My Big Gypsy Wedding": Fact Or Fiction

My Big Fat Gypsy Wedding is a reality TV show that first aired in the UK in 2010 and was later adapted for US audiences by TLC in 2012. The show focuses on the marriage customs of Romani-Americans, or gypsies, and features over-the-top wedding dresses, teen brides, and trailer park fighting matches. While the show gained popularity, it has also faced a lot of criticism and controversy. Many have accused the show of being fake and misleading, with one of the participants, Priscilla Kelly, revealing that producers faked weddings and engagements. The show has also been criticised for perpetuating negative stereotypes, racism, and causing racially motivated bullying. Members of the Romani community have spoken out against the show, stating that it misrepresents their culture and promotes racist stereotypes.

The show omits major cultural details

One of the biggest criticisms of the show is that it groups Travellers and Roma together, despite there being very prominent differences between the two cultures. Travellers are ethnic Irish, while the Roma came from Eastern Europe and India. Seyward Darby, online editor for The New Republic, explains:

> Viewers are instead offered an overly simplistic view of the cultures of Travellers and Roma with scarcely any historical or political context about their place in the United Kingdom and Europe. There is no explanation of why tradition dictated for centuries that they live nomadic lifestyles.

European Roma, Pip, seconds this in an open letter to the show's producers, writing:

> Just 10% of the Gypsy and Traveller population are actually Irish Travellers. The majority, like myself, are in fact Romany, yet your 'documentary' seems to ignore our existence. While Irish Travellers originate from Ireland, we can trace our routes back to India, so it was hardly surprising that I was somewhat confused when you use the word Gypsy in the title of your 'documentary' about Irish Travellers.

The Romani Gypsy community has criticised the series for misrepresenting the ethnic minority with non-Romani characters posing as “Gypsy”. Billy Welch, a spokesman for Romani Gypsies, said:

> They called the show Big Fat Gypsy Wedding and you've yet to see a Romani Gypsy in it.

The American version of the series has faced similar criticism from Romani-Americans, journalists, and activists concerned with minority rights, claiming that the series is “wildly misleading,” cultivating racist stereotypes, and misrepresenting the American Romani community.

The outrageous 'grabbing' ritual isn't real

The TLC reality show "My Big Fat Gypsy Wedding" has been accused of being wildly misleading, perpetuating stereotypes, and misrepresenting the Romani Gypsy community. One of the most controversial aspects of the show is its portrayal of the so-called "grabbing" ritual, which allegedly gives young men permission to grab a woman and use force to receive a kiss.

However, this ritual has been called into question by members of the Romani Gypsy community, who claim that it is not a part of their culture. In an open letter to the show's producers, a male Roma using the pseudonym Pipopotamus wrote sarcastically, "I would have been married by now if only I had known that the key to a woman's heart was to sexually assault her using a Gypsy courting ritual called 'grabbing'. I asked my brother if he had grabbed his wife, but it turned out he had just asked her out on a date instead... It appears that in reality, no one actually knows what grabbing is."

Mary, a 15-year-old Irish Traveller, revealed to The Guardian that "Grabbing has never happened to me or any of my friends and the first time I ever saw it was on the telly. I wouldn't put up with it, and I don't know why they made out we all do it. It's just one nasty boy they showed." Brigid, another Irish Traveller, echoed these sentiments, stating, "Grabbing has never happened to my kids. I have honestly never heard of it. It's all make-believe."

The show's portrayal of the "grabbing" ritual has been criticized for contributing to a negative image of the Romani Gypsy community and perpetuating stereotypes. It is important to recognize that the community already faces discrimination and that such portrayals can have real-world consequences, including bullying and racism directed towards members of the community.

In addition to the concerns about the "grabbing" ritual, the show has also been criticized for its portrayal of wedding dresses, gender roles, education, and economic status. Many members of the Romani Gypsy community have spoken out about the show's inaccuracies and its failure to represent their culture and traditions accurately.

The show doesn't offer access to a secret community

Despite its claims, "My Big Fat Gypsy Wedding" does not actually offer viewers access to a secret community. While the show promises to reveal the hidden world of gypsies and provide exclusive insights into their unique culture, it falls short of delivering on this promise.

The show often teases viewers with statements like "the secrecy behind a Traveller communion is revealed for the first time" or "another important Gypsy [marriage] custom is the cake-cutting". However, as pointed out by The New Republic, these so-called secretive rituals are not arcane or particularly revealing. For example, the "secrecy behind a Traveller communion" turns out to be nothing more than a young girl in a too-big, ornate dress, followed by a large family party—not much different from modern weddings.

The show also fails to provide historical or political context about the place of Traveller and Roma communities in the United Kingdom and Europe. It groups Travellers and Roma together, despite their distinct cultural differences. Seyward Darby, online editor for The New Republic, explains that "Viewers are instead offered an overly simplistic view of the cultures of Travellers and Roma with scarcely any historical or political context about their place in the United Kingdom and Europe."

European Roma, Pip, echoed this sentiment in an open letter to the show's producers, writing: "Just 10% of the Gypsy and Traveller population are actually Irish Travellers. The majority, like myself, are in fact Romany, yet your 'documentary' seems to ignore our existence. While Irish Travellers originate from Ireland, we can trace our routes back to India, so it was hardly surprising that I was somewhat confused when you use the word Gypsy in the title of your 'documentary' about Irish Travellers."

The show's portrayal of these communities as highly secretive and mysterious perpetuates stereotypes and contributes to the misunderstanding of their cultures. In reality, the lives and traditions of Travellers and Roma are far more complex and varied than what is depicted on the show.

The show has had a negative effect on Traveller and Roma communities

The show "My Big Fat Gypsy Wedding" has been accused of having a negative impact on Traveller and Roma communities. The program has been criticized for perpetuating negative stereotypes and causing racial discrimination.

One of the most significant criticisms is that the show groups Travellers and Roma together, despite their distinct cultural differences. This has led to a misunderstanding of their cultures and histories, with viewers and the media perpetuating stereotypes. For instance, the show has been accused of portraying the communities as uneducated and reinforcing the idea that they are secretive. In reality, the communities have been historically persecuted and face social exclusion, with high rates of unemployment and government dependence.

The program has also been criticized for its portrayal of women. One viewer commented that the show depicts women as "nothing but slaves to the men, only good for cooking and cleaning, and always being available to open our legs to them". The show has also been criticized for its portrayal of the "grabbing" ritual, which involves young men grabbing and kissing women without their consent. This ritual has been condemned as a form of sexual assault, and many in the community have stated that they have never heard of or experienced it.

The show's focus on extravagant weddings and over-the-top dresses has also been criticized. One community member commented that the show failed to feature traditional Gypsy and Traveller designers and that the clothing they are known for is far more interesting than what was portrayed. The show has also been accused of promoting the idea that girls are encouraged to leave school at a young age to get married and start families, which is not an accurate representation of their culture.

The negative impact of the show has been felt by community members, with one Irish Traveller mother of six sharing that other parents at her children's school refuse to let their kids play with hers due to the stereotypes perpetuated by the show. The show has also led to racial bullying, with one Twitter user commenting that they "now understand why all of Europe hates gypsies".

The show doesn't accurately represent the Romani community

My Big Fat Gypsy Wedding has been criticised for its misrepresentation of the Romani community. The show has been described as wildly misleading, cultivating racist stereotypes and misrepresenting the Romani-American community. The show has been accused of grouping Travellers and Roma together, despite their distinct cultural differences. Roma Pip, a male Roma, pointed out that the show ignores the existence of the Romani community, focusing instead on Irish Travellers.

The show has also been criticised for its portrayal of Romani and Traveller women as slaves to men, with no lives outside of cooking, cleaning, and being "available to open their legs". One Traveller woman, Helen, stated that the show is a disgrace in its representation of women. The show also fails to address the issue of domestic violence within these communities, as well as the high rates of miscarriage and stillbirth, which are often linked to poor sanitation and a lack of clean water.

The show has been accused of perpetuating stereotypes by portraying members of these communities as uneducated, flashy, and closed-minded people who live in trailer parks and throw enormous parties. In reality, the Roma community in Europe often lives in dire poverty, facing issues such as forced sterilisation, segregation in schools, and forced repatriation. The show's failure to provide historical or political context contributes to this simplistic and inaccurate portrayal.

Thelma Madine, a dressmaker who is not from the Romani or Traveller communities, serves as the show's arbiter of these cultures. Her comments and explanations of these communities' practices further perpetuate stereotypes and misunderstandings.

The show's focus on extravagant weddings and parties, rather than providing a robust and accurate cultural portrait, has led to a deep misunderstanding of these communities. Many viewers have taken to social media to express their negative opinions of the Romani and Traveller communities, further spreading stereotypes and misinformation.

Frequently asked questions