Choosing The Perfect Frosting For Your Wedding Cake

Wedding cakes are often some of the most beautiful and best-tasting cakes you'll ever come across. The frosting on a wedding cake is an important part of its design and flavour, and there are many types of frosting to choose from. From fondant to Swiss meringue buttercream, each type of frosting has its own unique taste, texture, and finish. The type of frosting you choose will depend on your personal preference, the design of the cake, and the setting of the wedding.

Fondant: a sweet sugar paste, perfect for intricate designs and warm-weather weddings

Fondant is a sweet sugar paste that is perfect for creating a clean, polished, and elegant look for your wedding cake. It is a firm sugar icing that is extremely versatile and can be easily dyed, making it a great choice for intricate designs. For example, you can add edible illustrations, sugar crystals, flowers, and other decorative elements to a fondant-covered cake.

Fondant is also a good option for warm-weather weddings as it holds up well in warmer temperatures and will keep your cake fresh. This is especially important if your wedding is outdoors or in a warm climate, as you want to ensure your cake remains in good condition throughout the event.

One potential downside of fondant is that it may not be as tasty as other frosting options, and some people may choose to peel it off before eating the cake. However, this can be mitigated by layering buttercream or another frosting underneath the fondant, ensuring that your cake still tastes delicious even if some guests choose to remove the fondant.

Fondant is also the most expensive frosting option, so it may not be suitable if you are working with a tight budget. However, if you are looking for a beautiful and elegant cake that will impress your guests and complement your wedding theme, fondant is definitely worth considering.

Overall, fondant is an excellent choice for couples who want a wedding cake that is both visually stunning and able to withstand warm temperatures. With its versatility and ability to enhance the aesthetics of your cake, fondant is a popular option for creating a memorable and elegant dessert for your special day.

American Buttercream: a classic, affordable option, suitable for most temperatures

American Buttercream is a sweet, creamy, and affordable option for wedding cakes. It is sturdy, pipes well, and holds its shape. It is also versatile and can be tailored to fit any style, aesthetic, and wedding theme. It is also suitable for most temperatures and can be left out at room temperature for a couple of days.

American Buttercream is made by combining butter and confectioners' sugar or powdered sugar. It is the easiest and fastest type of buttercream to make and can be flavoured in various ways, such as berry, caramel, chocolate, espresso, or peanut butter. It is also a blank canvas for whatever flavour you can imagine. For example, you can add spices, nut butters, booze, chocolate, nuts, preserves, berries, citrus zest and juice, herbs, fruit powders, coffee powder, or vanilla beans.

When making American Buttercream, it is important to whip the butter well before adding the sugar. Sifting the sugar beforehand is also recommended, as it helps break out clumps. Adding the sugar slowly, 1/2 cup to 1 cup at a time, and whipping well in between additions is key to achieving a smooth and silky buttercream.

Once all the sugar is added, whip for at least 3 minutes, and then add only as much liquid (cream, milk, or water) as needed to reach the desired consistency. Whip some more until the frosting is completely smooth.

American Buttercream is a great option for those who want a classic, affordable, and versatile frosting for their wedding cake that will hold up in most temperatures.

Italian or Swiss Meringue Buttercream: less sweet, fluffy, and sturdy, but avoid for outdoor summer weddings

Italian and Swiss Meringue Buttercreams are less sweet and have a fluffy, buttery texture. They are also sturdier than American buttercream, which is why they are a good choice for a wedding cake. However, they are not suitable for outdoor summer weddings.

Italian and Swiss Meringue Buttercreams are made by adding cubes of softened butter to a sweet base of egg foam. This is known as the 'cubed-butter method'. For Swiss Meringue Buttercream, the egg whites and sugar are heated to a temperature of 120 degrees over a pan of hot water, then beaten and cooled. For Italian Meringue Buttercream, hot sugar syrup is poured into a mixer with egg whites. Both methods require careful mixing to create a water-in-fat emulsion.

These buttercreams are less sweet than American buttercream because they are made with butter and have a soft, fluffy, buttery taste. They are also sturdier than American buttercream, which is why they are a good choice for a wedding cake. Wedding cakes are often displayed for long periods of time and may be transported to different locations, so a sturdy frosting is important.

However, Italian and Swiss Meringue Buttercreams are not suitable for outdoor summer weddings. While they hold up pretty well in warmer temperatures, they do contain raw eggs, which can be a food safety issue if the wedding is outdoors in hot weather. Additionally, the butter in these frostings can start to melt in very warm temperatures, causing the frosting to become a sad little puddle.

If you want to use Italian or Swiss Meringue Buttercream for a wedding cake, it is best to choose an indoor venue or an outdoor venue with a cool, shaded area for the cake. It is also important to bring the frosting to room temperature before serving, as cold buttercream is very firm and less creamy.

Cream Cheese Buttercream Blend: tasty, but can have a yellow tint

One popular option for wedding cake frosting is a cream cheese buttercream blend. This type of frosting is a tasty choice, particularly for couples who enjoy carrot cake with cream cheese frosting, or red velvet or lemon cake. The addition of cream cheese to the buttercream creates an insanely tasty flavour that complements these cake flavours nicely.

However, one potential downside of this type of frosting is that it can sometimes have a yellow tint due to the cream cheese. While the yellow hue is not always desirable, it can be minimised by properly blending the cream cheese with the buttercream, resulting in a softer white colour.

When choosing a frosting for a wedding cake, it is important to consider not only the flavour but also the appearance and stability of the frosting, especially if the wedding is taking place in warm weather. Fondant, for example, is often used for its ability to create intricate designs and provide a flawless, smooth finish. It is also stable for indoor or outdoor display for up to ten hours, making it a good choice for warm-weather weddings. However, some people may find fondant too thick or sweet, and it is usually the most expensive option.

Another popular choice is American buttercream, which is a classic, affordable option that works well for elegant or rustic designs. It can also stay stable for up to six hours in most temperatures, making it suitable for indoor or outdoor weddings. However, some people may find buttercream too sweet, so it can be paired with a filling of whipped cream and fresh fruit to balance the flavours.

Whipped Cream Frosting: delicious and light, but can only be used for a smooth finish

Wedding cakes are usually some of the best-tasting and most beautiful cakes you'll come across. The frosting is a key part of this, and there are many types to choose from, each with its own unique characteristics. One such type is whipped cream frosting, which offers a delicious and light taste sensation. However, it is important to note that whipped cream frosting is only suitable for a smooth finish.

Whipped cream frosting is a popular choice for those who want a light and fluffy texture. It is often described as having a delicate almond flavour, although other flavourings such as lemon can be added. This type of frosting is perfect for those who find other icings too sweet, as it offers a more subtle taste experience. It is also a good option for those who want to avoid the use of butter, as it can be made without it.

One of the key benefits of whipped cream frosting is its stability. It holds up well for decorating and can even withstand transport and warm temperatures. This makes it a surprisingly durable option for a wedding cake, as long as it is not exposed to extreme heat. It is important to note, however, that whipped cream frosting is not suitable for all types of decoration. It is best suited to a smooth finish, as it cannot be used for intricate piping or complex designs.

Preparing whipped cream frosting requires a few key ingredients, including heavy cream, powdered sugar, and flavourings such as vanilla or almond extract. It is important to beat the frosting for a sufficient amount of time to achieve the desired light and fluffy texture. This can be done using a mixer or a food processor. Leftover frosting can be stored in the refrigerator, but it is important to bring it back to room temperature and give it a quick mix before using it again.

While whipped cream frosting offers a delicious and light option for wedding cakes, it is important to consider its limitations. It may not be suitable for outdoor weddings or warm climates, as it can become runny and difficult to work with. Additionally, it may not be the best choice for those who want a more complex or intricate cake design. However, for those who want a simple, elegant, and delicious frosting, whipped cream can be a perfect choice.

Frequently asked questions