Ministers And Priests: Can They Officiate Weddings Together?

The Catholic Church does not allow a Catholic priest to concelebrate a wedding with a Protestant minister. Canon 1127.3 forbids a marriage celebration in which the Catholic celebrant ministers together with a non-Catholic cleric, with each following the ritual prescribed by their faith. However, it may be possible to obtain a dispensation from canonical form under certain circumstances, such as when a Catholic wishes to marry a Protestant whose father is a minister. In such cases, a dispensation from the Catholic party's bishop allows the Catholic to marry in the Protestant ceremony, and the marriage is still considered valid by the Catholic Church.

Catholic weddings must be officiated by a Catholic priest or deacon

While a Catholic priest or deacon must be present to officiate a Catholic wedding, it is possible for a dispensation from canonical form to be granted in certain circumstances. For example, if a Catholic wishes to marry a Protestant whose father is a minister, a dispensation can be obtained from the Catholic party's bishop in advance, allowing the couple to marry in a Protestant ceremony conducted by the Protestant's father. The Catholic Church will still recognize the marriage as valid.

However, it is not permissible for a Catholic priest or deacon to co-officiate a wedding alongside a non-Catholic cleric, as this would imply that the Catholic Church considers other religious groups to be its equal. The Church wants to avoid giving the impression that a non-Catholic wedding or cleric is on equal footing with a Catholic one.

It is worth noting that the rules regarding Catholic weddings and who can officiate them can be complex and may vary depending on specific circumstances.

A dispensation from canonical form can be requested for a non-Catholic wedding

Catholics who wish to marry must observe canonical form. This means that the marriage of a Catholic is only valid if it is celebrated by the local bishop or pastor of the parish, or a priest or deacon delegated by either of them, and in the presence of two witnesses.

However, it may be possible to obtain a dispensation from canonical form under certain circumstances. For example, dispensations are frequently granted when a Catholic is marrying a Protestant Christian whose father is a minister and who wants to officiate at the wedding of his own child. If a dispensation is obtained from the Catholic party's bishop in advance, the Catholic may marry in the Protestant ceremony conducted by the Protestant party's father, and the Catholic Church will still recognize the marriage as valid.

In the Archdiocese of Saint Paul and Minneapolis, a dispensation from canonical form can be requested when there are serious difficulties in observing the Catholic canonical form in a marriage between a Catholic and a non-Catholic Christian or between a Catholic and an unbaptized person. The conditions for seeking a dispensation from the canonical form of marriage from the Archbishop of Saint Paul and Minneapolis are as follows:

• The marriage may not take place outdoors or in private homes, halls, commercial wedding chapels, or in clerical or religious chapels.
• In the case of a marriage between a Catholic and a non-Catholic Christian, a dispensation may be granted to allow the marriage to take place in the church of the non-Catholic party.
• In the case of a marriage between a Catholic and an unbaptized person, a dispensation may be granted to permit the marriage to take place in another suitable location outside of the churches of both parties, noting the restrictions outlined in the first condition. This accommodation is reserved for cases in which there is an unwillingness on the part of the unbaptized party or their family to celebrate the marriage in a Catholic church or chapel.
• The officiant of the marriage will not be a Catholic priest or deacon, and no Catholic priest or deacon will participate in the ceremony as an official witness.
• The Catholic party must express a genuine commitment to continue the practice of the Catholic faith.

In the Archdiocese of Vancouver, a dispensation from canonical form can be requested when a Catholic party is planning to enter into a mixed-religion marriage. The Archbishop may provide a dispensation from canonical form, permitting the marriage to take place before non-Catholic clergy or a civil official in certain circumstances. However, this dispensation must be granted before the marriage, and cannot be given for a marriage where both parties are Catholics.

A non-Catholic minister cannot co-officiate a Catholic wedding

The Catholic Church is very clear on this matter, and it is not simply a matter of personal preference or opinion. The Church's position stems from its belief that it is the true faith established by God, and therefore, a non-Catholic minister or wedding ceremony cannot be considered equal to a Catholic one. The Church wants to avoid giving the impression that it views other religious groups as equals or that a non-Catholic cleric can officiate at the marriage of a Catholic.

However, it is possible for a Catholic to obtain a dispensation from canonical form under certain circumstances. For example, if a Catholic is marrying a Protestant Christian whose father is a minister, a dispensation can be granted for the Catholic to marry in the Protestant ceremony conducted by the Protestant minister. In this case, the Catholic Church will still recognize the marriage as valid.

In the case of a Catholic wedding, if one of the parties to the marriage is non-Catholic and their minister is unable to co-officiate, there may be other ways to include them in the ceremony. For example, the non-Catholic minister could be seated in a prominent place in the church during the ceremony, as long as it is clear that they are not officiating. Alternatively, the Catholic party may request a dispensation from canonical form, allowing the wedding to take place in the non-Catholic party's church with their minister officiating.

A Catholic cannot attend a non-sacramental wedding

A Catholic can attend a non-sacramental wedding, but there are some considerations to keep in mind. Firstly, it's important to understand the difference between a sacramental and a non-sacramental wedding. A sacramental marriage occurs when a Catholic marries a baptised non-Catholic, such as an Episcopalian, Presbyterian, or Baptist. On the other hand, a non-sacramental marriage takes place when a Catholic marries a non-baptised individual, such as a Hindu, Jew, or Muslim.

When it comes to attending a non-sacramental wedding, the key factor to consider is whether the marriage is valid according to natural law. If the marriage is valid, meaning both spouses are free to marry and intend to do so with unity and indissolubility, then a Catholic can attend without conflict. However, if the marriage is invalid, such as in the case of a Catholic marrying outside the Church without the bishop's dispensation or the remarriage of a divorced person without an annulment, it would be against Catholic teachings to participate.

Additionally, it's worth noting that while a Catholic can attend a non-sacramental wedding, they should refrain from taking an active role in the ceremony, such as being a best man or performing a reading. They should also be mindful of any rituals or religious activities that may conflict with their own faith.

In conclusion, while a Catholic cannot participate in a non-sacramental wedding that goes against Church teachings, they are generally allowed to attend as an observer, as long as the marriage is considered valid according to natural law.

A Catholic wedding must be witnessed by an authorised representative of the Church

The Catholic Church recognises sacramental marriages in Protestant denominations because it is the couple, not a priest or deacon, who make the sacrament of marriage present. However, a Catholic wedding must still be witnessed by an authorised representative of the Church. This is a requirement even if a dispensation from canonical form has been obtained, allowing a Catholic to marry in a non-Catholic ceremony.

In the case of a mixed marriage between a Catholic and a non-Catholic, a dispensation from canonical form may be obtained to allow the wedding to take place in a non-Catholic church. However, the Catholic Church may only permit this under certain circumstances, such as if the non-Catholic party has strong spiritual and familial connections to the church. Even in this case, the wedding must still be witnessed by an authorised representative of the Church.

If a dispensation from canonical form is not obtained, a Catholic should not attend the wedding, as there will be no valid sacramental union to celebrate.

Frequently asked questions