According to Father Francis Hoffman, a Catholic should not attend the wedding of a divorced person who has remarried without an annulment. He states that doing so would be condoning an invalid marriage and would make one partly culpable for the sin. He suggests that a Catholic should explain their absence by saying that they love the individuals and want the best for them, but cannot ignore the clear teachings of Jesus Christ.

However, Hoffman also acknowledges that some priests believe there may be legitimate reasons for passive attendance, especially to maintain a relationship with a relative. In such cases, the principle of double effect should be applied:

• The action of attending is good or indifferent.
• The intention behind attending is good.
• The good effect intended is not a consequence of the evil effect.
• There is a proportionately serious reason for attending.

In conclusion, while the Catholic Church does not prohibit its members from attending the wedding of a divorced person who has remarried without an annulment, it is generally advised against. Attending such a wedding may be considered condoning a sin, and one should carefully consider the potential consequences of their actions.

Frequently asked questions