Buttercream Vs Fondant: Which Is The Best For Wedding Cakes?

Choosing the right icing for a wedding cake is a crucial decision. The two main types of icing used on wedding cakes are fondant and buttercream, and each has its advantages and disadvantages. Fondant is usually made of sugar, corn syrup, and water, melted together to form a clay-like consistency, which makes it ideal for creating decorative elements such as shapes, patterns, and flowers. It also provides a polished appearance and is easy to transport. On the other hand, buttercream, a combination of butter and sugar, offers a soft, creamy consistency, a rich taste, and is ideal for piping and decorating with fresh flowers. It is also less expensive than fondant. However, buttercream is not suitable for sculpting and can be challenging to transport due to its smooth texture and sensitivity to heat and humidity.

Fondant is more expensive but offers a flawless, smooth finish

Fondant is more expensive than buttercream, but it offers a flawless, smooth finish.

Fondant is made by melting together sugar, corn syrup, and water, and sometimes includes gelatin or marshmallows. This creates a clay-like consistency, which is easy to roll out and cover cakes with. Fondant has a candy-like flavour and is very sweet. It is also great for sculpting, making it ideal for creating decorations such as flowers, basket weave patterns, bows, cutouts, and toppers. Fondant is more stable than buttercream and can hold its shape for longer, making it a good option for outdoor events and transportation.

Fondant is a popular choice for traditional-style cakes, as it has a similar aesthetic to royal icing but without the tooth-chipping hardness. It can be made brilliantly white or used for modelling vibrant novelty cakes. Fondant provides a polished appearance and a clean, beautiful finish.

However, fondant cannot be piped, and some people may not like its very sweet taste and rubbery texture, often choosing to remove it before eating the cake. Fondant also dries quickly, which can cause cracks in the exterior of the cake. Due to its hard texture, it can be difficult to cut through with a fork and is not suitable as a filling between cake layers. Fondant is also more time-consuming and labour-intensive to work with, which contributes to its higher cost.

Despite the drawbacks, fondant is the way to go if you want a flawless, smooth finish and cost is not a concern. It is stable, pliable, and can be shaped into various designs, making it a popular choice for couples seeking a visually stunning wedding cake.

Buttercream is a guest favourite due to its taste and texture

When it comes to choosing a wedding cake, one of the most important considerations is the icing. Do you go for the rich, creamy taste of buttercream or the malleable, shaping capabilities of fondant? Well, if it's taste and texture that are the priority, then buttercream is the guest favourite.

Buttercream is a combination of butter and sugar, whipped together to create a soft, fluffy, creamy frosting. This gives it a rich, sweet, creamy texture and taste that is often preferred over fondant. It is also less sugary than fondant, especially if you opt for Swiss meringue buttercream, which has 50% less sugar. This type of buttercream is also great for taking on other flavours, from light citrus to tangy cream cheese.

Fondant, on the other hand, has an intense sweetness that can be overpowering when paired with an already sweet cake. It is made from powdered sugar, water and glycerine, or sugar, corn syrup and water, creating a paste that can be rolled out thinly. While it is versatile for creating decorations and modelling, it is not ideal for piping and can be difficult to cut through when eating.

Buttercream, with its lighter texture, is much easier to cut and bite through. It also has a creaminess that complements the crumb of the cake. While it may not be ideal for intricate sculpting, it is perfect for piping and creating flowers, designs and piped edges. It is also a more lightweight option, meaning you can spread it thickly without compromising the texture of the cake.

So, if you're looking for a cake that your guests will sweetly reminisce about for years to come, buttercream is the way to go. Its taste and texture make it a favourite among guests, and its versatility means it can be adapted to suit any wedding theme or colour scheme.

Fondant is great for sculpting and creating decorations

Fondant is a great option for couples who want a flawless, clean aesthetic for their wedding cake. Fondant is made from sugar, water, corn syrup, and sometimes gelatin, creating a clay-like consistency that is easy to work with and great for sculpting and creating decorations.

Fondant's malleable, dough-like texture enables cake designers to create smooth finishes and/or elaborate structural elements. Fondant is ideal for creating decorations such as sugar flowers, basket weave patterns, bows, ruffles, cutouts, and cake toppers. Fondant is also suitable for painting and creating intricate patterns or designs. If you're looking for a cake with a lot of decorative details, fondant is a good choice.

Fondant also provides a polished appearance, creating a clean and beautiful finish. It can be rolled out thinly and easily to cover the exterior of a cake with a beautiful pattern or finish. Fondant can also be coloured with food dye to match any colour scheme.

Fondant is also a good choice for outdoor weddings or transportation as it is more stable than buttercream and can hold its shape and form for longer. It is also less likely to melt in warm climates or on hot days, making it a better option for spring and summer weddings.

Buttercream is more susceptible to heat and harder to transport

Buttercream is a soft, rich, and thick icing that is a popular choice for those who want to serve a delicious cake on their big day. It is made from butter and sugar, whipped together for a soft, creamy consistency. However, one of its main drawbacks is that it is more susceptible to heat and harder to transport than fondant.

Buttercream's soft and creamy texture makes it more prone to melting in high temperatures and humid conditions. This can be a significant issue for outdoor weddings or events in hot weather, as the frosting may become soft, runny, or even melt completely. Therefore, if you choose buttercream for your wedding cake, it is crucial to ensure proper storage and transportation conditions to maintain its shape and texture.

Transporting a buttercream cake can be challenging due to its smooth and creamy nature. It may slide during transport, especially if the cake is transported in a car. Sudden stops or bumps can also cause the icing to dent or shift, affecting the overall appearance of the cake. To minimise these risks, it is recommended to keep buttercream cakes in a cool, dark, and dry place, with minimal exposure to heat.

Additionally, when transporting a buttercream cake, it is essential to keep it in a box. This helps to protect the cake from direct exposure to the refrigerator's cold air, preventing it from becoming sticky. It is also crucial to ensure that the cake is not placed near any strong-smelling items, as buttercream can absorb these odours.

In summary, while buttercream is a delicious and popular choice for wedding cakes, its susceptibility to heat and transport challenges are important considerations. Proper planning, storage, and transportation methods are key to ensuring the success of a buttercream wedding cake.

Fondant is not ideal for piping

Fondant is made from sugar, corn syrup, and water, which are melted together. It has a gummy texture and a clay-like consistency, which makes it ideal for creating decorative elements such as shapes, patterns, and flowers. Fondant is also easy to transfer and transport, and cakes with a fondant finish can stay fresh in the fridge for days, making it a good choice for spring or summer weddings.

Buttercream, on the other hand, is made from butter and sugar, whipped together to create a soft and creamy consistency. It is rich in taste and can be flavoured in a variety of ways. Buttercream is ideal for piping and decorating with fresh flowers. It is a good choice for a rustic or chic cake and is usually less expensive than fondant. However, buttercream is not suitable for sculpting and does not lie flat. It is also more susceptible to heat and humidity and is harder to transport than fondant.

While both fondant and buttercream have their advantages and disadvantages, buttercream is generally considered a better option for piping due to its smooth texture and ease of piping. Fondant, while providing a polished and beautiful finish, is not ideal for piping due to its clay-like consistency and gummy texture.

Frequently asked questions