Understanding The Wedding Cake Model Of Justice

The Wedding Cake Model of Justice, developed by Samuel Walker, is a theory that explains how cases move through the criminal justice system and how they may be treated differently by media and society. The model is based on the idea that the criminal justice system is like a wedding cake, with different tiers or layers. Each layer represents a different level of criminal cases, ranging from petty crimes to the most severe and violent offences. The bottom layer, which is the largest, represents misdemeanours and minor offences, while the top layer, which is the smallest, represents high-profile celebrated cases. The layers in between represent varying levels of felonies, from least to most serious. This model is significant as it provides a clear distinction between high-profile cases and the majority of criminal proceedings, which are typically less sensational and receive little to no media attention.

Misdemeanours: The bottom layer of the wedding cake model, misdemeanours are the least dangerous types of crimes

Misdemeanours make up the bottom layer of the wedding cake model of criminal justice. This layer represents the most significant number of cases handled by the system. Misdemeanours are the least dangerous types of crimes, often involving first-time offenders, and can include public intoxication, prostitution, graffiti, petty theft, disturbing the peace, minor acts of vandalism, and traffic violations. These crimes are usually resolved when the defendant makes a plea agreement and may result in a monetary fine rather than jail time.

The bottom layer of the wedding cake model is the largest, reflecting the high volume of misdemeanour cases in the criminal justice system. These cases are often processed rapidly and without media attention, as they are considered less newsworthy than more serious crimes. The assembly line nature of processing these cases allows the criminal justice system to handle the large number of misdemeanours that come through the system.

While misdemeanours are the least severe type of crime, they still have consequences. Defendants may be required to pay a monetary fine, be placed on probation, or, in some cases, serve a short jail sentence of less than a year. However, it is uncommon for misdemeanour cases to go to trial, as most people with minor crimes are offered and accept plea bargains.

The lack of media coverage of misdemeanours is notable. Newspapers and other news outlets rarely report on these types of crimes as they are considered too common and uninteresting. As a result, the public may be less aware of the high volume of misdemeanour cases in the criminal justice system.

The bottom layer of the wedding cake model, representing misdemeanours, is an important component of the model as it highlights the reality of the criminal justice system. While high-profile cases may dominate media coverage, misdemeanours make up a significant portion of the cases handled by the system. Understanding the bottom layer of the wedding cake model provides a more accurate picture of how the criminal justice system functions on a daily basis.

Lesser felonies: The third tier of the model, these are less severe and often remain less visible to the general public

The Wedding Cake Model of Criminal Justice, developed by Samuel Walker, is a model that differentiates types of crimes by their nature and severity. The model is structured like a wedding cake, with four layers, each representing a different level of crime. The third tier of the model, Layer 2, is made up of lesser felonies, which are less severe and often remain out of the public eye.

The third tier typically involves non-violent crimes, such as financial or drug-related offences. These crimes are usually committed by first-time offenders or those who have a relationship with the victim. Cases in this tier are often resolved through plea agreements, and sentences are generally shorter than those in the second tier. For example, a person speeding five miles over the speed limit on the interstate is unlikely to be pulled over or spend time in court. They will likely pay a fine, which admits guilt, and the case will be closed.

The third tier is also where many low-level violent crimes are placed. These crimes hurt another person but do not result in death. Offenders in this tier may face jail time, but it is usually short, less than five years. Some examples of crimes in this tier include stalking, theft, and DUI (first-time offences).

The third tier of the Wedding Cake Model is significant because it highlights the reality of the criminal justice system. While high-profile cases receive a lot of media attention, the majority of cases handled by the system fall into the third tier. These cases are often processed quickly and without much fanfare. The model also shows how cases in this tier are treated differently by the media and society compared to more serious crimes.

Serious felonies: The second tier of the model, these are more violent in nature and may include charges such as aggravated battery or rape

The Wedding Cake Model of Justice, developed by Samuel Walker, is a theory that attempts to demonstrate how cases move through the criminal justice system and how they may be treated differently by media and society. The model is represented by a four-tiered wedding cake, with the smallest, most attention-grabbing crimes at the top and the largest volume of less-severe offences at the base.

The second tier of the model consists of serious felonies, which are more violent in nature. These offences include aggravated battery, rape, and other violent crimes such as Robbery in the First Degree and Burglary in the First Degree. These crimes tend to generate significant public concern and can result in serious consequences for those convicted. While bail is often denied for these offences, it is not always the case.

Serious felonies are considered level two cases and require the full attention of the criminal justice system. They are handled in the highest criminal courts, along with level one cases, which are high-profile cases involving celebrities or other prominent figures. These second-tier cases often involve violent crimes against individuals, such as assault, battery, or sexual assault. They can also include significant white-collar crimes and large-scale drug offences, which can have a significant impact on society.

The consequences of being convicted of a serious felony are severe and can include lengthy prison sentences. For example, in New York, Class "B" felonies, which include violent felonies like Rape in the First Degree, carry a minimum sentence of five years in prison and a maximum sentence of 25 years. The impact of these crimes on the victims and society as a whole is also profound, often resulting in physical, emotional, and psychological trauma.

The prosecution of serious felonies is generally handled with strict guidelines, as outlined in various penal codes. For example, plea bargaining is prohibited in cases involving violent sex crimes or the use of firearms. The criminal justice system aims to address these serious felonies with the appropriate level of attention and severity, ensuring that offenders are brought to justice and that victims receive the support and justice they deserve.

High-profile cases: The top layer of the model, these cases involve celebrities or other big names and garner a great deal of media attention

The wedding cake model of criminal justice, developed by Samuel Walker, is a model that categorises crimes into four tiers based on their nature and severity. The top tier of the model, representing the smallest part of the cake, is reserved for high-profile cases that involve celebrities or other notable figures and attract significant media attention. These cases are often referred to as "celebrated cases" and can spark public debates about societal issues.

The cases in this tier differ significantly from those in the lower tiers, not only in terms of media coverage but also in the resources allocated to them within the criminal justice system. High-profile cases receive the full attention of the system, with access to highly competent legal counsel, expert witnesses, and extensive trial and appeal processes. The time and resources devoted to these cases can be substantial.

Examples of top-tier cases include the O.J. Simpson trial, Ted Bundy, and police brutality cases such as the Rodney King case. These cases have not only captured the public's imagination but have also had a lasting impact on society and the criminal justice system. For instance, the Rodney King case led to public outcry against police misconduct and prompted reforms within law enforcement agencies.

The extensive media coverage of high-profile cases can shape public perception of crime, justice, and safety. The public may perceive these cases as representative of the norm within the justice system, even though they constitute a small proportion of criminal proceedings. This disproportionate coverage can influence public opinion, impacting voting behaviours and indirectly leading to changes in criminal justice policy.

The wedding cake model highlights the differences in treatment and perception between high-profile cases and the more common, less sensational cases in the lower tiers. By illustrating the proportions of crimes and the allocation of resources, the model provides valuable insights into the criminal justice system and helps predict sentencing possibilities for various offences.

The role of media: The model highlights the role of the media in shaping public perception of crime and safety

The wedding cake model of criminal justice, developed by Samuel Walker in the 1980s, is a framework that divides crimes into four layers, or tiers, of severity. The model is so-called because it resembles a wedding cake, with the largest layer at the bottom and the smallest at the top. The top layer represents a small number of "celebrated cases" that are widely known and receive extensive media coverage. The bottom layer, by contrast, represents the least severe and most common offences, such as misdemeanours and traffic violations, which are rapidly processed and rarely make the news.

The model highlights the role of the media in shaping public perception of crime and safety. Media coverage of crime tends to focus disproportionately on violent, shocking, or high-profile cases, which do not accurately reflect the majority of criminal cases that occur. This can create a skewed perception of the criminal justice system, as people may believe that these high-profile cases are more common than they are.

The extensive coverage of high-profile cases can also impact public policy. Media portrayals of criminal cases can shape public opinions and perceptions, which in turn can influence voting behaviour and lead to changes in criminal justice policy. On the other hand, under-reporting of crimes can lead to a lack of urgency in addressing them. For example, the majority of crimes are in the lower tiers of the wedding cake model, but the lack of media coverage may mean that voters are less likely to advocate for policies related to these crimes.

The wedding cake model is a useful tool for understanding the criminal justice system and how it is portrayed in the media. It is important to recognise that media coverage can shape public perceptions and influence the outcome of criminal cases.

Frequently asked questions