Catholic Wedding Attendance: Outside Church Weddings

The Catholic Church has strict rules about where weddings can take place and who can attend. For centuries, it was against canon law to marry outside of a Catholic church, but now the church is giving permission for couples to marry in alternative venues in two US cities: Montana and Baltimore. The Catholic Church does not explicitly address the question of whether or not to attend a wedding that will not result in a valid marriage, but it does address words and attitudes that encourage and confirm others in objectively wrong behaviour. The Catechism states that every word or attitude is forbidden which by flattery, adulation, or complaisance encourages and confirms another in malicious acts and perverse conduct.

Catholics can now marry outdoors in two US cities: Montana and Baltimore

For centuries, it has been against Catholic canon law to marry outside of a Catholic church. Under the Catholic Church's cannon law, marriages are meant to be performed by a Catholic priest inside either the bride or groom's parish church. However, some dioceses in the United States are starting to test the boundaries of this law.

The Archdiocese of Montana and the Archdiocese of Baltimore, Maryland, have recently ruled that a priest or deacon can now officiate a wedding in "another suitable place." This means that Catholics can now marry outdoors in these two US cities. The change in policy states that a priest can request to marry a couple in a non-church wedding as long as at least one member of the couple is Catholic, resides in the Archdiocese of Baltimore, and agrees to go through the church's marriage preparation.

While this change is a step towards accommodating the preferences of couples who want a personalized venue for their wedding, there are still some restrictions in place. Weddings cannot take place in bars, clubs, or on boats, and the location must be listed as within the individual parish territory.

It is important to note that while this change allows for greater flexibility in the location of the wedding ceremony, Catholics who choose to marry outdoors or in a non-church setting should be mindful of the theological and pastoral aspects of their decision. The Church's commitment to the couple's marriage and the sacraments that take place within the church context remain central to the Catholic faith.

In conclusion, while the change in policy opens up the possibility for Catholic couples to marry outdoors or in non-church venues in Montana and Baltimore, it is essential to respect and follow the guidelines set by the Archdiocese and the Church's teachings on marriage.

A Catholic wedding in a non-Catholic setting is valid, but Catholics may not receive communion

In the Archdiocese of Montana and the Archdiocese of Baltimore, Maryland, priests or deacons can officiate weddings in "another suitable place". In other dioceses, this may be allowed on a case-by-case basis. However, certain venues are still prohibited, such as bars, clubs, and boats.

When a Catholic marries in a non-Catholic ceremony, the Church does not recognize it as valid unless a dispensation from canonical form has been granted by the diocesan bishop. This dispensation permits the Catholic to marry in a non-Catholic ceremony, which is then considered valid in the eyes of the Church.

Catholics may attend a Catholic wedding in a non-Catholic setting with reservations. However, if there is a communion service, Catholics may not receive communion in a non-Catholic ceremony. It is important to note that Catholics should not attend a wedding that will not result in a valid marriage, as it would be considered condoning an invalid marriage.

A Catholic wedding outside the church without the bishop's dispensation is a sin

The Catholic Church has strict rules about how and where its members can marry. For centuries, it has been against canon law to marry outside of a Catholic church. However, in recent years, the clergy has started to make some changes, and now, in certain circumstances, it is possible for a Catholic couple to marry outside of a church.

The Church's Position on Catholic Weddings Outside of a Church

According to the Code of Canon Law, a Catholic wedding must be contracted "before the local [bishop], pastor, or a priest or deacon delegated by either of them, who assist, and before two witnesses" (can. 1108 §1). If a Catholic wishes to marry outside of the Church, they must obtain a dispensation from their bishop, which is usually only granted in very specific circumstances, such as serious illness or injury.

The Sin of Marrying Outside the Church Without Dispensation

Isolating the 'sin' of marrying outside the Church without dispensation is complex. The Church does not explicitly address the question of attendance at a wedding that will not result in a valid marriage. However, it does address the broader issue of words and attitudes that encourage and confirm others in objectively wrong behaviour. The Catechism states that "every word or attitude is forbidden which by flattery, adulation, or complaisance encourages and confirms another in malicious acts and perverse conduct" (CCC 2480).

Therefore, attending a wedding that will not be recognized as valid by the Church could be considered a sin if it encourages or confirms the couple in their decision to marry outside of the Church without dispensation. This is especially true if the Catholic spouse is aware that they are committing a sin by marrying outside of the Church without seeking dispensation.

Attending a Catholic Wedding Outside of the Church

There are differing opinions among Catholics about whether or not it is acceptable to attend a Catholic wedding that takes place outside of the Church. Some argue that attending such a wedding is "intrinsically evil" because the Church does not recognize the marriage as valid. Others argue that there is no official binding rule against attending an invalid wedding, and that each situation should be assessed individually.

Factors to Consider When Deciding Whether to Attend

When deciding whether or not to attend a Catholic wedding outside of the Church, it is important to consider the potential impact on the couple's relationship with the Church. If your attendance would push the Catholic spouse further away from the Church, it may be best to refrain from attending. However, if your presence could help bring them closer to the Church, it may be appropriate to attend, especially if you use the opportunity to encourage the couple to seek dispensation and blessing from the Church.

In conclusion, while it is not explicitly stated as a sin, attending a Catholic wedding outside of the church without the bishop's dispensation could be considered sinful if it encourages or confirms the couple in their decision to act against Church teachings. The decision to attend or not attend should be made with careful consideration of the potential impact on the couple's spiritual well-being.

A Catholic should not attend the wedding of a divorced person without an annulment

However, some priests with pastoral experience believe that there may be rare cases where attendance could be justified to avoid permanently cutting ties with a relative. In such cases, the principle of double effect would apply: the action of attending the wedding would be good or indifferent; the intention would be good, keeping lines of communication open; the good effect intended would not be a consequence of the evil effect; and there would be a proportionately serious reason for attending.

It is important to note that the Catholic Church does not recognise civil divorce as altering a person's status within the Church. However, for a divorced Catholic to remarry in the Church, an annulment is required. This is a declaration by a Church tribunal that the marriage fell short of at least one of the essential elements required for a binding union. The process involves submitting written testimony and a list of people familiar with the marriage, and can take anywhere from a few months to a year or more, depending on the diocese and the specific circumstances of the case.

No Catholic should attend or witness the attempted marriage of persons of the same sex

The Catholic Church teaches that marriage is a union between a man and a woman. Attending a same-sex wedding may be considered support for something that is incompatible with this truth. Therefore, no Catholic should attend or witness the attempted marriage of persons of the same sex.

The Church's teaching on marriage is based on the belief that marriage is a sacrament, a sacred ritual that confers divine grace. The Church holds that marriage is a lifelong commitment between one man and one woman, and that it is ordered toward the good of the spouses and the procreation and education of children. This belief is based on the understanding that sexual difference is necessary for a full self-gift between spouses, and that marriage is the only place where men and women can truly "speak" the language of sexual love.

While the Church teaches that individuals who identify as gay are beloved children of God, it explicitly denies its blessing for marital unions between two people of the same sex. The Church has intervened in political discourses to resist efforts to establish same-sex marriage, and has instructed Catholic legislators to actively oppose the legal recognition of same-sex unions.

When faced with the question of whether to attend a same-sex wedding, Catholics should consider the impact of their attendance on their witness to the Church's teaching on marriage. While there is no absolute canonical prohibition against attending, church leaders have advised Catholics not to attend such ceremonies. Attending a same-sex wedding could be seen as a sign of approval and could cause scandal, leading others to interpret one's presence as a justification for their actions.

In certain limited circumstances, however, there may be legitimate moral reasons for a Catholic to attend a same-sex wedding. For example, if one's absence would send the message that the person getting married is no longer welcome or wanted in the Church, it might be feasible to attend while making clear one's disagreement with the union. In such cases, it is advisable to consult a priest or spiritual director to navigate this delicate situation.

Frequently asked questions