Catholics Attending Non-Catholic Weddings: Is It Allowed?

The Catholic Church permits Catholics to attend the non-Catholic weddings of other Catholics, but it is a complex issue that has sparked debate. While Canon law does not prohibit attendance at invalid weddings, Catholics are advised to carefully evaluate the situation. Maintaining family peace is important, but individuals should also consider the couple's intentions and whether their presence would indicate approval of a non-canonical marriage. Catholics who choose not to attend invalid weddings may face strained relationships and hurt feelings. Ultimately, the decision to attend a non-Catholic wedding requires prudence and discernment, weighing various factors, such as family dynamics and the potential for scandal or cooperation in evil.

Baptised Catholics can attend non-Catholic weddings

However, under certain circumstances, there could be valid reasons for attending such weddings. For instance, a civil marriage may be the first step for a couple in recognising the importance of marriage. Attending and supporting the couple could be an opportunity to invite them towards the sacrament of matrimony and maintain a good relationship, keeping the door open to help lead them back to the Catholic Church.

When deciding whether to attend a non-Catholic wedding, it's essential to consider the intention behind the invitation. As a deacon or representative of the Catholic Church, one must be cautious not to have their presence misinterpreted as a stamp of approval. If the invitation comes from a close relative, maintaining family relationships may take precedence, especially if it's a Christian wedding.

In conclusion, while baptised Catholics can attend non-Catholic weddings, it's a matter that requires prudence and discernment. One should carefully evaluate the situation, seeking spiritual guidance and ensuring that their presence does not imply approval of any deviation from Catholic doctrine.

Catholics can marry non-Catholics

Firstly, marriage to a non-Catholic is technically called a "mixed religion marriage" if both people are baptised Christians, and a "disparity of cult marriage" if one is unbaptised. However, the Catholic Church will only allow such a marriage if the bishop gives special permission, called a "dispensation". This is easy to obtain and is requested through the parish when the couple gets engaged and starts marriage preparation.

Secondly, the marriage must be "in the Church", meaning with the Catholic Church's blessing. The wedding must happen in a Catholic parish, witnessed by a Catholic priest or deacon, and using the Catholic ritual, unless the bishop gives special permission to use a different location, minister, or ritual (another dispensation).

Thirdly, both parties must be prepared to love each other until death (no divorce) and to accept children from God and bring them up in the Catholic Church (no contraception). The couple declares these intentions as part of all Catholic weddings, but they are particularly important in a mixed marriage.

For a mixed marriage, the Church also requires that the Catholic spouse promise to do everything in their power to raise the children as Catholics and inform the other spouse of that promise.

The Church allows Catholics to marry non-Catholics if they can both meet these criteria. However, mixed marriages are only tolerated by the Church, not encouraged. According to the Catholic Encyclopedia, the Church was reluctant to approve these unions and only allowed dispensations to avoid greater evils.

If a Catholic marries a non-baptised person, the wedding is not a sacrament. Only the baptised can receive sacraments. It would still be a valid marriage, though.

Catholics must not approve of non-canonical weddings

According to Father Angel Perez-Lopez, formation adviser and assistant professor of philosophical ethics and sacred moral theology at St. John Vianney Seminary in Denver, this issue demands an exercise of prudence. On the one hand, Catholics should avoid cooperating in evil and scandal by attending such weddings. By doing so, they risk giving the impression that they approve of the couple's decision to disregard the canonical form of marriage. It is crucial to make it clear that you do not agree with their choice. Moreover, one should avoid being an active participant in the ceremony.

On the other hand, under certain circumstances, there could be valid reasons for attending such weddings. For instance, a civil marriage may be the first step for a couple in recognizing the importance of marriage. Attending such weddings could be an opportunity to invite couples to the sacrament of matrimony and guide them back to the Church. Maintaining good relationships with family members who marry outside of the Church is essential to keep the door open for potential reconciliation.

When deciding whether to attend a non-canonical wedding, it is important to consider the intention behind the invitation. As Deacon Michael McKeown of St. Mary's Church in Seaforth, Minnesota, explains, he must be cautious that his presence is not seen as a stamp of approval by the Catholic Church. If he feels that his attendance would be perceived as an endorsement, he chooses not to attend. However, if it is a close relative getting married, he makes an effort to attend to maintain family relationships.

In conclusion, while Catholics are not explicitly prohibited from attending non-canonical weddings, they must exercise prudence and discernment. It is vital to avoid giving the impression of approving a couple's decision to marry outside of the Church. Attending such weddings may be justified in specific circumstances, but Catholics should always make their disagreement with the couple's choice clear and refrain from actively participating in the ceremony.

Catholics must avoid cooperation in evil and scandal

To avoid cooperation in evil and scandal, Catholics should make it clear that they do not agree with the couple's decision to marry outside the Church. They should also avoid being an active participant in the ceremony. However, under certain circumstances, there could be good reasons to attend such weddings. For example, a civil marriage may be the first step for a couple in recognising the importance of marriage, and attending could help lead them back to the Church.

Catholics should also be mindful of maintaining peace within families. If a close relative is getting married in a Christian wedding, it may be important to attend to preserve family relationships. In some cases, not attending the wedding service but going to the reception can be a way to show respect for the couple's decision to marry while also maintaining one's Catholic beliefs.

Ultimately, the decision of whether to attend a non-Catholic wedding requires careful discernment, prayer, and evaluation of the specific circumstances. Seeking guidance from a priest or other trusted advisor can also help Catholics make an informed decision that aligns with their values and avoids cooperation in evil and scandal.

Catholics can marry non-baptised people

To receive a dispensation for a non-sacramental marriage, the Catholic party must promise to do everything in their power to baptise and raise their children in the Catholic Church. They must also declare that they are prepared to remove any dangers that might cause them to fall away from the faith. Additionally, the non-Catholic person must be informed about the Catholic party's promises and obligations. The couple must also be informed of the purposes and properties of marriage.

It is important to note that the Catholic Church recognises the validity of non-Catholic baptisms. For example, if a Catholic marries a baptised non-Catholic (such as a Baptist) in a Catholic ceremony, the Church teaches that each spouse receives the sacrament of matrimony. However, if a Catholic marries a non-baptised person in a Catholic ceremony, the non-baptised spouse does not receive the sacrament of matrimony because they have not received the sacrament of baptism.

In summary, while the Catholic Church discourages Catholics from marrying non-baptised people, it is possible to receive permission for such marriages through a dispensation from the bishop. These marriages are considered natural marriages and are not sacramental.

Frequently asked questions