Wedding Bands: Metal Pros And Cons

There are many pros and cons to the different types of men's wedding bands. From traditional metals like gold, platinum, and silver, to more contemporary options like tungsten, titanium, and cobalt chrome, each material has its unique set of advantages and drawbacks. Factors such as durability, scratch resistance, weight, hypoallergenic properties, affordability, and style play a crucial role in the selection process.

Black wedding bands are affordable, but can't be resized

Black wedding bands are a unique and affordable alternative to traditional wedding rings made from metals such as gold or platinum. They are typically made from metals such as tungsten, carbon fibre, or titanium, and are known for their scratch resistance and durability.

However, one significant drawback of black wedding bands is that they cannot be resized. Unlike gold or platinum rings, which can be adjusted by a jeweller, black wedding bands are often made from materials that cannot be cut, reshaped, or resized. This means that if your ring no longer fits comfortably, you will need to purchase an entirely new ring. This can be costly and may diminish the symbolic value of the original wedding ring.

While black wedding bands offer a modern and trendy alternative to traditional styles, their inability to be resized may be a significant consideration for those looking to purchase a wedding band. It is important to carefully weigh the pros and cons of different wedding band materials before making a final decision.

In addition to their affordability and scratch resistance, black wedding bands offer several other advantages. They are hypoallergenic, making them a safe choice for individuals with metal allergies. Their dark and edgy appearance is highly sought-after and offers a unique look compared to traditional wedding bands.

However, black wedding bands also come with some potential drawbacks beyond their inability to be resized. They may not be as timeless as traditional styles and could go out of fashion in the future. Additionally, they cannot be repaired if broken and may need to be smashed off during medical emergencies. The heavy metals used in their construction can also be distracting for those who are not used to wearing rings.

Gold is highly malleable, but requires rhodium plating

Gold is a highly malleable metal, which means it can be crafted into a wide variety of styles and shapes for men's wedding bands. This is not the case with harder metals like tungsten and titanium. However, one of the drawbacks of gold is that it requires rhodium plating, especially white gold.

Rhodium is a silvery-white metal in the platinum family that is highly reflective and does not tarnish. It is also harder than gold and extremely durable. When used as a plating, it increases the resilience of gold rings from scratches and adds an elegant, reflective white finish. It is commonly applied to white gold jewellery but may also be used for silver and other precious metals.

Rhodium plating is often advertised as a tough coating that will protect gold jewellery from knocks and scratches. While rhodium is a tough metal, it is too brittle to be made into jewellery. Plating is only ever microns thick, so it hardly serves as protective armour for gold rings. Rings are the most at-risk jewellery for wear and tear as they come into contact with various surfaces throughout the day. When a rhodium-plated ring hits a harder metal, it will leave a mark or wear down the rhodium plating over time.

One of the benefits of rhodium plating is that it is hypoallergenic. It is devoid of nickel and other harmful materials commonly applied to jewellery. This makes it a good option for people who have sensitive skin or metal allergies.

Another advantage of rhodium plating is its longevity. When used to plate a piece of jewellery, it adds resistance against scrapes and scratches.

The biggest disadvantage of rhodium plating is its cost. Because rhodium is two times more expensive than gold, applying a rhodium coat can be expensive. Even rhodium plating a small piece of jewellery can cost upwards of $100. And because rhodium wears off after a while, you will need to spend another $100+ to have your jewellery replated.

Rhodium plating is also less common in small suburbs. Independent jewellers don’t always offer rhodium plating services. So you might have to take your business out of town. Some jewellers offer a mailing option, but many are reluctant to use it for fear of their collections being lost.

The process of rhodium plating is also incredibly toxic to the environment. Most commonly, the electroplating process is used, so don't be fooled by the term 'dipping'. This process involves dipping the jewellery into a heated tank of rhodium sulphate, sulphuric acid and water. An electric current is run through the jewellery, which acts as a cathode or negative electrode so that the rhodium particles are attracted to it, forming a permanent bond between the metals. The resulting effect is a micron-thick coating on the outside of the jewellery.

In addition, rhodium plating requires regular maintenance. For rings that are worn daily, the plating may start coming off after a year due to hand-washing, dish-washing, friction from gripping things, etc. When the plating wears off, the metal colour starts to tarnish, revealing the original yellowish hue. This becomes apparent at the bottom of the jewellery where most pieces receive the most wear and tear.

Rhodium plating is an effective way to increase the aesthetic appeal of gold jewellery while protecting it from blemishes and scratches. Though not strictly required, it is recommended for high-end pieces that you wear on a regular basis. Wedding rings, for instance, are often plated with a rhodium solution.

Platinum is hypoallergenic and low-maintenance

Platinum is a popular choice for men's wedding bands due to its hypoallergenic qualities and low-maintenance requirements.

Firstly, platinum is hypoallergenic, meaning it is unlikely to cause an allergic reaction. This is because platinum is 95% pure, unlike other metals such as gold and sterling silver, which are often mixed with alloys that can trigger allergies. Platinum is also highly unreactive, so it won't oxidise or be affected by common acids, sweat, body oils, or cosmetics. This makes it an excellent choice for those with sensitive skin.

In addition to being hypoallergenic, platinum is also low-maintenance. It is a strong and durable metal that doesn't tarnish, corrode, or easily wear down. With daily use, platinum jewellery will not wear out easily over time. Even if it does get scratched, platinum can be easily polished back to its original state. Platinum is also a good choice for diamond settings as its silvery-white colour enhances the sparkle of diamonds.

While platinum may be more expensive than other metals due to its rarity, its hypoallergenic and low-maintenance qualities make it a good investment for a piece of jewellery that will last a lifetime.

Titanium is lightweight and exceptionally strong

Titanium is an excellent choice for men's wedding bands due to its unique combination of strength, durability, and lightweight comfort. With the highest strength-to-weight ratio among metals, titanium rings are incredibly durable and resistant to wear and tear, making them ideal for daily wear and active individuals.

One of the standout features of titanium is its exceptional strength. Titanium is as strong as steel but 45% lighter, making it a lightweight metal that is extremely comfortable for prolonged wear. Its resilience ensures that titanium rings can withstand the test of time and everyday use, making it a popular choice for those seeking a stylish and long-lasting wedding band.

In addition to its strength and lightweight properties, titanium is also highly scratch-resistant, retaining its shine over the years. This makes titanium a low-maintenance option, as the rings require minimal upkeep to maintain their natural colour and lustre. Titanium's resistance to scratches and dents also contributes to its overall durability, ensuring that it can endure accidental damage.

Furthermore, titanium is a hypoallergenic metal, making it perfect for individuals with sensitive skin. Its hypoallergenic nature ensures that titanium rings won't cause allergic reactions, allowing for comfortable daily wear. This feature, combined with its lightweight comfort, makes titanium an excellent choice for those seeking a wedding band that can be worn effortlessly every day.

Titanium's versatility in design is another advantage. Its adaptability allows it to be crafted into a wide range of styles, from sleek and minimalist designs to intricate and detailed patterns. Titanium rings cater to various tastes, whether one prefers a classic, elegant look or a more contemporary, bold statement.

Overall, titanium wedding bands offer a blend of characteristics that are hard to match. With their exceptional strength, durability, lightweight comfort, and hypoallergenic properties, titanium rings provide a stylish, affordable, and long-lasting option for men's wedding bands.

White gold is luxurious, but may cause skin irritation

White gold is a popular choice for men's wedding bands, and it's easy to see why. This precious metal is timeless, with a neutral colour that matches any outfit or style. Its silvery sheen exudes a contemporary vibe while retaining a touch of classical elegance. It is also more affordable than platinum, though it is less durable and may require more upkeep.

One of the biggest downsides of white gold is that it may not be the right choice for those with sensitive skin. White gold is not pure gold but is created by mixing the natural gold with other white metals, such as silver, palladium, or nickel. These alloys could irritate your skin if you have a sensitivity to them. White gold is also not hypoallergenic, and many people are allergic to the alloys used, which can cause skin irritation.

If you know you have allergies or sensitive skin, it is essential to consider this when choosing a wedding band. Platinum, for example, is a hypoallergenic metal and may be a better option for those with skin sensitivities. While white gold is a beautiful and luxurious choice, it may not be the best option for everyone due to the potential for skin irritation.

Additionally, white gold requires more maintenance than platinum. To maintain its white colour, white gold needs to be rhodium-plated periodically, which can be costly and time-consuming over the lifetime of the ring. Without rhodium plating, white gold would have a yellow tonal finish due to the high concentration of yellow gold in the alloy. This is something to consider if you are looking for a low-maintenance wedding band.

In conclusion, white gold is a luxurious and elegant choice for a men's wedding band, offering a timeless and versatile look. However, its potential to cause skin irritation and its high maintenance requirements are important considerations. If you have sensitive skin or prefer a low-maintenance option, you may want to explore other metal choices, such as platinum.

Frequently asked questions