Plain Or Diamond: Your Wedding Band, Your Choice

Choosing a wedding band is a big decision, after all, you'll be wearing it for the rest of your life. While some people prefer the timeless, classic, and understated look of a plain band, others may opt for the sparkle and glamour of a diamond band.

A plain band is a more traditional choice, often favoured for its simplicity and elegance. It pairs beautifully with a diamond engagement ring, allowing the latter to stand out and shine. Plain bands are also more practical for those with active lifestyles or jobs that are rough on the hands, as they are easier to maintain and less likely to get damaged.

On the other hand, diamond wedding bands offer a wider range of styles and customisation options. They can make a unique statement and add a touch of sparkle to your finger. However, they are more expensive and require more maintenance than plain bands.

Ultimately, the choice between a plain or diamond wedding band depends on personal preferences and lifestyle considerations.

Practicality: plain bands are more practical for manual jobs

When it comes to practicality, plain wedding bands are the best option for those in manual jobs. They are much easier to keep clean, so they are ideal for those who handle raw materials or work in manual or medical environments. The smooth surface of a plain band means there is less chance of dirt or residue getting stuck on the ring. This is especially important for those in the medical field, as it prevents the build-up of bacteria.

Another benefit of plain bands is that they can be easily reworked or reshaped if they get bent. This is a huge advantage for those who work with their hands, such as mechanics, painters, or construction workers, or anyone in a physically demanding profession. Plain bands are also a good choice for those who want to avoid their rings getting snagged on things.

Additionally, plain wedding bands are typically easier to refinish than diamond bands. Most bench jewellers can refinish plain bands to keep them looking polished and new. This process is particularly important for white gold rings, which may require re-rhodium plating to maintain their ultra-white colour. While refinishing can be expensive and time-consuming, it will leave your ring looking brand new.

Overall, plain wedding bands are a more practical choice for those in manual jobs due to their ease of cleaning, reworking, and refinishing. They are also more comfortable for those who work with their hands, as they are less likely to snag or cause discomfort.

Maintenance: diamond bands require more cleaning and maintenance

When it comes to wedding bands, there are many different styles to choose from. One of the most important considerations is whether to go for a plain band or one with diamonds. While diamond wedding bands offer a subtle sparkle that can complement your engagement ring, they do require more maintenance and cleaning than a plain band.

Diamond wedding bands are more high-maintenance than plain bands. They require regular cleaning to keep them in optimal condition and prevent a buildup of oil, debris, and cosmetic residue, which can cause skin irritation, discolouration, and scratching. It is recommended that diamond rings are professionally cleaned at least once a year, and that at-home cleanings are performed in between these professional services.

There are several methods for cleaning diamond rings at home. One common method is to soak the ring in warm water mixed with a degreasing solution, such as dish soap, shampoo, or body wash. It is important to avoid using harsh chemicals such as bleach, chlorine, and acetone, as these can damage the ring. After soaking, the ring should be scrubbed with a soft-bristled toothbrush to remove any remaining dirt, paying particular attention to the back of the diamond and crevices where grime builds up. The ring should then be rinsed thoroughly and allowed to air dry.

Another option for at-home cleaning is to use specialised jewellery cleaning products, such as liquids, cloths, or ultrasonic cleaners. However, it is important to choose products that do not contain chemicals or abrasive components, as these can damage the ring. Additionally, ultrasonic cleaners should be used with caution, as the vigorous movement can cause stones to become loose and fall out.

While diamond wedding bands may require more maintenance and cleaning, this extra care can help to ensure that your ring remains in optimal condition, sparkling beautifully alongside your engagement ring.

Cost: diamond bands are more expensive

When it comes to choosing a wedding band, one of the most important considerations is cost. Diamond wedding bands are significantly more expensive than plain bands, and this increased cost is due to the inclusion of diamonds and other stones. The price of a diamond band can be further influenced by the number and size of the diamonds, as well as the cut and setting.

The additional diamonds and stones in a diamond wedding band can also lead to higher maintenance costs. Diamonds can attract residue build-up underneath, and if not cleaned regularly, they can loosen and even fall out. This means that diamond bands require more frequent cleaning and maintenance compared to plain bands, which can be easily refinished by most jewellers.

The higher cost of diamond wedding bands may also limit your options when it comes to the type of metal used. While plain bands are typically available in a variety of metals, including white, rose, and yellow gold, as well as titanium and platinum, diamond bands may be restricted to certain metals that complement the diamonds. This limited selection can further increase the cost of diamond bands.

In addition to the financial cost, diamond wedding bands may also come with an opportunity cost. If you plan to wear both your engagement ring and wedding band, a diamond band could detract from the sparkle of your engagement ring. On the other hand, a plain band will complement your engagement ring without taking away from its shine.

When making your decision, it is important to consider your budget and the overall look you want to achieve. Diamond bands offer more sparkle and glamour, but they come at a higher cost. Plain bands, on the other hand, provide a classic and elegant alternative that is more affordable and allows your engagement ring to take centre stage.

Style: diamond bands offer more styles and cuts

Diamond wedding bands offer a wide variety of styles and cuts to suit every taste and budget. From dainty to extravagant, there is a diamond wedding band to match any preference.

For those who want a more subtle sparkle, a diamond band with tiny diamonds can be a perfect choice. This adds a hint of glamour without being overpowering. On the other hand, if you're looking for something with more dazzle, you can opt for a pavé setting, which has a more encrusted look. Pavé bands are ideal for brides who want the sparkle of diamonds without the appearance of high-set prongs.

Another style to consider is the eternity band, which features diamonds around the entire perimeter of the ring. Within this style, there are options such as the shared prong setting, where diamonds sit next to each other and are secured by a 'u'-shaped prong, maximising the sparkle. Or, for a more cohesive look, a channel-set eternity band has diamonds laid side by side within a metal channel. Eternity bands can be customised with various diamond cuts, from round brilliant to cushion or emerald, allowing you to create a unique design.

If you're looking for something truly unique, you could opt for a contemporary two-tone band with wavy diamond pavé or a fluid tiara shape with multi-shaped diamonds in various sizes. Diamond bands also come in a range of metals, including platinum, yellow gold, white gold, and rose gold, allowing you to choose the metal that best complements your style and skin tone.

With so many styles, cuts, and settings available, diamond wedding bands offer endless possibilities to create a ring that perfectly symbolises your love and commitment.

Expression: plain bands may not allow for self-expression

When it comes to wedding bands, plain rings are the traditional choice. They are simple, elegant, and classic, providing the perfect contrast to a more elaborate engagement ring. However, some people may feel that plain bands do not allow for self-expression. Here are some reasons why someone might feel this way:

Lack of Self-Expression Through Design

Plain wedding bands are typically chosen for their simplicity and understated appearance. While this can be appealing to those who value minimalism and refinement, others may see it as a lack of opportunity for self-expression. With fewer design options compared to diamond bands, plain bands may not offer the same level of customisation and individuality that some people desire.

Inadequate Boldness or Uniqueness

Those who wish to make a bold statement with their wedding band may find that a plain band falls short of their expectations. Plain bands are often chosen for their timeless and classic appeal, but this can also be seen as a lack of uniqueness or modern flair. If someone is seeking a ring that stands out and makes a statement about their personality, a plain band might not be their first choice.

Limited Opportunities for Customisation

Although plain bands can be customised to a certain extent, such as through engraving or choosing different metals and widths, some individuals may crave more opportunities for personalisation. Diamond bands offer a wider range of options in terms of diamond cuts, settings, and overall styles, allowing for a more bespoke and tailored look.

Inability to Showcase Individuality

For some, a wedding band is not just a symbol of commitment but also an expression of their unique personality and style. A plain band, with its simplicity and understated design, may not provide the same level of individuality that someone might desire. Diamond bands, with their sparkle and variety, can offer a way to showcase one's taste and preferences more distinctly.

Conformity to Traditional Norms

In some cases, individuals may view plain wedding bands as overly traditional or conforming to societal norms. While some appreciate the classic and timeless appeal of a plain band, others may seek to express their individuality by deviating from traditional choices. Diamond bands or alternative styles can provide a way to break free from conventional expectations and embrace a more contemporary or unconventional look.

While plain wedding bands have their advantages, such as ease of refinishing, durability, and timeless elegance, they may not offer the same level of self-expression as diamond bands or more ornate styles. Ultimately, the choice of a wedding band is a personal decision, and individuals should select a ring that aligns with their values, tastes, and desire for self-expression.

Frequently asked questions