The Unreliable Best Man: What To Do?

The best man is the groom's right-hand man and go-to confidante, tasked with a long list of responsibilities, from planning the bachelor party to holding the wedding rings. But what happens when the best man is undependable? Being undependable means being unable to be trusted or relied on. It can manifest in various ways, such as missing appointments, rescheduling at the last minute, or constantly dropping the ball on tasks assigned to them. If the best man is undependable, it can cause a lot of stress and chaos for the groom and the wedding party. So, what can be done to address this issue?

Ask another groomsman to step in

If your best man is proving to be undependable, it might be time to ask another groomsman to step in and take on the role. Here are some tips on how to handle this situation:

Firstly, it's important to have an open and honest conversation with your current best man. Let him know that you value your friendship but that you feel he may be unreliable for the role. It's possible that he is dealing with personal issues or has taken on too many commitments, and by having this conversation, you can give him a graceful exit.

Next, you'll want to choose another groomsman to take on the role of best man. This person should be someone you trust and who has the time and organisational skills needed for the role. It's a good idea to ask someone who has already been a best man, as they will be familiar with the responsibilities and what is expected of them.

Once you've chosen your new best man, be sure to clearly communicate their new role to them and the rest of the wedding party. They will need to take on additional responsibilities, so give them a detailed list of what is expected, including any tasks that need to be completed by a certain date.

Your new best man will also need to be included in any pre-wedding events or activities that have already taken place. This may include introducing them to the other groomsmen and making sure they feel included and up to speed.

Finally, don't forget to update your best man on the day-of timeline and any other important information. This will ensure that they can fully step into their new role and be the supportive and dependable right-hand man that you need on your wedding day.

Take over the best man's duties

If you are taking over the best man's duties, it is likely that you are already aware of the responsibilities that come with the role. However, it is always good to have a clear understanding of what is expected of you. Here is a comprehensive list of duties that you, as the best man, will need to take on:

Before the Wedding:

• Help choose the suits: As the best man, you will need to assist the groom in selecting and purchasing or renting wedding formalwear, as well as coordinating the other groomsmen's ensembles. This may include gathering measurements, setting order deadlines, or even placing the order yourself.
• Arrange to meet the ushers: Get to know the other ushers and groomsmen, and be the point of contact for any questions or concerns they may have. You can make this fun by inviting everyone to get together, including the couple, and bonding over food and drinks.
• Liaise with the Maid of Honour: Although not an official duty, communicating with the Maid of Honour can be helpful. You can coordinate and have certain things on hand for the wedding day, such as umbrellas in case of bad weather or gifts for the couple.
• Help with planning: While traditionally the best man is not expected to pitch in with wedding planning, offering to help with logistical details like booking vendors, managing RSVPs, or coordinating schedules can take a lot of stress off the couple.
• Plan the stag do: You will be in charge of organising the groom's last big night out before the wedding. Check with the groom for a guest list and preferred dates, and try to accommodate everyone's budget. It is recommended to plan the stag do at least a month before the wedding so that everyone has time to recover.
• Write your speech: Start working on your best man's speech well in advance, and don't be afraid to practise! You can find guides and examples online to help structure your speech and include all the necessary elements.
• Organise a groomsmen's gift: Although not compulsory, it is a nice gesture to present the groom with a gift from all the groomsmen. Chat with the other groomsmen and see if they would like to contribute.
• Final fittings: Keep an eye out for any last-minute suit fittings that the groom or groomsmen might need. With all the wedding planning, they might not have the time or energy to chase down alterations.
• Check in with the groom: Take some time to check in with the groom and provide emotional support. The wedding day is one of the biggest days of his life, and he may be feeling nervous or overwhelmed.
• Help with pre-wedding set-up: Offer to help with any tasks at the venue, such as picking up and delivering hired items, setting up furniture, or directing suppliers.

On the Wedding Day:

• Help the groom get ready: On the morning of the wedding, assist the groom with getting dressed and ensure that all the groomsmen are ready on time. You can also put together a playlist of songs to get everyone in a festive mood.
• Organise the ushers: On the wedding day, be the point of contact for the ushers, especially if there are any younger page boys or junior ushers who need help with their outfits or general supervision.
• Keep the rings safe: One of the most important duties of the best man is to be the ring bearer and keep the wedding rings safe until they are exchanged during the ceremony. Even if there is a separate ring bearer, you may still be tasked with holding the rings until they are needed.
• Greet the guests with the groom: Ensure that the groom arrives at the venue at least 20 minutes before the ceremony is scheduled to begin. Stand by his side, welcome the arriving guests, and create a warm and inviting atmosphere.
• Stand at the altar with the groom: Before the ceremony, take your place on the front right-hand side of the room at the altar. If you are the ring bearer, make sure you have the rings ready for when the couple exchanges them.
• Escort the Maid of Honour: Tradition states that after the ceremony, the best man escorts the Maid of Honour out of the room ahead of the newlyweds.
• Stand in the receiving line: If the couple chooses to have a receiving line, you will be expected to greet the guests as a key part of the wedding party.
• Help organise wedding photographs: Work with the ushers to round up guests for group photos and ensure that everyone on the photographer's list is included.
• Be the Master of Ceremonies: If the couple has not hired a toastmaster or Master of Ceremonies, you may be asked to announce key moments such as the couple's arrival, the speeches, and the cutting of the cake.
• Deliver your speech: After the meal (or before, depending on the couple's preference), it will be time to deliver your best man's speech. Speak slowly, pause for laughter, and mention everyone who needs to be mentioned.
• Get the party started: After the first dance, it is traditional for the best man to dance with the Maid of Honour (if there is one) and encourage everyone onto the dance floor.

After the Wedding:

• Return and clean suits: Help round up and return any hired items, such as suits or decorative details used at the venue. If the suits weren't hired, take them to be dry-cleaned as soon as possible.
• Take care of wedding gifts: If the couple goes on their honeymoon immediately, you may be asked to safely store the wedding gifts, cards, guest book, and other keepsakes until they return.

Remember, it is important to stay organised and prepared throughout your role as the best man. Create checklists and timelines to ensure that you don't miss any important tasks.

Have the groom handle his own responsibilities

If the best man is proving to be undependable, it may be a good idea for the groom to handle his own responsibilities. Here are some ways to approach this:

Be Proactive

The groom should take charge of his own responsibilities and not rely on the best man to handle them. This means taking ownership of tasks and ensuring they are completed without depending on the best man. The groom should also be prepared for any last-minute changes or cancellations by the best man and have backup plans in place.

Communicate Clearly

The groom should clearly communicate his expectations and responsibilities to the best man. He should be direct and specific about what needs to be done and when. This will help the best man understand his duties and the importance of fulfilling them. It is also essential to have open communication, so the groom should express his concerns and frustrations if the best man is not meeting his responsibilities.

Seek Alternative Support

The groom can enlist the help of other groomsmen or friends to take on some of the best man's responsibilities. By delegating tasks to multiple people, the groom can ensure that things get done without putting all the pressure on an unreliable best man. It is also beneficial to have a backup plan, such as having another groomsman ready to step in if needed.

Focus on the Positive

While it is essential to address the best man's unreliability, the groom should also acknowledge and appreciate the things he does well. This can help boost the best man's confidence and motivate him to step up. Additionally, focusing on the positive aspects of their relationship can help strengthen their bond and encourage open communication.

Set Clear Boundaries

The groom should set clear boundaries and let the best man know what behaviour is unacceptable. He should communicate the consequences of not meeting responsibilities and be firm in enforcing them. This will help the best man understand the seriousness of his role and the impact of his actions.

Offer Support and Guidance

If the best man is struggling with his responsibilities, the groom can offer support and guidance to help him improve. This could involve having an open conversation about any challenges the best man is facing and working together to find solutions. The groom can also provide resources or connect the best man with people who can help him become more reliable.

Postpone the wedding

If your best man is unreliable, it may be best to postpone the wedding. Here are some reasons why:

The Impact on Your Mental Health

It can be disappointing, frustrating, and infuriating to deal with unreliable people. If your best man is causing you stress, it may be best to take some time to re-evaluate the situation and postpone the wedding. This will give you the opportunity to address any issues and ensure that everyone is on the same page before moving forward with the wedding plans.

The Impact on Your Relationship

Unreliable behaviour can lead to resentment and disconnection in relationships. If your best man is not fulfilling his responsibilities, it may cause tension and affect your friendship. Postponing the wedding will allow you to address these issues and work on rebuilding trust.

The Impact on Your Wedding Plans

The best man plays an important role in the wedding, and if he is unreliable, it could affect your plans. By postponing the wedding, you can ensure that you have enough time to make alternative arrangements if needed. This will also give you the opportunity to communicate your expectations clearly and ensure that everyone is on the same page.

The Impact on Your Guests

If your best man is unreliable, it could affect the experience of your guests. For example, if he is supposed to give a speech but doesn't show up or is not prepared, it could disrupt the flow of the wedding and leave a negative impression on your guests. Postponing the wedding will allow you to address any potential issues and ensure that your guests have a positive experience.

The Impact on Your Future Plans

Postponing the wedding will give you the opportunity to address any underlying issues and work on improving your relationship with your best man. It will also allow you to set clear boundaries and expectations for the future. This will help ensure that you can rely on him not only for the wedding but also for any future plans or important life events.

Call off the wedding

Calling off a wedding is never an easy decision, and it's essential to consider all the factors involved. Here are some paragraphs to guide you if you're thinking of calling off the wedding due to an unreliable best man:

Recognize the Impact of Unreliability:

The best man plays a crucial role in the wedding ceremony and the lead-up to the big day. If he is unreliable, it can cause significant stress and disruption. From failing to plan and organize the bachelor party to missing important rehearsals and events, his unreliability can affect the entire wedding party and the couple. It's essential to acknowledge the impact of his actions and how they are influencing your decision.

Communicate Your Concerns:

Before making any drastic decisions, it's important to communicate your concerns directly to the best man. Schedule a private meeting, express your intention to improve the situation, and share your worries honestly. Explain how his unreliability is affecting you and the wedding preparations. Be specific, providing examples of instances where he has let you down. This open communication may prompt him to change his behavior and step up to his responsibilities.

Explore Underlying Issues:

Sometimes, unreliability can stem from underlying issues. Consider whether the best man is facing personal challenges, such as depression or other emotional difficulties, that are impacting his ability to fulfill his duties. Approach this conversation with empathy and offer your support. If he is dealing with personal struggles, it may be appropriate to relieve him of his best man duties to reduce his stress and allow him to focus on his well-being.

Set Clear Boundaries and Expectations:

If the best man is simply unreliable due to a lack of commitment or poor time management, it's crucial to set clear boundaries and expectations. Communicate the importance of specific tasks and events and ask him to commit to them. For example, you could say, "It's important to me that you attend the rehearsal dinner and be there to support me. Can I count on you for that?" By setting clear expectations, you give him a chance to step up and be more dependable.

Consider Alternatives:

If the best man continues to be unreliable despite your efforts, it may be necessary to consider alternatives. Depending on the situation, you could ask another friend or family member to step in as best man or divide the duties among the groomsmen. This can ensure that the necessary tasks are completed without placing all the responsibility on one unreliable person.

Make a Decision:

Ultimately, the decision to call off the wedding or not rests with you and your partner. If the best man's unreliability is causing significant stress and disruption to the wedding preparations and your relationship, it may be wise to reconsider the wedding date. Postponing the wedding can give you time to resolve the issues, reorganize, and ensure a smoother process. However, this is a significant decision that should not be taken lightly, and it's essential to weigh all factors involved.

Remember, open communication and empathy are key when dealing with an unreliable best man. While it's essential to consider the impact on your wedding, it's also important to approach the situation with compassion and explore potential solutions together.

Frequently asked questions