Wedding Cake Nightmares: When Sweet Turns Sour

Wedding cakes are often the centrepiece of a wedding reception, but sometimes they can go disastrously wrong. From spelling mistakes to cakes collapsing, there are many ways that a wedding cake can be a disaster. Sometimes the cake is the wrong flavour, or it might be decorated in a way that the couple didn't ask for. Other times, the cake might be fine, but the topper is a disaster. In one instance, a baker was a fraud and stole photos of other people's cakes, but was unable to recreate them.

Cake decorators delivering melted disasters

A cake is a highlight of any wedding, but it can quickly become a nightmare if it's not executed properly. Here are some stories of cake decorators delivering melted disasters:

One unfortunate incident involved a cake decorator who had to deliver a cake to a steamy reception in Haiti. Despite the cake's beautiful buttercream frosting, it couldn't withstand the high temperatures. The decorator recounted how the "Port au Prince streets and Haiti heat just melted and shook my frosting and roses right off the cake." To avoid future disasters, they now bring extra frosting to redecorate cakes on-site.

Another story involved a couple who ordered a unique wedding cake that resembled three motorcycle tires, as they enjoyed riding motorcycles together. However, on their wedding day, they received a purple and gray blob of melting fondant instead of the expected tire-shaped cake. This story serves as a reminder for couples to thoroughly research and choose reputable bakers to avoid such disasters.

In another instance, a bride-to-be named Genevieve Myles was unpleasantly surprised when she picked up her wedding cake. It was not what she had envisioned, and she described it as "a sorry-looking wedding cake that needed a makeover." Fortunately, Myles remained optimistic and decided to fix the cake herself, transforming it into the Pinterest-inspired cake she had wanted.

These stories highlight the importance of careful planning and execution when it comes to wedding cakes. While these incidents may have caused some stress and disappointment, they also showcase the resilience and creativity of those involved in turning these melted disasters into memorable experiences.

Spelling mistakes

One couple's cake had "Congvatulations Jess & Anthong" written on it, with a glaring misspelling of "congratulations". Despite the mistake, the bride, Jessica Peachman, maintained a positive attitude, focusing on the true meaning of her wedding day.

Another couple's cake had "Happy Birthday Sheri" written on it, with the name misspelled as "Sheri" instead of the correct spelling, "Shari".

In another instance, a cake was supposed to say "Happy Birthday, Daniel" in multiple languages but ended up saying it in only one language, English, likely due to a misunderstanding or miscommunication.

While not a direct misspelling, one couple's cake had "Happy 60th Birthday, Linda (cherry on top)" written on it, with the parentheses likely intended to specify that the cake should include a cherry on top. However, the baker interpreted this as instructions to write the phrase "cherry on top" on the cake, which may have been avoided with clearer instructions.

Lopsided cakes

• Use a cake leveler to ensure that each cake layer is even. This will help create a stable foundation for stacking.
• When assembling the tiers, use cake circles or cake boards at the bottom of each tier. These provide a solid base and prevent the cake from collapsing or sinking into itself.
• Insert support dowels or straws into each tier to provide additional stability. These should be cut to the height of the tier they are supporting and placed in a balanced square formation.
• Always use a cake board between tiers to distribute the weight evenly.
• When stacking the tiers, mark the centre of the base tier and outline where the next tier will go. This will help you place the support dowels correctly and avoid any visible gaps between tiers.
• If your tiers are taller than 6 inches, consider using an additional cake circle in the middle of the tier for extra support.
• Practice assembling and stacking tiered cakes before attempting a wedding cake. This will help you perfect the technique and avoid any mistakes on the big day.

By following these tips and allowing adequate time for assembly and chilling, you can create a beautiful and stable wedding cake that won't end up lopsided.

Faulty cake toppers

Cake toppers are a fun way to personalise a wedding cake, but sometimes they can go wrong. From spelling mistakes to structural failures, faulty cake toppers can ruin an otherwise beautiful cake. Here are some stories of when cake toppers went wrong and how they were fixed or could have been prevented:

Spelling Mistakes

Spelling mistakes on cake toppers can be embarrassing and ruin the elegant look of a wedding cake. In one instance, a cake topper congratulating "Jess & Anthong" was marred by a misspelling of "congratulations". While the bride, Jessica Peachman, had a positive attitude about the mistake, it's safe to say that the couple had hoped for a correctly spelled cake topper on their special day.

Structural Failures

Sometimes, cake toppers can literally fall flat. In one case, a wooden cake topper with "Mr and Mrs [last name]" and the wedding date snapped on the way home the day after the wedding. To prevent this type of structural failure, it's important to choose a sturdy material for the cake topper and handle it with care.

Design Misplacement

A well-intentioned baker may inadvertently place a cake topper in a less-than-ideal location. In one example, a heart-shaped cake topper was positioned in a questionable spot on the cake, leading some to interpret it as the groom having a change of heart. To avoid this blunder, bakers should carefully consider the placement of cake toppers to ensure they align with the desired message or theme.

Inedible Materials

Some cake toppers are made with materials that are not food-safe, which can be a problem if they come into direct contact with the cake. To prevent this, couples can attach the topper to a wooden dowel or use a small cake board to keep it separate from the cake. Alternatively, they can create a dummy display cake for pictures, ensuring the topper never touches the actual cake.

Incorrect Flavours

While not exactly a cake topper, it is worth mentioning that getting the flavours wrong can also ruin a wedding cake. In one instance, a baker mixed up the flavours for a two-tier cake and cake pops, delivering pink lemonade instead of the requested chocolate and strawberry. The baker offered a partial refund, and the issue was resolved. To prevent this mistake, bakers should double-check the invoice and confirm the flavours with the couple before finalising the order.

Flavour mix-ups

While the appearance of a wedding cake is important, the flavour is equally crucial. After all, it is meant to be enjoyed by the couple and their guests. However, things can go awry when it comes to the flavours, leading to disappointed palates and confused taste buds.

In one unfortunate incident, a baker mistakenly delivered a cake with the wrong flavours. The bride had specifically requested a bottom tier of chocolate and strawberry cake pops, but instead, both tiers were pink lemonade, and the cake pops were chocolate and vanilla. The baker, realising their mistake, felt horrible and considered offering a partial refund. This mix-up left the bride confused and disappointed, as she had to serve a cake that didn't meet her expectations.

Another couple experienced a similar flavour fiasco when their wedding cake arrived with the wrong flavours. The baker had promised a specific set of flavours, but upon tasting, the couple discovered that the cake was completely different from what they had ordered. They were left scrambling for a solution, unsure if they should demand a refund or try to make the best of a bad situation.

In some cases, flavour mix-ups can be more amusing than disastrous. One couple, for instance, received a cake that was supposed to be yellow, but instead, it turned out to be various shades of brown. While not what they had envisioned, the cake still provided a comedic element to their special day.

To avoid such flavour disasters, it is essential to communicate clearly with the baker, double-check orders, and, if possible, conduct a tasting session before the big day to ensure the cake meets expectations. While flavour mix-ups may not ruin a wedding, they can certainly leave a less-than-desirable taste in the couple's mouth.

Frequently asked questions