Wedding Cake Wonders: Do Weddings Still Need Them?

Wedding cakes have been a staple of wedding celebrations for centuries, but are they a necessity? The answer ultimately depends on the couple's preferences and traditions. While some couples opt for a traditional tiered wedding cake, others choose to forgo the cake altogether in favour of alternative desserts or interactive dessert stations.

The history of wedding cakes dates back to ancient Rome, where the groom would break a loaf of barley bread over the bride's head, symbolising fertility and the end of her chastity. In medieval England, small spiced buns were stacked high, and the bride and groom shared a kiss over the tower, foretelling a lifetime of prosperity. Today, wedding cakes can be almost any dessert the couple chooses, with endless options for flavours, designs, and presentations.

Some couples still view the wedding cake as a must-have, whether for tradition, symbolism, or the simple love of cake. It serves as a focal point of the wedding, a delicious dessert for guests, and a memorable photo opportunity for the couple. However, others view it as an unnecessary expense, especially if they are serving other desserts or believe that guests won't eat it.

So, do weddings need wedding cakes? The decision rests with the couple and their vision for their special day. Whether they choose a grand tiered cake, a small cutting cake, alternative desserts, or no cake at all, the most important thing is that their choice reflects their unique personalities and preferences.

Wedding Cake History

Wedding cakes have been a part of the ceremony since ancient Greek and Roman times, although they didn't always come in the form we know today. In Ancient Rome, a cake of wheat or barley was broken over the bride's head to bring good fortune to the couple. This tradition was also practised by the ancient Greeks, to symbolise the end of the bride's purity and the groom's subsequent dominance over her.

In Medieval England, cakes were stacked as high as possible and the newlyweds would attempt to kiss over the top of the stack. If they were successful, it was believed they would be blessed with many children and a prosperous life together. From this tradition, the Croquembouche was created. The story goes that a pastry chef visiting Medieval England witnessed this custom and, upon returning to France, piled sweet rolls into a tower to make the first Croquembouche.

In the 17th century, two cakes were made: one for the bride and one for the groom. The bride's cake was usually a simple pound cake with white icing, as white was a symbol of virginity and purity. The groom's cake was typically a darker, rich fruit cake and was much smaller. In the 18th century, the bride's cake became sweeter and more elaborate, with double icing and three-dimensional decorations.

The modern wedding cake as we know it today originated at the wedding of Prince Leopold, Duke of Albany, in 1882. His wedding cake was the first to be completely edible, with separate layers of cake and dense icing that were stacked on top of each other. This method was a groundbreaking innovation for wedding cakes at the time.

Wedding Cake Traditions

Wedding cakes have been a part of wedding ceremonies for centuries, though they weren't always the focal point of the event. The contemporary wedding cake has evolved from various ethnic traditions, with one of the earliest traditions being that of the Ancient Romans, who broke a cake of wheat or barley over the bride's head to bring good fortune to the couple.

In Medieval England, cakes were stacked as high as possible, and the bride and groom would attempt to kiss over the top of the stack, with a successful kiss guaranteeing a prosperous life together. This tradition led to the creation of the Croquembouche, a tower of cream puffs, which is still popular in France today.

The tradition of the bride's cake, which was usually a simple pound cake with white icing, began in the 17th century. White was chosen as a symbol of the bride's virginity and purity. The groom's cake, which was a darker, rich fruit cake, eventually fell out of favour as the bride's cake became the main event.

The modern wedding cake as we know it today originated at the wedding of Prince Leopold, Duke of Albany, in 1882. His wedding cake was the first to be entirely edible, and it was created in separate layers with very dense icing that could be stacked once hardened.

• Freezing the top tier: Many couples choose to save the top tier of their wedding cake to eat on their first anniversary. This tradition dates back to the 19th century when couples would eat the preserved cake on their first child's christening, which usually occurred within a year of the wedding.
• Wedding cake pulls: This tradition, dating back to the Victorian era, involves placing ribbon-adorned charms on the bottom layer of the cake. Single friends and wedding party members then take turns pulling charms from the cake, with each charm holding a specific meaning, such as a ring for an upcoming engagement or a clover for good luck.
• Feeding each other cake: The tradition of the couple feeding each other the first bites of wedding cake dates back to Ancient Roman times. It symbolises their first feat as a unified team and their commitment to creating a sweet life together.
• Groom's cake: This tradition dates back to Victorian England, where three cakes were served at weddings: the guest cake, the bride's cake, and the groom's cake. The groom's cake often features the groom's favourite sports team or another aspect of his personality or hobbies.
• Cake cutting: Cutting the cake is often the first activity done as a couple, though historically the bride did this alone to symbolise the loss of her virginity. It also symbolises the couple's commitment to providing for one another.
• White wedding cake: In the Victorian era, white sugar was extremely expensive, so a white cake symbolised the family's wealth and social standing. White also symbolised purity and the start of the marriage union, as brides typically wear white dresses.
• Sleeping with a piece of cake under your pillow: This 17th-century superstition suggests that sleeping with a slice of wedding cake under your pillow will lead you to dream of your future spouse.
• Wedding cake toppers: These date back hundreds of years and are a chance for the couple to showcase their personality or fashion a small replica of themselves (and maybe their pets) to place on top of the cake.

Wedding Cake Flavours

Wedding cakes have been a part of wedding ceremonies for centuries, and while they were not always the focus of the event, they have always been steeped in symbolism.

In modern times, wedding cakes are often chosen to reflect the personalities of the couple. While some couples opt for a cake that serves as a centerpiece, others choose to focus on flavour.

• Vanilla: This classic flavour is a versatile option that can be paired with almost any cake filling or frosting. Some ideas include vanilla cake with passionfruit curd, raspberry filling, or a strawberry shortcake with heavy vanilla cream.
• Chocolate: For chocoholics, there are many ways to add a twist to a plain chocolate cake. Try hazelnut cake with chocolate buttercream, dark chocolate matcha with berries, or mint chocolate cake.
• Red velvet: This rich and decadent flavour is delicious on its own or served with cream cheese frosting.
• Almond: A nutty alternative to vanilla or chocolate, almond cake can be paired with cherry filling or, for a similar flavour, try pistachio cake with buttercream and caramelized pistachios.
• Lemon: A popular choice for summer weddings, lemon cake is sweet, light, and refreshing. Pair it with lemon curd and fresh strawberries for a tart dessert.
• Funfetti: This crowd-pleasing option is perfect for couples looking for something a little less traditional.
• Spiced cake: Ideal for autumn weddings, spice cake can be paired with pumpkin cream cheese frosting, spiced pear cake, or apple spice cake with salted caramel frosting.
• Marble cake: For couples who can't choose between chocolate and vanilla, marble cake offers the best of both worlds. A dusting of cinnamon or a dulce de leche glaze adds a unique touch.

Ultimately, the choice of wedding cake flavour depends on the couple's preferences. Whether they opt for a traditional flavour or something more adventurous, the cake should reflect their tastes and be enjoyed by their guests.

Wedding Cake Alternatives

Wedding cakes have been a tradition for centuries, but that doesn't mean you have to have one at your wedding! Here are some alternative ideas for wedding desserts:

Go for a Wedding Pie

Instead of a cake, why not try a pie? You could have a single large pie or a selection of smaller pies in different flavours. This idea harks back to the "bride's pie" of the 16th and 17th centuries, which was filled with oysters, lamb testicles, pine kernels and cocks' combs. Nowadays, you might prefer something a little sweeter!

Serve Up Some Doughnuts

Doughnuts are a fun and unusual alternative to a wedding cake. You could hang them on a wall, stack them in a tower, or create a "doughnut bar" where guests can customise their treats with sprinkles and frosting.

Offer an Array of Desserts

If you can't decide on one alternative, why not offer a selection of desserts? This could be a fully DIY affair, or you could ask the bakers in your family to contribute their favourite treats.

Opt for a Different Cultural Tradition

Take inspiration from other cultures and countries. For example, you could try a croquembouche (a tower of cream puffs and caramelised sugar, which is traditional in France), a tiramisu (an Italian dessert made with mascarpone custard, whipped cream, rum and coffee-soaked ladyfingers), or a Kransekake (a Scandinavian pastry made from rings of almond cookie and royal icing).

Choose Savoury Cheeses

If you're not a fan of sweet things, how about a "cake" made from stacked wheels of cheese? You could even add some flowers and greenery to make it look more like a traditional wedding cake.

Get an Ice Cream Truck

Hire an ice cream truck to come to your wedding and serve your guests a variety of flavours. This is a great idea for a summer wedding!

Create a Display of Macarons

Macarons are a popular choice for weddings, and it's easy to see why. These colourful French pastries can be arranged in a unique ombré pattern or stacked to look like a traditional tiered cake.

Serve Something Personal

Choose a dessert that has a personal meaning to you and your partner. For example, you could reference your favourite cookie by creating a tower of Oreos, or opt for a dessert that nods to your heritage, such as Italian millefoglie or cannolis.

Offer Pre-Portioned Treats

If you'd like to give each guest an individual dessert, you could try mini key lime pies, cake pops, or cupcakes.

Break with Tradition Completely

Who says you have to have a dessert at all? One couple on Reddit mentioned that they didn't have a cake or an alternative! If you're having a full meal, your guests might not be expecting another course.

Wedding Cake Toppers

Today, wedding cake toppers can be more personalised, with couples choosing toppers that reflect their personalities and interests. For example, toppers can be designed to showcase shared hobbies or passions, or can be humorous, light-hearted, or related to a couple's occupation. In Mexico, the wedding topper and other decorations are used to tell a story about the couple's history.

Frequently asked questions