Priests Performing Weddings: Beyond Church Walls

Whether a priest can perform a wedding outside of a church depends on the couple's religious affiliation, the priest's standing with the church, and the location of the wedding. In the Catholic Church, marriage is considered a sacrament and is therefore meant to be held in a church. However, there are rare exceptions where a bishop may grant authorization for a wedding to be held elsewhere, usually for political, cultural, or safety reasons. In the United States, outdoor Catholic weddings are permitted in two dioceses: Montana and Baltimore. In these cases, the priest must be from the Archdiocese of Baltimore or Montana, and the couple must include at least one confirmed Catholic. Some couples opt for two ceremonies: a simple rite of marriage inside a church followed by a larger renewal of vows at their chosen venue.

The Catholic Church's stance on outdoor weddings

The Catholic Church has strict rules about where weddings can take place. According to the Code of Canon Law, "Marriages are to be celebrated in a parish where either of the contracting parties has a domicile… With the permission of the proper ordinary or proper pastor, marriages can be celebrated elsewhere." (Canon 1115). In practice, however, it is extremely difficult to obtain permission to marry outside of a Catholic church. Bishops are reluctant to grant such dispensations, and usually only do so in exceptional circumstances, such as serious illness or injury.

Some couples choose to have two ceremonies: a small Catholic wedding in a church, followed by a larger symbolic ceremony in their desired outdoor location. In some cases, a priest may be willing to give a blessing at an outdoor ceremony, but this would not count as a sacrament.

There are a couple of exceptions to the rule. Firstly, if one partner is not baptised, the marriage can take place outside of a church, as long as it is still performed by a priest. Secondly, outdoor Catholic weddings are now allowed in two dioceses in the US: Montana and Baltimore. In these cases, one partner must be a confirmed Catholic and reside within the Archdiocese, and the couple must go through the Church's marriage preparation.

Overall, the Catholic Church's stance on outdoor weddings is conservative, and it remains very difficult to obtain permission to marry outside of a church.

Exceptions to the rule

The Catholic Church has strict rules about where weddings can take place, with marriages traditionally being performed inside a Catholic church. However, there are some exceptions to this rule, and outdoor weddings can be allowed in certain circumstances.

Firstly, the Code of Canon Law states that "with the permission of the proper ordinary or proper pastor, marriages can be celebrated elsewhere." However, it is very difficult to obtain such permission from the local bishop, who must authorise the change of venue. Bishops are generally reluctant to grant this authorisation due to the sacred nature of Catholic weddings. They may consider political, cultural, or safety reasons as valid exceptions, such as in the case of structural damage to the church building.

Another exception is when one partner is not baptised. In these cases, the marriage is still considered valid, and a priest may be willing to perform the ceremony outside of a church to avoid making either side uncomfortable with being in the other's place of worship. This exception was granted by the Pope in the 1970s.

In the United States, outdoor Catholic weddings are permitted in two dioceses: Montana and Baltimore. The Archdiocese of Baltimore has allowed priests or deacons to officiate weddings in "another suitable place", with nearly a third of these being outdoor locales. However, this policy is not widely promoted, and there are still certain venues that are not allowed, such as bars, clubs, and boats.

In some cases, couples may opt for a simple rite of ceremony inside a church, followed by a larger "renewal of vows" at their chosen destination. Alternatively, they may choose to have two ceremonies, one small Catholic church ceremony and a separate "symbolic" outdoor ceremony to accommodate family and friends.

While these exceptions exist, it is important to note that they are generally rare and require special permission or circumstances. The Catholic Church strongly prefers weddings to be held within a church to maintain the sacredness of the occasion.

The process of obtaining a dispensation

• Understanding the Church's Position: It is important to recognize that the Catholic Church considers a wedding ceremony to have spiritual, theological, and ecclesiastical implications. The Church maintains that a Catholic wedding is a sacred ritual through which the Sacrament of Marriage is conferred. Therefore, the Church generally requires that the ceremony be held within a Catholic parish to uphold the sanctity of the occasion.
• Code of Canon Law: According to Canon 1115 of the Code of Canon Law, "Marriages are to be celebrated in a parish where either of the contracting parties has a domicile... With the permission of the proper ordinary or proper pastor, marriages can be celebrated elsewhere." This means that, in certain circumstances, a bishop's authorization may be obtained to hold the wedding outside of a Catholic church.
• Obtaining Authorization: While the Code of Canon Law allows for the possibility of celebrating weddings elsewhere, obtaining authorization from the local bishop is extremely difficult. Bishops are generally reluctant to grant such authorizations due to their concern for maintaining the sanctity and sacredness of the occasion. They typically reserve these authorizations for exceptional cases, such as political, cultural, or safety reasons. For example, if the intended church building has been damaged by a natural disaster.
• Initiating the Process: If you believe you have a valid reason for requesting a dispensation, the first step is to consult with your local priest or the priest who will be performing the ceremony. They will be able to guide you through the specific procedures and requirements in your diocese. It is important to start this conversation early in your wedding planning process, as obtaining a dispensation can be time-consuming.
• Providing Justification: When requesting a dispensation, you will need to provide a compelling justification for holding the wedding outside of a Catholic church. The bishop will carefully consider your circumstances before making a decision. Remember that dispensations are typically granted only in very rare and exceptional cases.
• Timing and Logistics: The process of obtaining a dispensation can take a significant amount of time, so it is crucial to begin the process early. In some cases, it may take up to a year or more to receive a decision. Be prepared to provide detailed information about your wedding plans, including the intended location and date, as well as any extenuating circumstances that support your request.
• Alternative Options: If obtaining a dispensation proves challenging, there are alternative options you can consider. One option is to have a small ceremony inside a Catholic church to fulfill the religious requirements and then hold a larger, symbolic ceremony at your desired outdoor location. Another option is to have a priest provide a blessing at your outdoor ceremony, although this would not be recognized as a sacrament.

Remember that the decision to grant a dispensation ultimately rests with the diocesan bishop, and they have the authority to approve or deny your request based on their judgment. Each diocese may have its own specific rules and requirements, so it is essential to consult with your local priest to navigate the process effectively.

The role of the local bishop

Bishops are generally very reluctant to grant authorization for outdoor weddings performed by a Catholic priest. They are cautious about maintaining the sanctity and sacredness of the sacrament of marriage, which is at the heart of a Catholic wedding ceremony. The Catholic Church considers marriage a sacred occasion, and as a result, bishops rarely approve of weddings taking place outside of a church.

However, there may be exceptional circumstances where a local bishop may grant authorization for a Catholic wedding to be held outside of a church. These circumstances include political, cultural, or safety reasons. For example, if the church building intended to host the wedding has sustained structural damage due to a natural disaster, the local bishop may permit the wedding to take place elsewhere.

It is important to note that even with the local bishop's authorization, there are still certain rules and requirements that must be followed. The couple may be required to take a marriage course authorized by the Church and go through the necessary marriage preparation. Additionally, weddings cannot take place in bars, clubs, or boats, as these venues are not considered suitable by the Church.

In very rare cases, a local bishop may grant a dispensation for a Catholic wedding to occur outside of a church. This usually occurs only under extraordinary circumstances, such as serious illness or injury, and each request is carefully evaluated.

Alternative options for couples

If you are set on having a priest perform your wedding ceremony, there are a few alternative options to consider. Firstly, it is important to note that Catholic weddings are typically required to take place within a Catholic parish or church building. However, there may be rare exceptions granted by the local bishop for unusual circumstances such as political, cultural, or safety reasons. These circumstances are highly unusual and it is almost impossible to obtain such authorization.

One option is to work with your parish priest to find a suitable location that accommodates your requests. This may involve certain compromises, as there are still rules and requirements that the priest must follow. For example, weddings cannot take place in bars, clubs, or boats. Additionally, couples can opt to have a simple rite of ceremony inside a church followed by a larger "renewal of vows" at their chosen destination.

If you are open to having two ceremonies, you can have a small Catholic church wedding followed by a larger symbolic outdoor ceremony. This option may appease older, more religious family members while still allowing you to have the celebration of your dreams. Another possibility is to have an interfaith wedding with a priest and another religious leader, such as a rabbi, which has been allowed in certain cases.

In the United States, outdoor Catholic weddings are currently allowed in two dioceses: Montana and Baltimore. In these locations, a priest or deacon can officiate a wedding in "another suitable place" with the permission of the local bishop. However, one member of the couple must be a confirmed Catholic residing in the Archdiocese of Baltimore, and the couple must go through the Church's marriage preparation.

If you are unable to find a priest willing to perform your wedding outside of a church, there are other Catholic-adjacent denominations with members who may be willing to do so. These include breakaway organizations that perform interfaith and LGBTQ "Catholic-style" weddings. While these weddings may not be recognized by the Roman Catholic Church, they can provide a similar "look and feel" that your fiancé may value.

Frequently asked questions