My Big Fat American Gypsy Wedding" Cancelled: Exploring The Show's Sudden En

My Big Fat American Gypsy Wedding is a reality TV show that aired on TLC from 2012 to 2016. The show focused on the marriage customs of Romani-Americans, although many of its stars were not from the Romani community. The show attracted millions of viewers and was popular throughout its run, but it also sparked controversy and was criticised for misrepresenting and stereotyping the Romani community. The show has since been cancelled, but it continues to be talked about and has had a lasting impact on public perception of the Romani community.

The show's portrayal of Romani culture is inaccurate and offensive

My Big Fat American Gypsy Wedding has been criticised for its portrayal of Romani culture, with many Romani people finding the show offensive. The show has been accused of cultivating racist stereotypes, misrepresenting the Romani-American community, and grouping Travellers and Roma together despite their cultural differences.

One of the main criticisms of the show is that it perpetuates the stereotype that Romani people live in trailers, marry off their young daughters, and that Romani women are uneducated and prefer cleaning to getting an education. In reality, many Romani people have accomplished great things while still holding on to their identity. The show also fails to acknowledge that Romani people are an ethnic group, not a group defined by their way of life or a cult.

The show has also been criticised for its portrayal of Romani women as "slaves to men", only good for "cooking and cleaning, and always being available to open our legs to them". This portrayal is particularly harmful as it comes at a time when domestic violence against Romani and Traveller women in the UK is prevalent.

Furthermore, the show has been accused of causing harm to a group of people who are already under scrutiny. Irish Traveller Kathleen reported that after the show aired, parents at her children's school wouldn't let their kids play with hers because they said "we stink and don't talk properly".

Finally, the show has been criticised for its lack of authenticity. Many of the weddings featured on the show are fake, with actors hired to play the parts of the bride and groom.

The show omits major cultural details and fails to explain historical context

My Big Fat American Gypsy Wedding has been criticised for failing to explain the historical context of the cultures it depicts and omitting major cultural details. The show has been described as wildly misleading by journalists and activists concerned with minority rights.

One of the biggest criticisms is that the show groups Travellers and Roma together, despite there being very prominent differences between the two cultures. Travellers are ethnic Irish, while the Roma came from Eastern Europe and historians trace their origins back to India. Seyward Darby, online editor for The New Republic, explains that:

> Viewers are instead offered an overly simplistic view of the cultures of Travellers and Roma with scarcely any historical or political context about their place in the United Kingdom and Europe.

European Roma, Pip, wrote in an open letter to the show's producers:

> Just 10% of the Gypsy and Traveller population are actually Irish Travellers. The majority, like myself, are in fact Romany, yet your 'documentary' seems to ignore our existence. While Irish Travellers originate from Ireland, we can trace our routes back to India, so it was hardly surprising that I was somewhat confused when you use the word Gypsy in the title of your 'documentary' about Irish Travellers.

The show also fails to explain why these cultures have lived nomadic lifestyles for centuries, or how prejudice against them has evolved over generations. While the second episode touches on Traveller communities being evicted from their camps, there is no attempt to provide a broader context for this treatment.

The show has also been criticised for perpetuating dangerous stereotypes by referring to these communities as living in a "'hidden world' and having a 'highly secretive community'. This language encourages viewers to see Travellers and Roma as "others" or "aliens", when in reality, their cultures are incredibly diverse, with many individuals pursuing higher education and careers.

By failing to provide historical and political context, and perpetuating stereotypes, the show has contributed to a misunderstanding of these communities and has been accused of cultivating racist stereotypes and negatively impacting the lives of those in the Traveller and Roma communities.

The show's participants claim that some storylines are fake

The TLC reality show "My Big Fat American Gypsy Wedding" has been criticised by its Romani and Irish Traveller participants for misrepresenting their communities and perpetuating harmful stereotypes.

In 2014, Priscilla Kelly, a participant in Season 1, revealed on Facebook that producers hired actors and faked weddings to fit their narrative. She wrote:

> "Basically [producers] told me if I would just get married it didn't matter who it was it didn't have to be legal just so they had something to put on TV."

In 2020, a Reddit user who claimed to have gone to school with Season 2 participant Heather Small, alleged that several details of Small's storyline were fabricated. According to the user, Small was "constantly absent" from school, despite her mother's insistence on the show that she finish her education. They also claimed that Small's drama with her future mother-in-law was exaggerated, and that Small and her fiancé Brandon Boswell never actually got married.

In addition to these allegations, the show has been criticised for grouping Travellers and Roma together, despite their distinct cultural differences, and for portraying a ""simplistic view" of their cultures without historical or political context. Many participants have also taken issue with the show's portrayal of their communities as uneducated, violent, and obsessed with extravagant weddings.

The show has been accused of glorifying negative stereotypes

My Big Fat American Gypsy Wedding has been accused of glorifying negative stereotypes. The show has been criticised for cultivating racist stereotypes and misrepresenting the Romani Gypsy community.

The series, which revolves around the marriage customs of Romani-Americans, has been called ""wildly misleading"" by some journalists and activists concerned with minority rights. They argue that the show fails to provide historical or political context about the place of Romani Gypsies in the United States and instead presents an overly simplistic and biased view of their culture.

The show has also been criticised for grouping Travellers and Roma together, despite prominent differences between the two cultures. Travellers are ethnic Irish, while Roma originated from Eastern Europe and India. By failing to clearly distinguish between the two groups, the show contributes to the misconception that all Gypsies are the same.

In addition, the show has been accused of perpetuating dangerous stereotypes by portraying Romani Gypsies as ""uneducated, flashy, and closed-minded people who live in mobile-home parks and throw enormous parties." This portrayal reinforces the idea that Gypsies are "other" and reinforces prejudices and negative stereotypes about the community.

The advertising for the show has also come under fire. The Advertising Standards Authority ruled that the promotional posters for the second series of the original British version of the show, Big Fat Gypsy Weddings, were irresponsible and offensive, depicting a child in a sexualised way and reinforcing negative stereotypes about the Traveller and Gypsy communities.

Many members of the Romani Gypsy community have expressed outrage at the show's portrayal of their culture and traditions. They argue that the show gets many things wrong, from the extravagance of the wedding dresses to the ""grabbing" ritual, which most in the community have never heard of. The show also fails to represent the reality of poverty and discrimination that many Romani Gypsies face.

As a result of these criticisms, some have called for more accurate and nuanced representations of the Romani Gypsy community in the media, which reflect the diversity and complexity of their culture and experiences.

The show has had a negative impact on Traveller and Roma communities

The show "My Big Fat American Gypsy Wedding" has been criticised for its negative impact on Traveller and Roma communities. The programme has been accused of cultivating racist stereotypes, misrepresenting the Romani-American community, and grouping Travellers and Roma together despite their significant cultural differences.

One of the most significant criticisms of the show is that it perpetuates the idea that all members of these communities live in trailers, marry off their young daughters, and encourage women to be homemakers rather than pursue education or careers. In reality, many members of the Romani community have accomplished great things while still holding on to their cultural identity. The show also fails to acknowledge the existence of the Roma, who make up the majority of the Gypsy and Traveller population, instead focusing primarily on Irish Travellers.

The show's portrayal of Romani-Americans as uneducated, promiscuous, and violent has led to increased discrimination and bullying of these communities. One Irish Traveller mother of six shared that other parents at her children's school refuse to let their kids socialise with hers because they believe all Travellers are dirty and uneducated. The show's portrayal of Romani-Americans as a monolithic group has also led to a lack of understanding and empathy for the diverse range of experiences within these communities.

Furthermore, the show has been accused of perpetuating the idea that Romani-Americans are a homogeneous group, ignoring the diverse range of cultures, traditions, and lifestyles that exist within these communities. The show's focus on over-the-top weddings and parties, as well as its portrayal of Romani-Americans as having a "look but don't touch" policy towards relationships and sex, contributes to a simplistic and misleading view of these communities.

Frequently asked questions