Wedding Shower Chat: When Can You Sue?

Infidelity can be emotionally draining and stressful, and it is natural to wonder if you can sue your partner for cheating. While it is possible to bring a civil case against a cheating spouse, it is a complex process and is usually not successful. To win a cheating lawsuit, you must prove that the cheating caused measurable harm, such as financial problems or severe emotional distress. Additionally, only a few states in the US, such as Florida, North Carolina, Hawaii, Mississippi, New Mexico, South Carolina, and Utah, allow for alienation of affection lawsuits, where a third party can be sued for intentionally interfering in a marital relationship.

Adultery is illegal in Florida, USA

Adultery can also have an impact on divorce proceedings in Florida, despite it being a “no-fault” divorce state. For example, adultery can affect the distribution of assets and alimony if your spouse spent a lot of marital money on the other person. It can also impact child custody, as one of the factors a court considers when determining the best interests of the children is the "moral fitness of the parents".

In terms of civil lawsuits, it is possible to sue your spouse or their lover for cheating in certain circumstances. For example, if you contracted an STD/STI from your spouse because they had an affair, you could bring a civil suit against them for monetary damages. You could also sue your spouse for intentional infliction of emotional distress, although this can be challenging to prove. It is also possible to file an alienation of affection lawsuit against the third party in some states, but Florida is not one of them.

You can sue for emotional distress

Infidelity can be emotionally draining, stressful, and traumatic. If your spouse cheated on you, you may be wondering if you can sue for emotional distress. Although it is complicated, there are a few circumstances in which you could bring a civil case against a cheating spouse.

In the state of California, victims who have suffered emotional anguish due to the actions of another person can sometimes sue for either negligent or intentional infliction of emotional distress (NIED or IIED lawsuits). Adultery can cause significant emotional distress, but it is important to carefully consider the requirements for this type of lawsuit:

• Proving the existence of emotional pain through expert testimony, such as that of a counselor.
• Establishing that your pain is a direct result of the actions of the other person.
• Documenting the severity of your distress and how the trauma has diminished your quality of life.
• Demonstrating that your spouse's behaviour was outrageous or reckless and intended to cause you emotional distress (for IIED lawsuits only).

It is worth noting that proving these elements can be challenging and costly. Unless you have a strong case or stand to recoup a large amount of financial compensation, filing an NIED or IIED lawsuit may not be worth the time and expense.

In Florida, the law allows spouses to sue each other for intentional infliction of emotional distress. However, to succeed in such a claim, you would have to prove that your spouse:

• Acted intentionally or recklessly;
• Engaged in extreme and outrageous conduct; and
• Caused you severe emotional distress.

Given that statistical data indicates that approximately 57% of divorces are caused by infidelity, proving that your spouse's cheating rose to the level of "extreme and outrageous" conduct may be difficult.

In summary, while you may be able to sue for emotional distress in certain jurisdictions, it is important to carefully consider the requirements and challenges of bringing such a claim. It may be more constructive to focus on equitable solutions and moving forward with your life, rather than seeking vengeance through litigation.

You can sue for breach of contract

Infidelity can be emotionally distressing and stressful. If your spouse cheated on you, you may be wondering if you can sue them for a breach of contract. While it is not common, there are a few circumstances in which you might be able to bring a civil case against a cheating spouse.

In certain cases, a spouse who has been betrayed may claim that their partner's act of infidelity violates a specific or implied agreement within the marriage. However, courts usually hesitate to uphold such agreements, especially considering the prevailing trend of no-fault divorce in modern times.

To win a breach of contract lawsuit against your spouse, you would need to prove that their act of infidelity violated a specific or implied contract between you. This could include prenuptial or postnuptial agreements that outline the terms of your marriage, including fidelity. You would also need to demonstrate how their breach of contract caused you measurable harm, such as financial losses or emotional distress.

It is important to note that the laws and success rates of breach of contract lawsuits vary by state. In some states, such as California, it is generally not possible to sue for breach of contract in cases of infidelity due to the no-fault divorce law. In other states, such as Florida, adultery is illegal and can result in criminal charges, but civil lawsuits for breach of contract are less common.

Before pursuing legal action, it is essential to consult with an experienced family law attorney who can advise you on the specific laws and options available in your state. They can help you understand the potential challenges and costs associated with breach of contract lawsuits and guide you in making an informed decision.

You can sue the third party for alienation of affection

Adultery can be emotionally draining and stressful, and it is natural to want to seek justice and compensation for your pain. While it is complicated, there are a few circumstances in which you might be able to bring a civil case against a cheating spouse or the third party involved. One such circumstance is alienation of affection.

Alienation of affection is a civil tort claim that can be filed by a spouse whose partner has been unfaithful, usually against the third party involved. To file for alienation of affection, you must prove that your marriage was happy and loving, that the third party intentionally interfered and destroyed your marriage, and that they intended to do so. It is important to note that only a handful of states in the US recognize this type of lawsuit, including North Carolina, Hawaii, Mississippi, New Mexico, South Carolina, and Utah.

To win an alienation of affection lawsuit, you must provide evidence that the third party was primarily responsible for the loss of affection in your marriage. This can be challenging, as it requires proving the existence and loss of love, as well as the intention of the third party to cause harm. Additionally, the law surrounding adultery and infidelity has evolved over time, with a shift towards no-fault divorce and a recognition of the privacy rights of individuals.

While alienation of affection lawsuits can provide a sense of justice and compensation for the wronged spouse, it is important to carefully consider the challenges and costs associated with such legal action. Unless financial compensation is a significant factor, suing for alienation of affection may not be worth the time, effort, and emotional toll it entails. Instead, focusing on healing and moving forward may be a more constructive approach.

You can sue for criminal conversation

In the past, people could sue for "criminal conversation", which was based on the belief that a spouse had a right to exclusive sexual relations. However, most places have now abolished this law as it is outdated and invades people's privacy.

In the context of a wedding shower, if someone cheats, it is not possible to directly sue that person for "criminal conversation" or "alienation of affection". These types of lawsuits are generally not recognised, especially in no-fault divorce states. Instead, the cheating spouse may face criminal charges or civil liability for related issues such as transmitting an STD/STI or spending marital assets on their affair.

To successfully sue for "criminal conversation", one would have to prove that the cheating caused measurable harm, such as financial loss or severe emotional distress. This can be challenging and costly, which is why most people decide against taking legal action against a cheating partner.

Frequently asked questions