My Big Fat American Gypsy Wedding": Real Or Fake

My Big Fat American Gypsy Wedding is a reality TV show that claims to give viewers an insight into the marriage customs of Romani-Americans. However, the show has been criticised for being staged and misleading. One of the main criticisms is that it groups Travellers and Roma together, despite their cultural differences. The show has also been accused of glorifying negative stereotypes, omitting major cultural details, and not accurately representing the Romani and Traveller communities. In 2014, a Facebook post by a participant in Season 1 revealed that producers hired actors and faked weddings to fit their specific narrative.

The show is staged, including fake weddings and hired actors

The TLC reality show "My Big Fat American Gypsy Wedding" has been accused of staging scenes, including fake weddings and hiring actors.

In a 2014 Facebook post, season one participant Priscilla Kelly revealed that producers encouraged her to get married for the show, saying: "it didn't matter who it was, it didn't have to be legal, just so they had something to put on TV".

The show has also been criticised for misrepresenting the Romani and Traveller communities, omitting major cultural details, and portraying offensive stereotypes. For example, the show has been accused of portraying Romani and Traveller women as "nothing but slaves to men, only good for cooking and cleaning, and always being available to open our legs to them".

In addition, the show has been criticised for grouping Travellers and Roma together, despite their distinct cultural differences. While Travellers are ethnic Irish, Roma originated from Eastern Europe and historically, from India. The show has also been criticised for its lack of historical and political context about the place of these communities in the UK and Europe.

The show's portrayal of these communities as wealthy, with disposable income to spend on lavish weddings and parties, has also been called into question. In reality, many Roma live in dire poverty, often in shantytowns outside major cities in Central and Eastern Europe.

The show's producers have been accused of creating a "work of fiction" that strengthens stereotypes and ignorance towards the Romani and Traveller communities.

The show misrepresents Romani and Traveller communities

My Big Fat American Gypsy Wedding has been criticised for misrepresenting the Romani and Traveller communities. The show has been accused of cultivating racist stereotypes, with a spokesman for Romani Gypsies, Billy Welch, stating: "They called the show Big Fat Gypsy Wedding and you've yet to see a Romani Gypsy in it".

The show has been criticised for grouping Travellers and Roma together, despite significant differences between the two cultures. Travellers are ethnic Irish, while the Roma originated in Eastern Europe and India. By failing to differentiate between the two, the show offers an overly simplistic view of these distinct cultures. Furthermore, the show has been criticised for omitting major cultural details and providing little historical or political context about their place in the United Kingdom and Europe.

The Romani Gypsy community has also criticised the series for misrepresenting the ethnic minority with non-Romani characters posing as "Gypsy". Many Roma find the show offensive, with one male Roma, Pip, stating: "We suffer from discrimination on a daily basis and our human rights have historically been violated, yet you deem it acceptable to broadcast a misleading 'documentary' that has been made, not to raise awareness of our plight, but for entertainment. We are not a joke, we are human beings and your work of fiction is only strengthening stereotypes and ignorance".

The show has also been criticised for the way it portrays women, with one female Traveller, Helen, in her twenties, stating: "The way us women come across in the programme is a disgrace. It shows us as nothing but slaves to the men, only good for cooking and cleaning, and always being available to open our legs to them. We don't want that for our daughters".

The show omits major cultural details

The show "My Big Fat American Gypsy Wedding" has been criticised for omitting major cultural details and misrepresenting the Romani-American community.

The series, which follows different traveller groups in the Southern United States, has been accused of cultivating racist stereotypes and presenting a “wildly misleading” portrayal of Romani culture.

Billy Welch, a spokesman for Romani Gypsies, criticised the show for focusing exclusively on Irish Travellers and their traditions in its first three episodes, despite the show's title. He said:

> "They called the show Big Fat Gypsy Wedding and you've yet to see a Romani Gypsy in it."

Jane Jackson of the Rural Media Company also commented on the show's lack of cultural accuracy:

> "It's posing as a documentary, the voiceover is saying we're going to let you into the secrets of the traveller community – and it [sic] just not true. It might be true of the particular families in front of the camera, but it's not generally true. They're made to look totally feckless, not really to be taken seriously as an ethnic group."

The show has also been criticised for presenting a one-sided view of Romani-American culture, with some arguing that it focuses solely on the most extreme and controversial aspects of the community.

The show's participants are often wealthy, which is not representative of the wider community

The TLC reality show *My Big Fat American Gypsy Wedding* has been criticised for misrepresenting the Romani and Traveller communities by portraying them as wealthy. The show, which focuses on the Romanis and Irish Travellers, two ethnic nomadic communities, has been accused of glorifying negative stereotypes.

The show's participants are often portrayed as wealthy, with disposable income to spend on lavish parties and over-the-top weddings. However, this is not representative of the wider Romani and Traveller communities, who often face dire poverty and social exclusion. For example, Roma Pip, a male Roma, pointed out that the show failed to include any Gypsy or Traveller designers and that the clothing traditionally worn by these communities is far more interesting than what was portrayed on the show.

In reality, many Roma live in shantytowns outside major cities in Central and Eastern Europe, and face high unemployment rates and widespread dependence on government benefits. Additionally, Irish Travellers often live in trailers that are not connected to water pipes, and their toilets, bathrooms, and cooking facilities are in a small, unheated shed across the yard.

The show's portrayal of wealth and extravagance among the Romani and Traveller communities is not only inaccurate but also offensive to many members of these communities. For example, Roma Pip wrote in an open letter to the show's producers that "we suffer from discrimination on a daily basis and our human rights have historically been violated, yet you deem it acceptable to broadcast a misleading 'documentary' that has been made, not to raise awareness of our plight, but for entertainment." Similarly, Helen, a female Traveller in her twenties, told *The Guardian*, "The way us women come across in the programme is a disgrace. It shows us as nothing but slaves to the men, only good for cooking and cleaning, and always being available to open our legs to them. We don't want that for our daughters."

The show has had a negative impact on the Traveller and Roma communities

The show "My Big Fat American Gypsy Wedding" has been criticised for its negative impact on the Traveller and Roma communities. The series has been accused of cultivating racist stereotypes and misrepresenting the Romani-American community.

The Romani Gypsy community has criticised the series for misrepresenting the ethnic minority with non-Romani characters posing as "Gypsy". Billy Welch, a spokesman for Romani Gypsies, stated: "They called the show Big Fat Gypsy Wedding and you've yet to see a Romani Gypsy in it." The series has also faced allegations of racism in its advertising and causing racially motivated bullying.

The show has been accused of perpetuating negative stereotypes about Romani-Americans and promoting a misleading portrayal of their culture and traditions. The series often focuses on over-the-top events, such as extravagant weddings and birthday parties, and portrays a conservative and traditional lifestyle that may not accurately represent the diverse experiences of Romani-Americans.

The series has also been criticised for its portrayal of gender roles within the Romani-American community. The show depicts a world where men work, while women stay at home, drop out of school at a young age, and marry early. This portrayal of strict gender norms may contribute to a negative perception of Romani-American women as being subservient or lacking agency.

The impact of the show on the Traveller and Roma communities extends beyond its content. The series has sparked racially motivated bullying and contributed to a negative perception of these communities among the public. The show's focus on extravagant celebrations and conservative social norms may lead viewers to assume that all Romani-Americans adhere to these traditions, fostering a sense of "otherness" and promoting cultural misunderstandings.

While the show claims to offer an unbiased portrayal of Romani-American culture, its impact suggests otherwise. "My Big Fat American Gypsy Wedding" has contributed to a negative and misleading perception of the Traveller and Roma communities, fostering stereotypes and misunderstandings that have real-world consequences for these ethnic minorities.

Frequently asked questions