Foreign Rabbi Wedding Officiant: Is It Legal?

In Israel, a rabbi can be detained for conducting a non-Orthodox wedding. Rabbi Dov Haiyun was detained by the police for conducting a Jewish wedding outside the authority of Israel's haredi Orthodox Chief Rabbinate. However, in the United States, any Jewish person, not necessarily a rabbi, can perform a wedding ceremony. According to the Talmud, the laws of marriage are complex, and an error can be very serious, therefore, the person performing the wedding must be intimately familiar with these laws.

Non-Orthodox weddings in Israel can lead to arrest

In Israel, marriages are performed under the auspices of the religious community to which the couple belongs. The country only recognizes marriages under the Jewish, Muslim, and Druze faiths, as well as ten specified denominations of Christianity. The religious authority for Jewish marriages is the Chief Rabbinate of Israel and the Rabbinical courts.

While Israel recognizes civil, interfaith, and same-sex marriages performed abroad, it does not permit them within the country. As a result, some Israelis opt to marry in nearby countries like Cyprus or, since 2022, via videoconference with an officiant in Utah.

In 2013, Israel passed a law forbidding the performance of weddings outside the Rabbinate, which carries a sentence of up to two years in prison. This law was enforced for the first time in 2018 when Rabbi Dov Haiyun, a Conservative rabbi, was detained for conducting non-Orthodox weddings. The incident sparked protests in Israel and abroad, highlighting the Orthodox monopoly over Jewish practice in the country.

The law in question outlaws any traditional Jewish marriage performed outside the authority of the Chief Rabbinate. It states that rabbis who perform non-sanctioned weddings in Israel could be subject to prosecution, and the same applies to the marrying couple. When the law was passed, a spokesman for the Chief Rabbinate clarified that non-Orthodox weddings would only be considered illegal if they were performed using traditional Jewish rites.

The arrest of Rabbi Haiyun brought attention to the issue of civil marriage in Israel, which is a significant concern for secular and non-Orthodox Jews who are required to follow Orthodox practices to marry within the country.

The Orthodox monopoly over Jewish practice in Israel

In Israel, the state-sanctioned ultra-Orthodox Chief Rabbinate controls all recognized Jewish marriage, divorce, burial, and conversion. This has led to protests in Israel and abroad against the Orthodox monopoly over Jewish practice.

The Chief Rabbinate

The Chief Rabbinate is a state-sanctioned body dominated by haredi Orthodox rabbis that controls all recognized Jewish marriage, divorce, burial, and conversion in Israel. The Chief Rabbinate only recognizes as Jewish those who are born to a Jewish mother or those who have converted through an Orthodox conversion.

Protests Against the Orthodox Monopoly

There have been protests in Israel and abroad against the Orthodox monopoly over Jewish practice. In July 2018, Conservative Rabbi Dov Haiyun was detained by the Israel Police for conducting a non-Orthodox wedding. This incident highlighted an obscure law that threatens non-Orthodox rabbis with arrest if they perform traditional Jewish marriages outside the authority of the Chief Rabbinate.

The arrest of Rabbi Haiyun ignited a wave of protest against the Orthodox monopoly, with Israelis and Jews worldwide expressing disappointment and anger at the discrimination between Jews in Israel. In response to the protests, Israel's attorney general ordered the police to stop investigating Haiyun.

High Court Rulings

The High Court of Justice has also played a role in challenging the Orthodox monopoly. In April 2023, the High Court ruled that non-Jewish children being adopted in Israel must not be forced to undergo an Orthodox conversion and can be raised by non-Orthodox Jewish parents. This ruling came after a 20-year legal battle by the Israel Movement for Reform and Progressive Judaism.

Additionally, in 2016, Israel's Supreme Court ruled that the state must allow Jews who converted in private Orthodox courts in Israel to gain citizenship. Reform and Conservative groups have petitioned the court to extend this right to their converts as well.

Impact on Diaspora Jews

The role of a rabbi in a Jewish wedding

Firstly, the rabbi ensures that all the "paperwork", including the ketubah (marriage contract), is in order. The ketubah details the groom's obligations to the bride, such as providing food, clothing, and marital relations. The rabbi also ensures that the marriage witnesses meet all halachic criteria and that all other parts of the ceremony conform to halachic standards.

Secondly, the rabbi recites a blessing on behalf of the groom, which is traditionally done before the groom places a ring on the bride's finger. The rabbi performs this task because the groom is likely to be too nervous to properly pronounce the blessing.

The rabbi's presence at a Jewish wedding is necessary for the marriage to be universally accepted by the Orthodox world, including the Israeli rabbinate. However, it is possible for a non-rabbi to officiate the wedding as an MC, with the rabbi present to ensure everything is done according to Jewish law.

The legality of a Jewish wedding without a rabbi

According to the Talmud, the laws of marriage are complex, and an error can be very serious. Therefore, the presence of a rabbi who is an expert and experienced with these laws is often sought. However, it is not strictly necessary for a rabbi to be present at a Jewish wedding.

In Israel, a rabbi must be present for the marriage to be recognised by the state. The law states that any traditional Jewish marriage performed outside the authority of the Chief Rabbinate, the state-sanctioned body dominated by haredi Orthodox rabbis, will not be recognised. This includes all Conservative and Reform marriages.

In the United States, a rabbi does not need to be present for the marriage to be legally recognised. However, a religious or civil official is required under American civil law.

A Jewish wedding has two distinct stages: kiddushin (betrothal) and nissuin (full-fledged marriage). The first stage, kiddushin, is when the woman becomes prohibited to all other men, requiring a religious divorce to dissolve the union. The second stage, nissuin, permits the couple to each other.

During the kiddushin, the groom gives the bride a ring or another object of value, and says: "Be sanctified (mekudeshet) to me with this ring in accordance with the law of Moses and Israel." According to Jewish law, this is the central moment of the wedding, and the couple is now married.

For the nissuin, the bride and groom stand beneath the chuppah (wedding canopy) and recite seven blessings in the presence of a minyan (a prayer quorum of 10 adult Jewish men). The couple then retires to a private room for yichud (togetherness or seclusion), which completes the wedding ceremony.

While a rabbi is not strictly necessary for a Jewish wedding, their presence can ensure that everything is done correctly, and they will be the signatory to the marriage certificate, ensuring that it is universally accepted.

The consequences of a rabbi performing a non-sanctioned wedding

In Israel, performing a non-sanctioned wedding can result in the rabbi being detained and interrogated by the police. This was the case for Rabbi Dov Haiyun, who was detained for conducting a non-Orthodox wedding outside the authority of the country's ultra-Orthodox Chief Rabbinate. While he was eventually released without being questioned, his experience sparked protests in Israel and abroad, highlighting an obscure law that threatens non-Orthodox rabbis with arrest.

Furthermore, the rabbi's standing in the religious community may be impacted. They may face censure or criticism from other rabbis and Jewish organizations, especially if the wedding goes against the tenets of Orthodox Judaism. The rabbi's ability to perform future weddings or conduct other religious ceremonies may also be affected, as their reputation and authority could be questioned.

Additionally, the couple getting married may face consequences, as they could also be subject to prosecution under Israeli law. Their marriage may not be recognized by the state, which can have legal and practical implications for their union.

Overall, the consequences of a rabbi performing a non-sanctioned wedding can vary but can include legal repercussions, religious censure, and a potential impact on the couple's marital status and recognition.

Frequently asked questions