Wedding Cake Top: When To Eat And Celebrate

Wedding cake traditions have evolved over the years, but one custom that has stood the test of time is the practice of saving the top tier of the cake to eat on your first anniversary. This tradition dates back to the 19th century when couples would eat the top layer of their cake on their first child's christening day, which was expected to occur within the first year of marriage. Over time, as the birth of the first child became less closely tied to the wedding date, the tradition shifted to eating the top tier of the cake on the couple's first anniversary instead. Today, this practice is still followed by 50% of newlyweds, although some choose to skip it due to concerns about the cake's taste and texture after being frozen for a year.

The tradition of saving the top tier of a wedding cake dates back to the 19th century

The tradition of saving the top tier of a wedding cake is a long-standing one, dating back to the 19th century. While the practice has evolved over time, its underlying symbolism remains rooted in the idea of celebrating and commemorating a couple's special day, along with their commitment to each other.

In the 19th century, it was customary for families to make large, decorative cakes for the christening of their first child. As wedding cakes became more elaborate, the christening cake took on less significance. With the popularity of three-tier cakes, there was often an extra tier left over, which couples would save for their first child's christening, as it was assumed that the birth would occur within the first year of marriage. Over time, as the time between the wedding and the birth of the first child increased, the two events became disassociated.

The tradition evolved, and today, couples often save the top tier of their wedding cake to eat on their one-year wedding anniversary. This practice is considered a way to bring good luck to the marriage and is a symbol of the couple's commitment to each other. The cake serves as a reminder of their special day and the promises they made to each other.

To preserve the top tier of the wedding cake for their anniversary, couples need to plan and prep the cake before placing it in the freezer. It is recommended to wrap the cake tightly in several layers of cling film and then place it in an airtight container for additional protection. Discussing preservation methods with the baker is also advisable, as certain types of cakes are more suitable for freezing than others.

While some couples choose to follow this tradition, others may opt to skip it due to concerns about the cake's taste and texture after being frozen for a year. As an alternative, couples can request their baker to recreate a fresh version of the top tier or a miniature replica of their wedding cake to enjoy on their anniversary.

The top tier was originally eaten at the christening of the couple's first child

The top tier of the wedding cake was originally eaten at the christening of the couple's first child. This tradition dates back to the 19th century when it was customary for families to bake large, decorative cakes to celebrate the christening of a child. As wedding cakes became more elaborate, the christening cake was replaced by the top tier of the wedding cake, which was saved for the christening ceremony. It was assumed that the first child would be born within the first year of marriage, so the cake was eaten before the one-year mark. Some couples believed that eating the top tier of the cake at their child's christening brought good luck. Others believed that cutting the cake before the one-year mark brought bad luck.

Over time, the tradition evolved, and the top tier of the wedding cake began to be eaten on the couple's first anniversary instead of at the christening. This may be because the birth of the first child started to happen further from the wedding date, disassociating the two events. Today, about 50% of newlyweds still honour the tradition of preserving the top tier of their wedding cake, most commonly eating it on their first anniversary.

However, eating year-old cake can be unappealing, as the flavour and texture may not hold up after being frozen for so long. Some couples choose to bypass this custom or alter it by ordering a fresh replica of their wedding cake top or opting for alternative desserts such as cupcakes or pies. Others may choose to skip the cake altogether.

For those who still want to preserve the top tier of their wedding cake, there are some tips and tricks to ensure better preservation during its long stay in the freezer. It is recommended to put the cake in the freezer uncovered until it is firm, then remove it and wrap the cake twice with plastic wrap. Put the wrapped cake in a cake box, seal the corners and edges with tape, and cover the entire box with aluminium foil before storing it back in the freezer.

The tradition evolved to eating the top tier on the couple's first wedding anniversary

The tradition of eating the top tier of a wedding cake on a couple's first wedding anniversary is steeped in superstition and has evolved over time. While the practice of preserving the top tier of a wedding cake dates back hundreds of years, the original custom was to eat the cake on the christening day of the couple's first child, which was anticipated to occur within the first year of marriage. As the birth of the first child increasingly happened further from the wedding date, the tradition evolved, and today, many couples choose to save the top tier of their wedding cake to be eaten on their first wedding anniversary.

This evolution in tradition is thought to have occurred in the 19th century when three-tier cakes became popular, often leaving the top tier untouched. Couples would then save this tier to celebrate the christening of their first child. Over time, as the two events became disassociated, the top tier of the wedding cake took on a new significance, with couples eating it on their one-year anniversary for good luck in their marriage.

Today, this tradition is still commonly practised, particularly in the northern half of the United States and by couples in the South. Many newlyweds freeze the top tier of their wedding cake, intending to eat it on their first anniversary. However, some couples choose to bypass this custom due to concerns about the cake's flavour and texture after a year in the freezer. Instead, they may opt for alternatives such as having the baker recreate a fresh version of the top tier or choosing a different type of dessert altogether.

For those who wish to honour the tradition of eating the top tier of their wedding cake on their first anniversary, there are several methods for optimal preservation. Initially, the cake should be placed in the freezer uncovered until firm. Then, it is wrapped twice in plastic wrap and sealed inside a cake box, with corners and edges taped. Finally, the entire box is covered in aluminium foil and stored in the freezer until the first anniversary arrives.

Some believe the practice brings good luck

The tradition of saving the top tier of a wedding cake to eat on your first anniversary is believed to bring good luck to some. This custom dates back to the 19th century when couples would eat the top layer of their cake on their first child's christening day, which was expected to occur within the first year of marriage. Over time, as the birth of the first child became less closely tied to the wedding date, the tradition evolved, and couples began to associate eating the top tier of their wedding cake with their one-year anniversary instead.

The practice of preserving the top tier of a wedding cake is steeped in superstition. While some believe that it brings good luck, others consider it bad luck to cut into the top tier of the cake before the one-year mark. This notion persists today, and around half of newlyweds still honour the tradition.

The type of cake that was popular in the 19th century when this tradition began was typically a very dense fruit cake full of bourbon and wine. As the year went on, the fruit continued to ferment, and the cake remained palatable. However, today's wedding cakes are not designed to be stored for long periods, and most people find that their cake doesn't taste very good after a year in the freezer.

Despite the potential for a less-than-appetising cake, some couples still choose to honour the tradition for the symbolism and sentimentality it holds. For those who want to maintain the custom but don't want to sacrifice taste, there are alternatives, such as having the baker recreate a fresh version of the top tier for the one-year anniversary.

Others believe cutting the top tier before the one-year mark is bad luck

The tradition of saving the top tier of the wedding cake to be eaten on the first anniversary is believed to bring good luck to the couple. However, some people believe that cutting the top tier before the one-year mark is bad luck. This superstition has persisted, even though the practice of saving the top tier has evolved over time.

In the 19th century, when this tradition originated, couples would eat the top layer of their wedding cake on their first child's christening day, which was expected to occur within the first year of marriage. As the timing of the first child's birth became less closely tied to the wedding date, the tradition evolved, and couples began to associate eating the top tier with their first anniversary instead.

Today, about 50% of newlyweds still observe this custom, but many choose to alter it. Some couples opt for a freshly baked replica of their original cake to commemorate their anniversary, while others skip the cake altogether in favour of other treats.

Regardless of the variation, the underlying sentiment remains: celebrating and honouring the first year of marriage. Whether it's considered good luck, bad luck, or simply a meaningful ritual, the tradition of saving the top tier of the wedding cake continues to hold significance for many couples.

Frequently asked questions