Wedding Cakes: Timeless Tradition Or Outdated Trend?

Wedding cakes have been a staple of wedding ceremonies for centuries, but are they still relevant today? The traditional tiered cake, often white to symbolise purity, has been a centrepiece of wedding celebrations for generations. However, modern couples are increasingly opting for alternative dessert options and unique cake designs that reflect their personalities and style. While some couples still choose to stick with the classic tiered wedding cake, others are exploring more creative options such as dome-shaped cakes, cupcakes, or even non-cake desserts like pies or doughnuts.

Wedding cake traditions

Wedding cakes have been a part of wedding ceremonies for centuries, though they haven't always been the centrepiece of the event. The first wedding cakes were probably made in ancient Greece, and the tradition continued in ancient Rome, where a cake of wheat or barley was broken over the bride's head to bring good fortune to the couple.

In medieval times, bakers would make wedding cakes with as many layers as possible, and the bride and groom would kiss over the top of the cake. A successful kiss was said to bring good luck, prosperity, and a long, happy marriage.

In the 16th and 17th centuries, a "bride's pie" was served at most weddings. This was a savoury dish filled with oysters, lamb testicles, pine kernels, and cocks' combs. It was considered very rude and bad luck not to eat a piece of the bride's pie.

In the 17th century, two cakes were made: one for the bride and one for the groom. The bride's cake was usually a simple pound cake with white icing, as white was a sign of virginity and purity. The groom's cake was a darker, rich fruit cake and was much smaller.

Wedding cakes became a symbol of luxury, celebration, and social status, with bigger cakes indicating higher social standing. In Victorian times, white icing was also a symbol of wealth, as the fine white sugar needed to create it was extremely expensive.

Today, wedding cakes are often multi-tiered and come in a variety of sizes, depending on the number of guests. They are usually on display and served to guests at the reception, though sometimes they are only for show.

• Cutting the cake together: The couple cuts the first slice of the cake together, symbolising the first activity they do as a married couple.
• Feeding each other cake: The couple feeds each other the first bites of cake, symbolising their commitment to creating a sweet life together.
• Groom's cake: A separate, smaller cake that may contain the groom's favourite sports team logo or other interests.
• A tier for each partner: Each tier of the cake represents each person's favourite flavour.
• Saving the top tier: The top tier of the cake is saved and eaten on the couple's first wedding anniversary or at the christening of their first child.
• Wedding cake charms: Charms are baked into the cake or attached to ribbons for guests to pull out. Each charm has a special meaning, such as a ring for an upcoming engagement or a four-leaf clover for good luck.
• White wedding cake: White cakes symbolise purity and the start of the marriage union.
• Sleeping with cake under your pillow: The night before the wedding, the bride sleeps with a piece of cake under her pillow, believing it will inspire dreams of her future spouse.
• Wedding cake topper: A chance for the couple to show off their personality, with classic toppers like "LOVE" or "Mr. and Mrs." or a small replica of the couple (and maybe their pets).
• Sharing the cake with guests: In most cultures, sharing the same confectionery symbolises good luck and wishes for a sweet future.
• Kissing over the cake: Couples kiss over the top of their multi-tiered wedding cake, and if they succeed without knocking it over, it is said to bring good luck and a long, successful marriage.

Modern alternatives to wedding cakes

Wedding cakes have been a tradition for centuries, but modern couples are increasingly opting for alternative desserts to serve at their wedding receptions. Here are some modern alternatives to the traditional wedding cake:

Cupcakes

Cupcakes are a popular alternative to a traditional wedding cake, especially for couples who want a more modern and creative look for their wedding dessert. Cupcakes can be displayed on tiered stands, with a small cake at the top for the ceremonial cake-cutting. They offer a variety of flavours, colours, and designs, making them a versatile option.

Sheet Cakes

Sheet cakes are another alternative, particularly for couples looking for a more budget-friendly option. They can be cut and served easily, making them a practical choice for large weddings. Sheet cakes can also be decorated with fondant, flowers, and other embellishments to create a unique and elegant look.

Cake Meadows

A cake meadow is a recent trend where a dome-shaped cake is surrounded by smaller cakes or cupcakes in various flavours and designs. This option allows couples to offer a variety of dessert options to their guests while still having a unique and creative display.

Alternative Desserts

Some couples choose to forgo the cake altogether and serve alternative desserts such as fruit pies, doughnuts, cookies, or a dessert bar with a variety of treats. This option allows couples to personalise their wedding dessert and offer something unique to their guests.

Cultural Alternatives

In some cultures, traditional wedding desserts differ from the typical Western wedding cake. For example, in France, the traditional wedding dessert is a Croquembouche, a complex pastry made of cream puffs and caramelised sugar. In Norway and other Scandinavian countries, a Kransekake, a pastry made of stacked rings, is the preferred choice. These cultural alternatives offer a unique and meaningful twist to the traditional wedding cake.

The cost of wedding cakes

Wedding cakes are priced per slice, with prices ranging from $2.50 to $12 per slice in the US. The average wedding cake in the US costs around $500 to $600, with couples typically spending between $600 and $900 on their cakes. However, in bigger cities or for more elaborate cakes, couples can expect to pay anywhere from $1,000 to $1,200.

The cost of a wedding cake depends on several factors, including the number of tiers, the intricacy of the design, the complexity of the flavour, the type of frosting, and any additional decorations or add-ons. For example, unusual shapes, custom sugar flower detailing, and fondant frosting can drive up the price due to their labour-intensive nature or the cost of materials and ingredients.

Additionally, the cost of a wedding cake can vary depending on the cake designer and the location. Couples should also factor in additional costs such as delivery fees, cake stands or toppers, and the cost of serving the cake to guests.

To save money on a wedding cake, couples can consider the following options:

• Opting for a smaller cake and supplementing it with other desserts or cupcakes.
• Choosing a simpler design and basic flavours.
• Using buttercream frosting instead of fondant.
• Providing their own wedding cake, either by baking it themselves or sourcing it from a friend or a grocery store.

The history of wedding cakes

Wedding cakes have been part of the ceremony since ancient times, with the first wedding cakes probably originating in ancient Greece. In ancient Rome, a cake of wheat or barley was broken over the bride's head to bring good fortune to the couple. This tradition was slightly different in ancient Greece, where the groom broke bread over the bride's head to symbolise the end of her purity and her submission.

In medieval England, cakes were stacked as high as possible, and the bride and groom would kiss over them. If they managed to kiss without knocking the cakes over, it was believed they would be blessed with many children. This tradition led to the creation of the Croquembouche, a tower of sweet rolls topped with a halo of spun sugar.

In the 16th and 17th centuries, the "bride's pie" was served at most weddings. This was a savoury pie filled with oysters, lamb testicles, pine kernels, and cocks' combs. It was considered rude and bad luck not to eat a piece of the bride's pie.

In the 17th century, two cakes were made: one for the bride and one for the groom. The bride's cake was usually a simple pound cake with white icing, symbolising virginity and purity. The groom's cake was a darker, rich fruit cake and was generally much smaller.

In the early 19th century, sugar became more accessible and affordable, and white icing became a symbol of the bride's family's wealth and social status. When Queen Victoria used white icing on her wedding cake, it gained the title of "royal icing".

The modern wedding cake as we know it today originated at the 1882 wedding of Prince Leopold, Duke of Albany. His wedding cake was the first to be completely edible, with separate layers stacked on top of each other using dense icing.

The role of wedding cakes in the reception

Wedding cakes have been a part of wedding ceremonies for centuries, though they haven't always been the main event. Today, the wedding cake is a central feature of the reception, often serving as a visual centrepiece as well as a delicious dessert for guests to enjoy.

The wedding cake is usually displayed and served to guests at the reception. It is typically a tiered cake, with the number of tiers depending on the number of guests. Modern pastry chefs use a variety of ingredients and tools to create a cake that reflects the couple's personalities. Marzipan, fondant, gum paste, buttercream, and chocolate are all popular ingredients. Cakes can also be decorated with fresh flowers or cake toppers, which can represent shared hobbies or interests.

The wedding cake also holds symbolic meaning. In ancient Rome, a cake of wheat or barley was broken over the bride's head to bring good fortune to the couple. Today, the cake is often seen as a symbol of prosperity, luck, and fertility, with the highest-quality ingredients ensuring a long and happy life for the newlyweds. The cake-cutting ceremony symbolises the couple's first activity as a married couple and represents a commitment to provide for and care for one another.

While the wedding cake remains a popular tradition, modern couples may choose to replace it with alternative desserts such as cupcakes, pastries, or cookies. Ultimately, the decision to include a wedding cake is a personal one, allowing couples to create their own unique traditions on their special day.

Frequently asked questions