The Wedding Cake Model: A Tasty Layered Approach To Understanding

The wedding cake model is a concept in criminal justice that describes the hierarchy of criminal cases and how they are processed through the criminal justice system. The model was developed by Samuel Walker in the 1980s as a replacement for the Reagan Crime Commission's criminal justice model. It consists of four layers, each representing different levels of crime and their severity, with the smallest, most attention-grabbing crimes at the top, and the largest volume of less-severe offences at the base. The wedding cake model is significant as it provides insights into criminal justice priorities, illustrates the proportions of crimes, and highlights the role of the media in shaping public perception of crime and safety.

The wedding cake model is a concept in criminal justice

The wedding cake model consists of four layers, each representing different levels of crime and their severity. The bottom layer, or the base, represents misdemeanors and minor offences such as petty theft, disturbing the peace, or minor acts of vandalism. This layer typically includes first-time offenders and the cases are often resolved with a monetary fine rather than jail time.

The second layer from the bottom represents less serious felonies, which are usually non-violent offences involving financial or drug-related crimes. Many of these cases end with plea agreements.

The third layer from the bottom is for serious felonies, such as rape and aggravated assault. There is a lower chance of a plea agreement prior to trial, and bail may not be an option.

The top layer represents high-profile, "celebrated cases" that garner a lot of media attention. These cases often involve celebrities or other big names and spark public debate. Examples include the O.J. Simpson trial and Ted Bundy.

The wedding cake model is significant because it highlights the differences in how cases at different tiers are treated by the media and society, and how this can impact policy and public perception of crime and safety. It also shows that the majority of criminal proceedings involve minor and non-violent offences, rather than the high-profile cases that dominate media coverage.

However, one criticism of the model is that it can oversimplify criminal justice processes and obscure nuances and exceptions within each layer. Additionally, the focus on higher-profile cases may reinforce perceptions of criminality associated with certain groups, potentially leading to systemic biases and inequalities within the system.

It describes the hierarchy of criminal cases and how they are processed

The Wedding Cake Model, developed by Samuel Walker in the 1980s, is a model of crime that consists of four primary groups. It is a concept in criminal justice that describes the hierarchy of criminal cases and how they are processed through the criminal justice system.

The model takes its name and structure from the classic shape of a wedding cake, which traditionally consists of stacked tiers or layers arranged with the largest layer at the bottom and the smallest layer at the top. The bottom layer of the model represents the most significant number of cases handled by the system, which often includes misdemeanours and traffic violations. This layer may also include first-time offenders of less severe crimes. These cases are often resolved when the defendant makes a plea agreement and rarely go to trial.

The second layer from the bottom corresponds to less severe felonies, normally non-violent offences involving financial or drug-related crimes. Like misdemeanours, most of these cases end with plea agreements.

The third layer from the bottom is reserved for more serious or violent felonies, such as rape and aggravated assault. There is less chance of a plea agreement prior to trial and bail may not be an option.

The top and smallest layer corresponds to high-profile, highly publicised "celebrated cases" like those of Ted Bundy or O.J. Simpson. These cases involve additional factors like press coverage and cameras in the courtroom.

The Wedding Cake Model is significant because it draws clear distinctions between high-profile, "celebrated cases" and other types of cases that move through the justice system. It also shows how these less-sensational cases comprise the majority of criminal proceedings. The model is also useful for attorneys to predict the sentencing possibilities for various offences.

The model was developed by Samuel Walker in the 1980s

The Wedding Cake Model, developed by Samuel Walker in the 1980s, is a model of crime that consists of four primary groups. The model is unique in that it differentiates types of crimes by their severity, the relationship between the victim and offender, and how the cases are treated by the media and society.

The model draws its name from the classic shape of a wedding cake, with its stacked tiers or layers. The base layer represents the least severe and most common offences, typically misdemeanours and traffic violations, and the top layer represents a small number of widely known "celebrated cases". The two layers in between represent violent and non-violent felonies.

The Wedding Cake Model was introduced to the field of criminal justice in the 1980s by Samuel Walker, an accountability or police accountability specialist. Walker proposed the model as a replacement for the Reagan Crime Commission's criminal justice model, which was in use at the time. He presented the idea in his 1985 publication, "Sense and Nonsense About Crime, Drugs, and Communities", which the Department of Justice describes as "an analysis of conservative, moderate, and liberal crime control policies".

In his book, Walker delved into topics such as the effectiveness of the criminal justice system in controlling crime, punishment in the system, strategies for closing loopholes, and the treatment of repeat or habitual offenders. The Wedding Cake Model reflects how limited resources and public attention influenced the prioritisation of cases in many jurisdictions across the United States.

The Wedding Cake Model remains widely used today, nearly 40 years after its introduction. The model continues to be relevant as it reflects the reality of finite resources and the impact of media attention on criminal justice priorities.

It consists of four primary groups

The wedding cake model, first introduced by Samuel Walker in the 1980s, is a model of crime that consists of four primary groups. The model is a metaphor for different levels of crime and their severity. It gets its name from the classic shape of a wedding cake, with the smallest, most attention-grabbing crimes at the top, and the largest volume of less-severe offences at the base.

The first group, or the base layer, consists of misdemeanours. These are the least dangerous types of crimes, such as public intoxication, prostitution, or graffiti. These crimes are usually resolved with a monetary fine and are processed rapidly without media attention.

The second group consists of lesser felonies, which are less severe and often remain invisible to the general public. These include non-violent offences involving financial or drug-related crimes.

The third group is made up of serious felonies, such as rape and aggravated assault. There is less chance of a plea agreement before the trial, and bail may not be an option.

The fourth and final group consists of high-profile, "celebrated cases" that garner a lot of media attention. These cases often involve celebrities or other big names and spark public debate. Examples include the O.J. Simpson trial and police brutality cases.

It reflects how limited resources and public attention shape case prioritisation

The Wedding Cake Model, developed by Samuel Walker in the 1980s, is a model of crime that reflects how limited resources and public attention shape case prioritisation. The model consists of four primary groups, with crimes classified based on their nature and severity. The wedding cake metaphor is used due to its tiered structure, with the smallest, most attention-grabbing crimes at the top, and the largest volume of less-severe offences at the base.

The bottom layer of the model represents the least severe and most common offences, often misdemeanors and traffic violations, which are handled rapidly and without media attention. This layer is almost entirely made up of first-time offenders, who usually receive a monetary fine and probation rather than jail time.

The second layer from the bottom consists of low-level felonies that hurt another person but do not result in death. Offenders in this tier may face jail time or probation, with sentences typically less than five years.

The third layer from the bottom is made up of serious, high-level felonies that have resulted in significant injury or death. Offenders in this tier are mostly career criminals and face significant jail time, typically above five years.

The top layer represents a small number of high-profile, "celebrated cases" that garner a great deal of media attention and spark public debate. These cases often involve celebrities or other well-known individuals.

The Wedding Cake Model highlights the impact of media coverage on public perception and criminal justice priorities. It also reflects the reality of finite resources and how they are allocated across different tiers of cases. This model provides insights into the criminal justice system, including the disproportionate focus on a few top-tier cases, which can divert attention and resources from lower-tier cases.

Frequently asked questions