Golden Bachelor Wedding: Cancelled Or Postponed?

The Golden Bachelor wedding between Gerry Turner and Theresa Nist was a televised event that took place in January 2024, just three months before the couple announced their divorce. The wedding was broadcast live on ABC and Hulu and was the first-ever Golden Wedding in the franchise's history. Turner, 72, and Nist, 70, were the first Golden Bachelor couple, having met on the show and gotten engaged in November 2023. Despite their fairytale ending, the couple's marriage was short-lived, with Turner and Nist citing their inability to decide on a place to live as the reason for their split.

Gerry Turner and Theresa Nist's televised wedding

Gerry, a 72-year-old widower from Indiana, and Theresa, a 70-year-old financial advisor from New Jersey, had a whirlwind romance that captivated viewers across the nation. Their journey began on the show's premiere on September 28, when Theresa arrived at the Bachelor Mansion on her 70th birthday, along with 21 other contestants aged 60 to 75. The couple hit it off immediately, sharing a kiss after Gerry playfully smeared birthday cupcake frosting on his lips and asked Theresa for help cleaning up.

Their bond strengthened during a solo date in Episode 2, where they found solace in each other as they discussed the loss of their respective spouses. Gerry had been married to his high school sweetheart, Toni, for 43 years before she passed away in 2017. Theresa, on the other hand, had been married to her husband, Billy, for 42 years before his death in the same year. During this date, the couple even fantasised about running off to Italy together, a dream that would later become a reality.

However, their path to love wasn't without drama, as Theresa found herself in the midst of mansion drama, particularly with fellow contestant Kathy Swarts, who expressed frustration over Theresa's constant retelling of her solo date with Gerry. The tension culminated in a heated exchange, with Kathy infamously telling Theresa, "Zip it!" This phrase became a meme and a catchphrase, but it ultimately led to Kathy's early departure from the show.

Despite the challenges, Gerry and Theresa's love prevailed, and in the November 30 finale, Gerry got down on one knee and proposed to Theresa, who excitedly accepted. The wedding was a star-studded event, with appearances by fellow Bachelor alumni and even a surprise proposal by a former "Bachelor in Paradise" contestant to his girlfriend. The ceremony was officiated by popular contestant Susan Noles, and it marked the beginning of a new chapter for the lovebirds.

Unfortunately, their fairytale came to an abrupt end just three months after the wedding, when the couple announced their decision to divorce. In a joint interview on "Good Morning America," Gerry and Theresa revealed that they had mutually agreed to dissolve their marriage, citing differences in plans for the future. Despite their short-lived union, the couple insisted that they still loved and supported each other, and they encouraged others to continue seeking love, no matter their age.

The couple's short-lived marriage

Gerry Turner and Theresa Nist's marriage was short-lived. The couple, aged 72 and 70, respectively, first met on the reality dating show 'The Golden Bachelor'. Turner, a widower from Indiana, was the show's first "Golden Bachelor", and Nist, a financial advisor from Shrewsbury, New Jersey, was one of 22 contestants. The two hit it off from the start, bonding over the loss of their respective spouses. Turner proposed to Nist in the show's finale, and they married in a televised "Golden Wedding" just two months later.

However, their fairytale ending was not meant to be. Just three months after their wedding, the couple announced their decision to divorce. In an interview with Good Morning America, they revealed that they had mutually decided to end their marriage, citing differences in where they wanted to live as a reason for their split. Despite their short-lived marriage, the couple insisted that they still loved and cared for each other, with Turner stating that he rooted for Nist every day.

The news of their divorce came as a surprise to many, including the show's host, Jesse Palmer, who shared his well-wishes for the couple on Instagram. While some criticised the wedding as a boring and ick broadcast, others reflected on the impact of the show and the couple's relationship, which offered a sense of authenticity and charm that resonated with viewers.

Turner's controversial past

Gerry Turner, the 72-year-old first-ever Golden Bachelor, has had his fair share of controversies. On the show, Turner claimed that he hadn't dated anyone since the death of his first wife, to whom he was married for 43 years. However, a woman came forward and identified herself as Turner's ex-girlfriend, stating that they dated for over two years. When confronted about this revelation, Turner acknowledged "there's just enough truth in [the article]" but brushed it off, claiming it didn't fit with the positive things happening in his life.

Additionally, Turner's professional qualifications were also called into question. The details of his controversial past emerged right before the "After the Final Rose" ceremony, where he proposed to Theresa Nist, the winner of the Golden Bachelor. This timing led to accusations of blindsiding from Leslie Fhima, the other finalist on the show, who expressed her displeasure on live TV.

Despite these controversies, Turner and Nist decided to move forward with their wedding, which was televised as "The Golden Wedding." The couple's relationship and wedding captivated audiences due to their authenticity and charm, as they both seemed more real and vulnerable than typical reality TV stars. However, their fairy-tale romance ended just three months after their televised wedding, when they announced their decision to get a divorce.

The Golden Wedding's reception

The Golden Wedding reception was a star-studded affair, with many famous—if not exactly A-list—faces in attendance. The guest list included former contestants from The Golden Bachelor, such as Kathy Swarts, who acted as an interviewer on the red carpet, as well as other members of Bachelor Nation. The reception was also attended by the final two women from the show, Leslie and Theresa, and even the runner-up, Leslie, who had expressed her heartbreak on live TV upon hearing Gerry's proposal to Theresa.

The reception was held indoors, following an outdoor ceremony, and was part of an ABC special on the wedding. The special also included footage from a bachelorette party involving Theresa and other contestants from the show, and an embarrassing proposal between a former Bachelor in Paradise contestant and his girlfriend.

The reception itself was a conventional affair, with the couple exchanging rings by Neil Lane. The bride, Theresa, wore a Badgley Mischka dress, though one commentator preferred the Nordstrom-available number she wore at the finale of the show. The couple also promoted their "Golden Registry" on Amazon, which included diamond-crusted items selected by designers.

The wedding was a chance for the couple to make bank, and they were gifted a honeymoon in Italy by the show's host, Jesse Palmer, on behalf of ABC. The reception was a let-down for some viewers, who had hoped for a more authentic celebration, given the ages of the couple and the reality of the show.

The Golden Bachelor's impact

The Golden Bachelor couple, Gerry Turner and Theresa Nist, announced their divorce just three months after their televised wedding. The couple, both in their 70s, had a short-lived, whirlwind romance that captivated audiences and brought a new dynamic to reality TV.

Impact on Reality TV

The Golden Bachelor was a spin-off of the popular reality dating show, The Bachelor, but with a senior edition. The show's premise of featuring older contestants brought a sense of authenticity that resonated with viewers. The joy of this iteration was that the contestants seemed more real, with their own unique life experiences, aches, pains, and a deeper sense of self. This charmed audiences who had perhaps tuned out of the typical reality TV dating scene. The success of The Golden Bachelor and its impact on audiences proved that there is a market for more diverse and authentic representations on reality TV.

Impact on Audiences

The couple's later-in-life love story was inspiring to many, especially those searching for a second or third chance at love. Despite the short-lived nature of their marriage, their story encouraged people to embrace love, regardless of age. Theresa Nist, in particular, encouraged people not to give up on love, stating, "Don't give up. Stay hopeful." This message resonated with audiences, and the show's popularity led to the greenlighting of another spin-off, The Golden Bachelorette.

Impact on the Couple

While the marriage ended shortly after the wedding, the couple insists they still have love for each other and are not giving up on the idea of love. They have returned the ring gifted by the show and will likely have to navigate the challenges of being influencers and public figures post-breakup.

Impact on Future Relationships

The Golden Bachelor couple's experience may have a lasting impact on how future contestants on the show, and perhaps even in real life, approach relationships and marriage. Their story highlights the potential challenges of finding love on reality TV, where contestants have very little time to get to know each other and make life-changing decisions. It serves as a reminder that a rushed decision to get married may not always be the best choice, even if it feels right in the moment.

The impact of The Golden Bachelor wedding and its subsequent divorce reached far beyond the couple themselves. It sparked conversations about the authenticity of reality TV, the nature of love and relationships, and the potential consequences of impulsive decisions. While the couple's marriage did not stand the test of time, their story and its aftermath will continue to resonate with audiences and future contestants navigating the complex world of reality TV relationships.

Frequently asked questions