Catholic Attending A Mormon Wedding: Is It Allowed?

The Catholic Church has strict rules about weddings and marriage, and these rules apply to Catholics marrying non-Catholics, non-Christians, and non-believers. While the Church does not explicitly forbid Catholics from attending invalid marriages, it is generally not considered appropriate to attend a wedding outside of the Church, especially if it is a Catholic marrying outside of the Church without permission. However, the Church does not have an absolute norm in this regard, and Catholics must use their prudential judgment, keeping in mind the necessity to uphold the Catholic understanding of the sanctity of marriage.

The Church's stance on Catholics attending non-Catholic weddings

The Catholic Church does not explicitly forbid Catholics from attending invalid or non-Catholic weddings, but it is generally advised against. The Church teaches that Catholics should not attend weddings of other baptised Catholics held outside of the Church, or weddings that are invalid due to other factors, such as a same-sex wedding, or a wedding where one or both spouses have been married before and do not have a decree of nullity. This is because attending a wedding ceremony indicates celebration of the union, and in some cases, Catholics cannot celebrate what is being done. Attending such ceremonies may also sow confusion or scandal by leading others to think the wedding is fine by Catholic standards when it is not.

However, the Church recognises that there may be situations where refusing to attend a wedding may damage family relationships, and in such cases, a prudential judgment can be made to attend. The Church teaches that the overall goal is to witness to the Catholic faith and to seek conversion and a return to the sacraments for fallen-away Catholics. Therefore, it may be better to attend but resolve to later explain the need to validate the marriage to the couple and others.

The Church also advises that while Catholics may attend as non-participating guests, they should not actively involve themselves in the wedding. If one decides not to attend a wedding as a matter of principle, it is not recommended to then attend the reception or give a gift, as this would honour an occasion that one does not believe in or celebrate.

In the case of same-sex weddings, the Church has spoken strongly against them, and it is not recommended to attend or celebrate them under any circumstances.

The Church teaches that Catholics must use their own prudential judgment in deciding whether or not to attend a non-Catholic wedding, keeping in mind the necessity to uphold the Catholic understanding of the sanctity of marriage. One may consider if the couple is doing their best to act honourably and according to the truth that they know. For example, one may decide to attend the wedding of a couple who is expecting a child, thereby attempting to provide a family for that child, but may decline to attend the wedding of a couple known to have engaged in adultery, thereby destroying previous marriages and families.

The validity of a Catholic-Mormon marriage

The Catholic Church considers a marriage between a Catholic and a non-baptised person to be invalid. However, a dispensation from this rule, known as a "dispensation for disparity of cult", can be granted by a bishop or other diocesan official, allowing a Catholic to marry a non-Christian.

In the case of a Catholic marrying a baptised non-Catholic, permission from the competent authority is required. If permission is not obtained, the marriage is still valid but technically illicit.

Mormons have a form of baptism, but the Catholic Church has declared it invalid. Therefore, a Catholic wishing to marry a Mormon requires a dispensation for disparity of cult.

The Church's chief concern in these cases is for the faith of the Catholic party to the marriage. The diocesan bishop must ensure that the Catholic party is prepared to remove any dangers of defecting from the faith and must promise to do their best to raise any children of the marriage as Catholics.

The Catholic Church does not consider a marriage between a Catholic and a non-Catholic to be automatically invalid. The marriage is presumed valid unless a marriage tribunal finds otherwise.

Attending a non-Catholic wedding

The Catholic Church does not explicitly forbid Catholics from attending presumptively invalid marriages, leaving it to the prudential judgment of individuals. However, the Church does not recommend participating as a member of the wedding party in such weddings.

Catholics who attend the invalid marriage of another Catholic may cause scandal, as their attendance can be interpreted as approval. This can lead others to think that the wedding is fine by Catholic standards when it is not.

In certain limited circumstances, there may be a legitimate moral reason for a Catholic to attend the invalid wedding of another Catholic, such as to avoid sending the message that the Catholic spouse is cutting themselves off irrevocably from the Church.

In summary, while the Catholic Church has specific rules regarding Catholic-Mormon marriages, the validity of such marriages ultimately depends on whether the Catholic party has obtained the necessary dispensation or permission. Catholics may attend non-Catholic weddings but should use their judgment and be mindful of the Church's teachings on the sanctity of marriage.

The theological implications of attending a non-Catholic wedding

Theologically, a Catholic wedding is more than just a ceremony or a social event; it is a sacrament, and therefore, attending a non-Catholic wedding can have implications for Catholics. The Code of Canon Law states that Catholics are required by law to marry in a Catholic wedding ceremony, following the canonical form. This means that a Catholic wedding must be celebrated by the pastor of the parish or the diocesan bishop or a cleric deputed by either of them and must have two witnesses present. Marrying outside of the Catholic Church without permission from the diocesan bishop is considered invalid by the Church.

When it comes to attending a non-Catholic wedding, the Church does not explicitly forbid Catholics from being present at presumptively invalid marriages. However, Catholics must use their prudential judgment, considering the necessity to uphold the Catholic understanding of the sanctity of marriage. While there is no absolute norm, the general norm is that Catholics should not attend the weddings of other Catholics held outside of the Church or weddings that are invalid due to factors such as same-sex marriages or remarriage without a decree of nullity. This is because attending a wedding indicates celebration and approval of the union, and Catholics should not celebrate what goes against their faith.

However, refusing to attend a non-Catholic wedding may cause issues within families, especially in cases of adoption or illness, as seen in the example of a man whose wife intends to support her sister-in-law with multiple sclerosis during her son's wedding outside of the Catholic Church. In such cases, a prudential judgment can be made to attend while resolving to explain the need to validate the marriage at a later time. Attending as a non-participating guest is different from actively involving oneself in the wedding, and it is recommended not to participate in the wedding party of a presumptively invalid marriage.

In summary, while there is no explicit prohibition, Catholics must use their judgment and uphold their understanding of the sanctity of marriage when deciding whether to attend a non-Catholic wedding. Attending as a guest is different from participating in the wedding party, and refusing to attend can be a charitable act to prevent spiritual downfall, especially for a fellow Catholic. The decision to attend or not attend carries theological implications regarding the Catholic faith and the spiritual well-being of those involved.

The pastoral implications of attending a non-Catholic wedding

The implications of a Catholic attending a non-Catholic wedding depend on several factors, including the religious affiliation of the couple, the nature of the ceremony, and the individual's relationship with the couple. While the Church does not explicitly forbid Catholics from attending non-Catholic weddings, individuals must exercise prudential judgment, upholding the sanctity of marriage.

When considering attendance, it is essential to assess whether the couple is honouring their understanding of truth and acting honourably. For instance, attending the wedding of a couple expecting a child may be justified to support the family unit, whereas declining an invitation from a couple known to have engaged in adultery may be prudent to avoid celebrating the destruction of previous marriages.

Active participation in the wedding party of a presumptively invalid wedding is generally discouraged. However, attending as a non-participating guest is a matter of individual conscience and the potential impact on family relationships. Writing a letter expressing love and prayers for the couple is recommended if one chooses not to attend. Attending same-sex weddings is strongly discouraged under any circumstances.

When a Catholic is invited to the wedding of another Catholic held outside the Church, the decision to attend carries tremendous moral responsibility for the spiritual well-being of the Catholic spouse. While there is no official Church ruling on this matter, declining the invitation can serve as a spiritual wake-up call for the Catholic spouse, potentially leading them back to the Church. However, in certain delicate situations, attendance may be justified to avoid permanently shutting the door on the Catholic spouse and sending the message that they are no longer welcome in the faith community. In such cases, attending the ceremony but sitting discreetly at the back and praying for the couple can be a thoughtful compromise.

In conclusion, Catholics facing the dilemma of attending a non-Catholic wedding must carefully weigh their decision, considering the couple's circumstances, the nature of the ceremony, and the potential impact on family relationships. While there is no one-size-fits-all answer, upholding the sanctity of marriage and prioritising the spiritual well-being of all involved should be central to the decision-making process.

The moral responsibility of a Catholic when invited to a non-Catholic wedding

When a Catholic is invited to a non-Catholic wedding, they may face a moral dilemma. While there is no absolute norm, the general guideline is that Catholics should refrain from attending weddings of Catholics held outside the Church or weddings deemed invalid by the Church, such as same-sex marriages or weddings involving divorced individuals. The reasoning behind this is that attending a wedding implies approval and celebration of the union, which may contradict Catholic teachings if the marriage is not recognized by the Church.

However, it is essential to note that the Church does not explicitly forbid Catholics from attending presumptively invalid marriages. Instead, Catholics are advised to use their prudential judgment, considering the necessity to uphold the Catholic understanding of the sanctity of marriage. They may ask themselves if the couple is acting honorably and according to their truth. For example, a Catholic might decide to attend the wedding of a couple expecting a child but decline an invitation from a couple who have engaged in adultery.

When it comes to participation in the wedding party, the Church advises against active involvement in weddings that go against Catholic teachings. Attending as a non-participating guest is generally acceptable, but Catholics are discouraged from participating in the ceremony as a member of the wedding party, such as a best man or bridesmaid.

If a Catholic chooses not to attend a non-Catholic wedding due to their beliefs, they are advised to express their love and prayers for the couple. They can write a letter conveying their well-wishes while withholding any details that may conflict with their conscience, such as specific prayers for the couple's repentance and conversion.

In the specific case of same-sex weddings, the Church has spoken strongly against them, and it is not recommended for Catholics to attend or celebrate these weddings under any circumstances.

Ultimately, the decision to attend a non-Catholic wedding rests with the individual Catholic's conscience and judgment. While there is no one-size-fits-all answer, it is important for Catholics to consider the potential impact of their attendance on their own spiritual well-being and that of the couple. Consulting with a priest or spiritual advisor can provide valuable guidance in navigating these complex moral decisions.

Frequently asked questions