Tasty Memories: Eating Frozen Wedding Cake After One Year

The tradition of freezing the top tier of a wedding cake to eat on a couple's first anniversary dates back to the 19th century when weddings were celebrated with liqueur-soaked fruitcakes. Sugar and alcohol are natural preservatives, so these cakes would be saved to commemorate a couple's first anniversary or the christening of their first child. Today, many couples continue this tradition, but with cakes that don't preserve as well. So, is it safe to eat a year-old frozen wedding cake?

The tradition of eating frozen wedding cake

Freezing a wedding cake for a year is generally considered safe by experts, as long as it is properly preserved and stored at a constant food-safe temperature. However, the flavour and texture of the cake may suffer, and it may not taste as good as it did on the wedding day. To ensure the best preservation, it is recommended to wrap the cake tightly in plastic shrink wrap and tin foil, seal it inside an airtight container, and store it in the refrigerator or freezer as soon as possible after the wedding.

Some couples choose to recreate the same cake or order a miniature version for their first anniversary to ensure it tastes fresh and delicious. This variation on the tradition allows couples to relive their cake-cutting moment with a freshly-baked dessert. Alternatively, couples may opt for other treats such as cupcakes, pies, donuts, or strudels to commemorate their anniversary.

Despite the potential risks to taste and texture, many couples still choose to participate in the tradition of freezing and eating their wedding cake on their first anniversary. It is a sentimental way to celebrate their special day and create lasting memories, even if the cake may not taste as good as they remember.

How to preserve a wedding cake

Preserving a wedding cake for your first anniversary is a long-honoured tradition. While it may not taste as good as it did on your wedding day, it is still harmless to eat a year later if it has been preserved properly. Here is how you can preserve your wedding cake:

Remove the decorations:

Take off the cake topper, large sugar flowers, and any other decorations on your cake. Smaller sugar flowers and icing details can remain.

Remove cardboard:

Transfer the cake to a plastic board if it is on cardboard. Otherwise, it will absorb the taste of cardboard during the year. You can also use a foil-covered board, but some people are paranoid about the potential connection between aluminium and Alzheimer's disease.

Pre-freeze the cake:

Place the cake in the freezer for an hour or so to let the frosting firm up. If you skip this step, the soft, sticky frosting will be a mess when you try to wrap it.

Wrap in plastic wrap:

Remove the cake from the freezer and wrap it tightly with plastic wrap. It is recommended to use at least five full layers of plastic wrap to prevent freezer odours and burn from getting into your cake.

Add a final layer of aluminium foil:

After mummifying your cake with plastic wrap, add a final layer of aluminium foil.

Place the cake in a large plastic container:

Place your wrapped cake in a big plastic container.

Have a backup plan:

Call your local baker and ask them to make a simple cake in your wedding cake flavours so you can enjoy a fresh cake on your first anniversary.

Alternatives to eating frozen wedding cake

Eating a frozen wedding cake on your first anniversary is a long-honoured tradition. The custom dates back to when weddings were celebrated with liqueur-soaked fruitcakes, which were easier to preserve. However, the idea of eating year-old frozen cake doesn't appeal to everyone. So, what are some alternatives to eating frozen wedding cake?

Opt for a Slice

If you don't want to preserve a whole tier of your wedding cake, you could simply save a slice. This takes up less room in your freezer and is easier to store in an airtight container.

Order a Mini Version

Another option is to contact the bakery that made your original wedding cake and ask them to make a miniature version with the same flavours and icing. This way, you can still enjoy a fresh and delicious cake on your anniversary without having to worry about preservation.

Fresh Top Tier Gift Certificate

Some bakeries offer a gift certificate for a free fresh top tier on the couple's first anniversary. This ensures the couple can enjoy a fresh cake without the hassle of preservation.

Make a New Cake

Instead of eating frozen wedding cake, you could make a new miniature recreation of the same cake. This option guarantees a fresh and delicious experience, just like on the wedding night.

Whether you choose to save the whole cake, a slice, or opt for a fresh alternative, there are plenty of ways to commemorate your special day.

The history of the wedding cake tradition

Wedding cakes have a long and varied history, with traditions evolving over time. One of the earliest traditions began in Ancient Rome, where a barley or wheat cake was broken over the bride's head to bring good fortune and fertility to the couple. The newlyweds would then eat some crumbs together, followed by guests who would scoop up the remaining crumbs for good luck.

When the Romans conquered Britain in 43 CE, they brought this tradition with them. However, the Brits added their twist by throwing the bread at the bride as a symbol of her fertility. During the medieval period, the English took this tradition further by stacking spiced buns, scones, and cookies as high as possible. The bride and groom would then try to kiss over this stack, with the success of the kiss predicting their future fortune.

The first known official wedding confection, the "Bride's Pye," originated in 1685. This unusual pie contained oysters, lamb testicles, throat, rooster comb, and pine kernels. It was believed that eating this pie would ensure a happy life for the couple, and it was considered rude and bad luck to decline a slice.

By the 17th century, bridal pies were being replaced by wedding cakes. These early cakes were often made of two pastry crusts baked on a hearth, with currants sandwiched between them and sprinkled with sugar. The bride would then toss the cake over her head, similar to the bouquet toss of today, to symbolise getting everything she wanted out of life.

The introduction of refined sugar in England led to the use of bright white icing on wedding cakes. This symbolised the bride's virginity and was also a display of wealth, as refined sugar was expensive. The more refined and whiter the sugar, the higher the social status of the family.

The tradition of stacking cakes evolved into tiered cakes, supposedly originating in the late 18th century. One legend attributes this innovation to a baker's apprentice in love with his boss's daughter. Inspired by the tiered spire of St. Bride's Church in London, he created an elaborate tiered cake to propose to her.

The modern wedding cake as we know it today originated at the wedding of Prince Leopold, Duke of Albany, in 1882. His wedding cake was the first to be completely edible, with separate layers stacked on top of each other using dense icing as support.

Another long-honoured tradition is freezing the top tier of the wedding cake to be eaten on the couple's first anniversary for good luck. This custom dates back to when weddings were celebrated with liqueur-soaked fruitcakes, which had a longer shelf life due to the alcohol and sugar preserving them.

The safety of eating frozen wedding cake

Eating frozen wedding cake a year after the wedding is a long-honoured tradition for married couples. The custom dates back to when weddings were celebrated with liqueur-soaked fruitcakes, which contained natural preservatives in the form of sugar and alcohol. While this tradition has persisted, modern wedding cakes are not as well-preserved, and many couples wonder if it is safe to eat their frozen cake a year later.

Experts agree that eating frozen wedding cake a year later is safe but not risk-free. The biggest concern is the quality of the cake, which will likely suffer during its time in the freezer. Oil-based cakes are thought to last longer than butter-based ones, and chocolate cakes fare better than vanilla. Fruit-based fillings are not recommended as freezing and thawing change the texture of the fruit.

To ensure safety, it is crucial to preserve the cake properly before freezing. The top layer of the cake should be wrapped in plastic shrink wrap and tin foil, sealed inside an airtight container, and placed in the refrigerator as soon as possible. In some cases, it is recommended to let the cake solidify in the fridge before freezing to prevent crushing the frosting. The cake should be stored at a constant food-safe temperature to prevent the growth of harmful substances like mould.

When you are ready to eat the cake, let it thaw in the fridge for around 24 hours and then another hour or so at room temperature. Be prepared for a cake that might not taste as delicious as you remember.

If you are hesitant about the risks of eating frozen cake, there is an alternative variation to this tradition. Instead of freezing the cake, you can opt to recreate a miniature version of the same cake on your first anniversary. This way, you can still enjoy a fresh and delicious treat while commemorating your special day.

Frequently asked questions