Donuts Over Wedding Cake: A Sweet Substitution?

Donuts are a popular alternative to wedding cake, with many couples opting for this unique and fun option. They can be a more affordable option, and guests often enjoy the variety of flavours and the interactivity of a donut wall or tower. However, some people consider donuts less elegant than cake, and there can be issues with freshness if they are not consumed quickly. It is also considered rude in some cultures to present food that is not offered to guests, so couples choosing donuts may want to consider providing a small cake for cutting and serving alongside the donuts. Overall, donuts can be a delicious and whimsical addition to a wedding, but it is essential to consider the potential drawbacks and plan accordingly.

Donuts are cheaper than cake

Donuts are a fun, unique, and delicious alternative to a traditional wedding cake. They can also be a more affordable option for couples looking to save money on their big day.

The cost of a wedding cake is typically calculated by the slice, with prices ranging from $3 to $12 per serving, depending on the type of cake, fillings, and decorations. On the other hand, donuts are usually priced per donut, and they are significantly cheaper. A standard donut can cost as little as $0.80, while even a specialty donut from a gourmet shop is unlikely to cost more than a few dollars.

For example, one couple shared that they spent around $300 on 350 donuts and 100 donut holes for their wedding of 250 people. In comparison, a traditional wedding cake for the same number of guests could have cost them upwards of $700, assuming an average price of $2 per slice.

Another couple considered a specialty donut shop that quoted them $20 for an 8" donut cake and $18 per two dozen mini donuts. This is a much more affordable option than a traditional wedding cake, which can easily cost a few hundred dollars, depending on the size and complexity of the design.

Donuts can also be a great option for couples who want to offer a variety of dessert options to their guests without breaking the bank. For instance, a couple who chose to have a small cutting cake along with donuts and a coffee cart for their wedding mentioned that the addition of the cake and coffee was still more affordable than a large, traditional wedding cake.

In addition to being a cost-effective option, donuts offer a level of flexibility and convenience that wedding cakes may not. Donuts can often be ordered with just a day's notice, and they can be easily picked up from local shops, eliminating the need for delivery fees. This makes them a great option for couples who are planning their weddings on a shorter timeline or who want to support local businesses.

Overall, donuts are a delicious and affordable alternative to a traditional wedding cake. They offer a unique and memorable experience for guests and can help couples stay within their budget without sacrificing the sweetness of their special day.

Cake is more elegant than donuts

While donuts are a fun and unique alternative to traditional wedding cake, cake is more elegant. Donuts are typically eaten with your hands, whereas cake is eaten with a fork. This makes cake more formal and elegant.

In addition, donuts are often associated with breakfast and cake is considered a dessert. Cake is also seen as more special, as people have it for their birthdays and other celebrations. It is a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to cut into a wedding cake, and the photos of this moment are often cherished.

Furthermore, cake is a more versatile option. It can be decorated in a variety of ways to match any wedding theme, from casual to elegant. It can also be displayed in a variety of ways, such as on a cake stand or as a multi-tiered cake.

While donuts can be dressed up, they may not be as well-suited to all wedding themes. For example, a rustic wedding with a donut display may not be as elegant as a cake display. Donuts may also not stay fresh as long as cake, and there is a possibility of them becoming stale or melting, depending on the type of frosting used.

Overall, while donuts can be a fun and tasty treat, cake is more elegant and versatile for a wedding. It is a traditional dessert that can be dressed up or down to match any wedding theme and create a beautiful and memorable display.

Cake is a traditional wedding dessert

The cake-cutting ceremony is a significant part of the wedding reception, and it usually takes place after the main course and before the dancing begins. It is often accompanied by the couple's first dance and the toasts. The cake is then served to the guests as dessert.

The wedding cake is often a large, multi-tiered creation, elaborately decorated and personalised to the couple's taste and wedding theme. It is typically made from rich fruit cake, Victoria sponge, or chocolate sponge, and covered in icing or fondant.

In recent years, some couples have chosen to replace the traditional wedding cake with alternative desserts such as donuts, cupcakes, or a dessert bar offering a variety of sweet treats. This can be a fun and unique way to add a personal touch to the wedding, especially if the couple has a particular favourite dessert or if they feel that a traditional cake does not suit their wedding style or budget.

However, some people may consider it rude or unacceptable to deviate from the traditional wedding cake, especially if the couple still performs the cake-cutting ceremony but does not serve cake to their guests. In such cases, it is often recommended to have a small cake for the cake-cutting ritual and provide an alternative dessert, such as donuts, for the guests to enjoy.

Donuts may get stale

If you're concerned about your donuts going stale, there are a few things you can do. First, consider the timing of your order. Some bakeries may not let you order too far in advance, but you can always contact them early to discuss your plans and get their advice on timing. It's best to get your donuts delivered as close to your wedding as possible to ensure maximum freshness. You could also ask the bakery about their storage recommendations and whether they have any tips for keeping the donuts fresh during your celebration.

On the day of your wedding, there are a few presentation and display ideas you can use to keep your donuts as fresh as possible. Some people choose to display their donuts on tiered cake stands, while others opt for more creative options like donut walls or hanging them from trees. However, it's important to remember that how you display your donuts can impact their freshness. For example, stacking donuts with pretty icing may ruin the decoration, and certain displays may make it difficult for guests to access the treats without touching or breathing on them. A simple display on a table or tiered stand can be just as beautiful and may help keep your donuts fresher.

If you're concerned about leftovers, you can donate any uneaten donuts or give them to your guests as favors. You could also get creative and find ways to transform stale donuts into other sweet treats. For example, you can soak stale donuts in milk overnight and use the sugary milk to make ice cream, or you can make donut French toast.

How to display donuts

There are many creative ways to display donuts at a wedding. Here are some ideas to help you get started:

Donut Walls

Donut walls are a trendy and modern way to display donuts at a wedding. You can create a wall with shelves, greenery, blooms, and signs that mark each type of donut. Alternatively, you can hang donuts on a wall with hooks or pegs, creating a sky-high stack that your guests can easily grab. Just remember to keep similar flavours together to avoid confusion!

Stands and Trays

If you want to add some height and dimension to your display, consider using stands and trays. You can find stands with multiple levels and layer donuts to create an impressive display. Hunt down some cute dishes and platters that match your wedding theme to make your display even more festive. For a rustic wedding, a stand made from tree trunk slabs and branches is a perfect choice.

Donut Towers

Take inspiration from macaron towers and croquembouche and create a chic and indulgent donut tower. You can even have a giant donut cake as the base of your tower, which you can cut into. Supplement it with individual donuts stacked on tiered platters for a true donut lover's dream.

Combine with a Cake

If you can't decide between a traditional cake and donuts, why not have both? You can replace one tier of your wedding cake with a stack of donuts or add some donuts as a cake topper. Donuts can also be used as decorations on your cake or as part of a larger dessert table.

Creative Displays

For a unique and edgy look, try a copper display with hooks and glazed donuts hanging from them. Alternatively, use a clear round display with holders for a stylish and modern feel. If you're feeling crafty, you can even make your own stand from plywood, metal, or acrylic. Get creative with shapes like hexagons or your monograms in various colours.

Donut Bars

Set up a dedicated donut bar for your guests, complete with coffee and tea. This is a great option for a relaxed and cozy wedding. You can also combine it with a candy bar and provide treat bags for your guests to take home as wedding favours.

No matter which display option you choose, your guests are sure to go nuts for these delicious treats!

Frequently asked questions