A Wedding Ring Proposal: Is It Okay?

While some wedding traditions are made to be broken, like single-gender bridal parties, others are harder to shake, like proposing with an engagement ring. But, if you're thinking about proposing without a ring, you're not alone. Many couples are foregoing engagement rings, with some deeming the tradition antiquated, overly gendered, or an unneeded expense. If you're considering proposing with a wedding ring instead, it's important to make sure your partner is on board with the idea. You don't want the absence of an engagement ring to be the focus of your proposal. It's also a good idea to check in with your partner to gauge their general feelings about rings, as people can be surprisingly attached to engagement rings. Ultimately, it's your unique love story, and you can propose in any way, shape, or manner that speaks to that.

Propose with a different piece of jewellery

While proposing with an engagement ring is a long-standing tradition, it is not the only way to pop the question. You can propose with a different piece of jewellery that reflects your partner's style and is meaningful to them. Here are some ideas for proposing with a different piece of jewellery:

Necklace, Bracelet, or Earrings

Propose with a piece of jewellery that your partner will wear daily, such as a necklace, bracelet, or earrings. Choose something that reflects their style preferences and has a special meaning. For example, you can select a pendant with a symbol that represents your favourite place to visit as a couple.

Watch

If your partner is a watch enthusiast, propose with a timepiece that they will cherish. A watch is a practical and preferred choice for someone who doesn't wear rings or already has a ring on every finger.

Heirloom Jewellery

Proposing with a family heirloom, such as a vintage ring or necklace, is a meaningful way to show your commitment. It represents not just the joining of two people but also the joining of two families. It is a reminder of the loved ones from past generations and a piece of history that will be carried into the future.

Handmade Jewellery

Craft your own bracelet or purchase a handmade ring or necklace from a craft fair or online platform like Etsy. A handmade piece of jewellery adds a unique and personal touch to your proposal.

Birthstone Jewellery

Propose with a piece of jewellery that features your partner's birthstone or both of your birthstones. This idea showcases your commitment and symbolises the union of two individuals.

Remember, the most important aspect of a proposal is your love and commitment to your partner. You can make it unique and memorable by choosing a piece of jewellery that speaks to your relationship and reflects your partner's style and preferences.

Propose with a pet

While some people might choose to propose with a ring, there are many other ways to pop the question, such as proposing with a pet. Here are some ideas for how to include your pet in your proposal:

Your Pet as the Ring Bearer

If your pet is well-trained, you could tie the ring to their collar, or use a ring box, pillow, or pouch to hold the ring in place. This ensures the ring is secure and won't get lost.

The Puppy Proposal

Surprise your partner with a puppy and a ring on the same day. If you and your partner have been considering getting a puppy, this could be an especially memorable way to propose. It would be hard for your partner to resist this adorable double proposal!

Let Your Pet Do the Asking

Order a new dog collar, tag, bandana, or accessory with "Will you marry me?" on it. Some brands allow for personalised messages or engravings, so your pet can pop the question for you.

Dress Up Your Pet

Get your pet involved in the celebrations by dressing them up for the occasion. You could put a bow tie on your dog, or even get matching outfits for you and your pet. Prepare a nice dinner or a special picnic to go with it.

Hang a Sign

Hang a sign around your pet's neck with the proposal message on it. This is a great way to create a surprise for your partner, especially if your pet arrives wagging their tail, unsuspectingly!

Include a Photo of Your Pet

If your pet is too big or has a fierce temperament, you can still include them in your proposal by using a photo of them on a card with the proposal message. This is a cute way to involve your pet without them having to be physically present at the proposal.

Remember, when including your pet in your proposal, it's important to consider their well-being. Make sure they are not anxious, stressed, or overexcited, and have water and treats on hand to reward them. Avoid fireworks, crowds, or loud noises, and dress them in weather-appropriate attire to ensure they are comfortable.

Use a placeholder ring

Using a placeholder ring for your proposal can be a great option for several reasons. Firstly, it can relieve the stress and pressure of finding the "perfect" ring, especially if you're unsure about your partner's preferences or want to involve them in the ring selection process. A placeholder ring allows you to propose without breaking the bank and gives you more time to save for the final ring.

Additionally, a placeholder ring can be a fun and whimsical element to your proposal, adding a little secret between you and your partner. It can also serve as a rehearsal for your actual proposal, giving you a chance to test the waters and make adjustments before committing to the real thing. This is especially useful if you're planning a surprise proposal but want your partner's input on the ring.

When choosing a placeholder ring, it's important to select something that looks good and fits your partner's style, whether it's a simple and understated design or a bold and blingy band. Make sure the ring is comfortable and fits well, as your partner will be wearing it for a while. Be clear about the temporary nature of the ring to avoid any disappointment or confusion.

Some people opt for less expensive materials for placeholder rings, such as sterling silver, yellow or white gold, or platinum. You can also choose between solitaires or rings with multiple gemstones. If you plan on taking photos after the proposal, consider choosing a placeholder ring that resembles the final ring to maintain consistency in the pictures.

Using a placeholder ring can be a practical and romantic choice, allowing you to focus on the moment and your partner's reaction without worrying about the ring. It gives you the flexibility to create a memorable proposal while ensuring that your partner has a say in the final ring they will wear forever.

Serve up your proposal

There are many ways to propose without a ring, and one idea is to serve up your proposal. Here are some ways to do this:

A Home-Cooked Meal

Prepare a meal for your partner, ending with a cake with "Will You Marry Me?" written in frosting. Alternatively, you could write the question on a plate or mug using porcelain paint. This is a great option if your partner prefers a low-key, private proposal.

A High-End Restaurant

If your partner would prefer a more public proposal, you could enlist the help of a professional chef and the staff at a high-end restaurant. You could have the question printed on the bottom of a plate or written in frosting on a cake. Just make sure to involve the manager and staff in your planning to ensure everything goes smoothly.

A Romantic Trip

If your partner values experiences over material items, you could propose during a romantic trip or bucket-list adventure. You could even propose during a nice dinner on the trip, combining this idea with the previous suggestions.

A Proposal Picnic

Pack a picnic with your partner's favourite foods and a bottle of something sparkling. You could write the question on a card or even in the condensation on the bottle. Find a beautiful spot, pop the question, and then enjoy your picnic together as a newly engaged couple!

Remember, it's perfectly fine to propose without a ring. By putting some effort and creativity into your proposal, you can make it a special and memorable moment for your partner.

Put your talent to work

There are many ways to propose without a ring, and you can absolutely put your talent to work to create a memorable and meaningful proposal. Here are some ideas to consider:

The Scrapbook Proposal

Compile a scrapbook of your favourite photos and memories as a couple. Get creative and include mementos such as ticket stubs from your first date, receipts from romantic dinners, or even a handwritten love letter expressing your feelings and intentions. End the scrapbook with a proposal page, asking the all-important question, "Will you marry me?" This approach is perfect for those who want to showcase their artistic side and create a proposal that is full of personal touches.

The Handmade Card

If you're looking for a more straightforward approach, consider creating a handmade card. Use your artistic skills to design a card with a heartfelt message about why you want to marry your partner. Include illustrations, inside jokes, and all the reasons why your significant other means the world to you. This idea is perfect for those who want to express their feelings through words and showcase their creativity.

The Handmade Jewellery

If you're crafty and want to create something truly unique, consider making a piece of jewellery as an alternative to a traditional ring. For example, you could create a handmade bracelet or necklace that symbolizes your love and commitment. This idea is perfect for those who want to give their partner something tangible to wear and cherish forever.

The Customised Gift

Use your talents to customise a gift that will be cherished forever. For example, you could paint a meaningful quote or the proposal itself on a piece of canvas or a mug. If you're into woodworking, you could create a custom picture frame or a keepsake box with a hidden proposal message inside. This idea is perfect for those who want to combine their creativity with a practical and personalised gift.

The Performance

If you're artistically inclined, consider putting on a performance for your proposal. Write and perform a song, poem, or dance that expresses your love and includes the proposal. You can even involve your partner's friends and family to make it a grand spectacle. This idea is perfect for those who want to showcase their performance talents and create a memorable event.

Remember, the key is to be creative, thoughtful, and true to yourself and your partner. By putting your talent to work, you can create a proposal that is unique, memorable, and full of love and intention. Good luck!

Frequently asked questions