Icing A Rustic Wedding Cake: Buttercream Basics

Creating a rustic buttercream wedding cake is an art form. It requires a strategic approach to achieve the perfect home-made look without appearing messy. The key to success is in the technique used to apply the buttercream icing. This guide will take you through the steps to create a beautiful rustic buttercream wedding cake, from choosing the right type of buttercream to adding the perfect finishing touches.

How to create a semi-smooth finish

To create a semi-smooth finish on a rustic buttercream wedding cake, start by applying a crumb coat to seal the sponge and prevent crumbs from getting into the icing. Then, use a combination of quick swipes, C-shapes, and S-shapes with an angled icing spatula to create rustic swirls all over the sides of the cake. Remember, the goal is a perfectly imperfect look, so don't overthink it. If you're not satisfied with a particular area, you can always re-texture it. Once you're happy with the texture on the sides, continue the same techniques on the top of the cake until it's filled in with rustic swirls. Finish off by pulling any extra icing towards the centre of the cake.

How to create rustic swirls

To create rustic swirls on a buttercream wedding cake, you should start by frosting the cake with a semi-smooth finish. This will ensure that there is an even layer of icing on all sides of the cake. You can then use an angled icing spatula to create the rustic texture. Swipe the spatula through the buttercream, using quick swipes, C-shapes and S-shapes to create the swirls. You can re-texture any areas that you are not satisfied with.

When you are happy with the texture on the sides of the cake, you can use the same technique on the top of the cake. Remember, you are aiming for a "perfectly imperfect" look, so try not to overthink it!

If you want to create ridges in your buttercream, you can use the comb side of an icing smoother on a freshly frosted cake. Spin the turntable while keeping the comb still. If the ridges start to clump, make sure your icing is not too thick and clean the comb between spins.

How to create ridges

Creating ridges on a rustic buttercream wedding cake is a simple process that can be achieved through a few different methods. Firstly, it is important to start with a semi-smooth finish to ensure an even layer of icing on all sides of the cake. This will provide a good base for creating the rustic texture.

One method to create ridges is to use the comb side of an icing smoother. Immediately after frosting the cake, gently touch the teeth of the comb to the smoothly iced surface. Hold the rigid edge perpendicular to the turntable and spin the turntable while keeping the comb still. This will create defined ridges on the cake. If the ridges start to clump or become undefined, ensure that your icing is not too thick and clean the comb between spins.

Another technique to create ridges is to use an angled icing spatula. Swipe the spatula through the buttercream to create quick swipes, C-shapes, and S-shapes for rustic swirls. This method allows for more freedom and creativity, as you can re-texture areas that you are not satisfied with.

Remember, the goal is to achieve a perfectly imperfect, rustic look. So, don't overthink it and have fun with the process!

How to create stripes

To create stripes on a rustic buttercream wedding cake, you'll first want to ensure you have a semi-smooth finish. This will ensure an even layer of icing on all sides of the cake, giving it a rustic and "home-made" look without appearing messy.

Once you have your base layer of icing, you can begin to create the stripes. One method is to use the comb side of an icing smoother to create ridges in the freshly frosted cake. Hold the rigid edge of the comb perpendicular to the turntable and gently touch the teeth to the icing. Spin the turntable while keeping the comb still, and if the ridges start to clump, ensure your icing isn't too thick and clean the comb between spins.

To create filled-in stripes, take buttercream of a different colour and carefully pipe it between the ridges. You can then use an icing smoother to remove a layer of buttercream around the sides, revealing the stripes.

Alternatively, you can create swirls and stripes by using quick swipes, C-shapes, and S-shapes with your angled icing spatula immediately after frosting the cake. This will give your cake a perfectly imperfect, rustic look.

How to choose the right type of buttercream

To create a rustic buttercream wedding cake, you should start with a semi-smooth finish to ensure an even layer of icing on all sides of the cake. You can then use an angled icing spatula to create a rustic texture all over the sides of the cake. You can use quick swipes, C-shapes and S-shapes to create rustic swirls.

When choosing the right type of buttercream, you should consider the flavour, texture, ingredients, modifications and difficulty. There are two main groups of buttercream: simple buttercreams and true buttercreams. True buttercreams require more steps and time, but they deliver melt-in-your-mouth textures and ultra-smooth, professional decorating results. Simple buttercreams, such as American buttercream, are easier to make and are great for piping decorations as they hold their shape. However, they have a mildly granular texture due to the undissolved powdered sugar. You can also make German buttercream, which uses a basic custard made with egg yolks and milk, or Swiss or Italian meringue buttercream, which tend to be silkier and smoother.

Frequently asked questions