Refreezing Wedding Cake: Is It Possible?

Freezing a wedding cake is a longstanding tradition, with many couples choosing to save the top tier to eat on their first anniversary. While it is possible to refreeze a cake that has been previously frozen, it is not recommended, as it may affect the texture and quality of the cake. The process of refreezing can help lock in moisture, but it is important to consume the cake within a few days after the initial thaw for the best taste and texture.

How to wrap a wedding cake for refreezing

To wrap a wedding cake for refreezing, you should first consider the timing. Ideally, the cake should be prepped for freezing on the wedding day after the cake-cutting ceremony or the morning after. It's important to remove any decorations, such as real flowers, sugar flowers, or a cake topper, before freezing.

The next step is to prep the frosting. Place the cake on a baking sheet or plate and let it sit in the freezer for one to three hours or overnight to allow the frosting to harden. This will prevent the frosting from sticking to the plastic wrap and making a mess.

Once the frosting is set, gather your supplies: plastic wrap, aluminium foil, and a zippered plastic freezer bag. Wrap the cake tightly in three layers of plastic wrap, pushing the wrap against the cake to ensure no air bubbles are left. Then, cover it with three layers of aluminium foil and place it in the plastic bag, pushing out as much air as possible.

Finally, place the wrapped cake in the back of your freezer, where it is coldest and least exposed to warm air.

How long can you freeze a wedding cake for?

Freezing your wedding cake is a great way to preserve a memory from your special day and relive it on your first anniversary. The length of time you can freeze a wedding cake depends on the type of cake.

A traditional fruit cake can be preserved for longer than a year, while a sponge cake (especially one with fruit and cream) may not hold up as well. For a sponge cake, it is recommended to not freeze for longer than one month. However, one couple shared that they froze their sponge cake tier and enjoyed it on their first wedding anniversary, saying it tasted as delicious as on their wedding day.

To avoid freezer burn, it is recommended to stick to the three-month rule. Check your cake periodically to ensure no ice is building up on it, and be sure to wrap it thoroughly to prevent air from reaching the cake.

If you are unsure about freezing your wedding cake, you can always check with your baker, who may be able to create a replica of your wedding cake's top tier for you to enjoy on your anniversary.

How to defrost a wedding cake

So, you've decided to stick with the tradition of saving the top tier of your wedding cake to enjoy on your first anniversary. Now, you're wondering how to defrost it. Here is a step-by-step guide on how to properly defrost your wedding cake:

• Timing is crucial: Take your cake out of the freezer 24 to 48 hours before you plan to eat it. This timing will ensure the cake has enough time to defrost properly.
• Unwrap the cake: Remove the cake from its airtight container and carefully take off all the plastic wrap.
• Back to the fridge: Place the cake back into the airtight container and return it to the refrigerator. Leave it there for a couple of hours or even overnight. You want to make sure the cake is fully defrosted and soft.
• Bring it to room temperature: On the day you plan to indulge in your sweet memories, take the cake out of the refrigerator and its container. Allow the cake to sit at room temperature for about two hours before serving. Then, enjoy your delicious trip down memory lane!

Some additional tips to keep in mind:

• It is recommended to defrost the cake slowly in the fridge to avoid condensation forming and causing permanent marks on the icing.
• If you're short on time, you can defrost the cake at room temperature, but it's best to give it a couple of hours to ensure it's fully thawed and ready to be enjoyed.
• While not necessary, for an extra touch of sentiment, you can decorate the cake with fresh flowers or a new cake topper similar to the one you had on your wedding day.

What types of wedding cakes are suitable for refreezing?

Wedding cakes with buttercream frosting generally freeze and thaw well. This includes Swiss Meringue Buttercream, which has a light yet indulgent texture and melts in your mouth. However, if your wedding cake is buttercream-based, it is best to avoid refreezing it after it has been thawed.

If you have a fondant-covered wedding cake, it can be refrozen, but it is not recommended. Fondant is typically used to cover cakes with buttercream or chocolate ganache underneath, which can be successfully frozen and refrozen. While fondant keeps the cake fresh for longer, it may not be the best option if you plan to refreeze your cake.

Chocolate ganache wedding cakes can also be frozen but are more temperamental due to the chocolate. White chocolate ganache, in particular, has a yellow tinge that can be challenging to colour unless tinted.

Naked or semi-naked cakes are not ideal for refreezing as they are more prone to drying out or melting. These cakes are also more suitable for immediate consumption as they do not keep well after the wedding.

In general, it is best to consult your baker about the specific cake you plan to freeze and refreeze, as some delicate cakes, such as sponge cakes, may not retain their intended texture and taste.

Wedding cake freezing traditions

The tradition of freezing the top tier of a wedding cake is a long-standing one, with roots in a 19th-century convention where couples would save the top tier for their first child's christening, with some believing it to bring good luck and prosperity. In modern times, this tradition has evolved, and many couples now choose to freeze their wedding cake to eat on their first wedding anniversary, marking a special milestone in their married life.

This tradition is a beloved part of wedding celebrations, allowing couples to relive the magic of their wedding day. The process involves carefully prepping, wrapping, freezing, and thawing the cake, ensuring it remains fresh and tasty for their anniversary. It is recommended to freeze the cake as close to the wedding day as possible, removing any decorations, and properly wrapping it to prevent freezer burn.

While some couples opt to follow this tradition, others may prefer a fresh cake on their anniversary. Bakers often offer to create a replica of the top tier, providing a freshly baked alternative for couples who want to enjoy their cake without freezing it.

The type of wedding cake also plays a role in this tradition. While most cakes can be frozen, certain delicate cakes, such as sponge cakes or those with whipped cream toppings, may not hold up well in the freezer. On the other hand, heartier cakes like chocolate, carrot, hazelnut, or almond cakes are better suited for freezing.

For those who choose to freeze their wedding cake, it becomes a special way to commemorate their bond and reflect on their relationship as they approach their second year of marriage. Whether it's enjoyed on the first anniversary or slightly after, the tradition of freezing and savouring a wedding cake is a meaningful way to celebrate love and create lasting memories.

Frequently asked questions