A Frozen Wedding Cake: Good Idea Or Not?

It is a long-honoured tradition for married couples to freeze the top layer of their wedding cake to eat on their first anniversary for good luck. But is it a good idea?

Freezing a wedding cake for a year is relatively harmless, as long as it is preserved properly. Experts agree that your biggest worry should be the flavour of the cake. It is unlikely that anything harmful can grow on a frozen cake, but the quality of the cake will suffer over time.

So, if you are thinking of freezing your wedding cake, make sure you follow the correct preservation steps and manage your expectations when it comes to how it will taste a year later.

Freezing wedding cake is safe but not risk-free

Freezing wedding cake is generally safe but not entirely risk-free. The tradition of freezing the top tier of a wedding cake to be eaten on the couple's first anniversary or at the christening of their first child is a long-honoured one. However, it is important to take the necessary steps to preserve the cake properly to avoid any potential risks.

Firstly, it is crucial to remove any large decorations from the cake and wrap it tightly in plastic wrap or cling film, ensuring an airtight seal. The cake should then be placed in an airtight container and stored in the freezer. It is recommended to freeze the cake at a constant food-safe temperature to prevent the growth of harmful substances such as mould.

While freezing a wedding cake for a year will not typically impact food safety, it is essential to consider the potential impact on the cake's quality and flavour. Experts agree that the cake's quality will likely suffer over time, even when properly stored. The texture may change, and the cake may not taste as fresh as it did on the wedding day.

Additionally, there is a risk of the cake acquiring off-flavours from the freezer or developing freezer burn if not wrapped properly. Transporting the frozen cake can also be challenging, especially if the couple moves during the first year of marriage.

To defrost the wedding cake, it is recommended to slowly thaw it in the refrigerator for around 24 hours and then let it sit at room temperature for about an hour before serving. This process helps minimise condensation, which can leave permanent marks on the icing.

In conclusion, while freezing wedding cake is generally safe when proper preservation methods are followed, it is not entirely risk-free. The potential risks include a decline in quality and flavour, off-flavours, freezer burn, and challenges with transport. Therefore, it is essential to carefully consider and follow the recommended preservation and storage guidelines to minimise these risks.

The quality of frozen wedding cake will suffer over time

Firstly, it is important to ensure that the wedding cake is preserved properly. Newlyweds should wrap the top layer of their cake in plastic shrink wrap and tin foil, sealing it inside an airtight container, and placing it into the refrigerator as soon as possible. If the cake is not wrapped and stored properly, it will not keep for a year.

Even if the cake is preserved correctly, it is unlikely to taste as good as it did on the wedding day. One source suggests that the cake might taste stale or sweaty after being frozen. Another source states that the cake won't taste "fresh and delicious" after being frozen.

In addition, there are some potential issues that could arise with freezing a wedding cake. For example, if a couple moves in the first year of marriage, they will have to transport the frozen cake, which could cause issues. Also, condensation can form when the cake is thawed, leaving permanent marks on the icing.

Overall, while it is possible to freeze a wedding cake for a year, the quality of the cake will likely suffer, and it may not taste as good as it did on the wedding day.

How to preserve a wedding cake

Preserving a wedding cake is a long-honoured tradition, but it's not always a tasty one. Experts agree that eating a wedding cake after freezing it for a year is safe, but it's not risk-free. The cake will be stale and the quality will suffer, but it's unlikely that anything harmful can grow on a frozen cake as long as it's not there in the first place.

Before freezing:

• Chill the cake in the refrigerator—this will harden the icing and make it easier to wrap the cake without sticking.
• Remove all decorations—this includes flowers, cake toppers, and other adornments. Even sugar or fondant flowers will spoil quickly. If you want to save sugar flowers as a memento, set them aside in a dry, room-temperature location.
• Remove cardboard—if the cake is on cardboard, transfer it to a plastic board. Otherwise, your cake will absorb the taste of cardboard.
• Pre-freeze the cake—place the cake unwraped in the freezer for an hour or so to let the frosting firm up.

Wrapping and freezing:

• Wrap the cake in plastic wrap—use at least five full layers of plastic wrap to prevent freezer odours and burn from getting into the cake.
• Add a final layer of aluminium foil—this will provide extra protection against freezer burn.
• Place the wrapped cake in an airtight container—this will help to keep the cake fresh and prevent it from drying out.
• Store the cake in a consistent freezer—avoid moving the cake around or defrosting and refrosting it, as this can impact its quality.

When you're ready to eat it:

• Thaw the cake in the refrigerator—take the cake out of the freezer and keep it in the fridge overnight.
• Let it sit at room temperature—leave the cake unwraped at room temperature for five to six hours before eating.

Remember, the cake may not taste as good as it did on your wedding day, but it's still a fun tradition to partake in on your first anniversary!

How to defrost a wedding cake

Preserving a wedding cake in the freezer for a year is a long-honoured tradition for married couples to bring themselves good luck. Freezing a cake for a year is relatively harmless, but it will impact the quality of the cake. To ensure the best possible outcome when defrosting a wedding cake, follow these steps:

Before freezing:

• Immediately place the cake in the freezer until the icing hardens.
• Remove any decorations, such as sugar flowers, so they don't interfere with the freezing process.

Wrapping:

• Remove the cake from the freezer and wrap it loosely in several layers of plastic wrap.
• Do not use aluminium foil, as this could lead to freezer burn.
• If using a box, wrap the box in several layers of plastic wrap, or place the cake in an airtight container.
• Label the cake so you don't accidentally throw it out.

Defrosting:

• Take the cake out of the freezer and remove the wrapping.
• Allow the cake to defrost for 24 to 48 hours in the refrigerator.
• Bring the cake to room temperature for 2 to 3 hours before serving.

Alternative options:

If you are concerned about the quality of your cake after freezing, you may want to consider the following options:

• Order a replica cake from your bakery for your anniversary.
• Cut off a chunk of the cake and place it in the fridge.
• Have a local baker create a small, fresh cake for your anniversary, replicating the original design.

Although freezing a wedding cake for a year may not result in the same taste and texture as the original, it is still a fun and sweet tradition to bring good luck to married couples.

Alternatives to freezing wedding cake

Freezing your wedding cake for your first anniversary is a long-honoured tradition. However, it is understandable that some couples might be hesitant to eat a year-old cake. While it is safe to eat, it may not taste as good as it did on the wedding day. So, what are some alternatives to freezing your wedding cake?

Firstly, you could opt for a replica cake. Many bakers offer this service, creating a miniature copy of your wedding cake for you to enjoy on your first anniversary. This way, you can still partake in the tradition without having to worry about the quality of the cake. It is guaranteed to taste fresh and delicious, just like it did on your wedding night.

Another option is to opt for a different type of cake altogether. For example, a heartier cake such as a chocolate, carrot, hazelnut, or almond cake will stand up better to freezing than a delicate cake like angel food cake or a cake with custard or fresh fruit fillings. If you know you want to freeze your cake, choosing a cake with more moisture and an oil base will ensure it lasts longer and freezes better.

Additionally, you could consider other ways to preserve the memory of your wedding cake without having to eat it a year later. For example, you could keep a photo of the cake or even preserve some of the decorations or the cake topper as a keepsake.

Finally, you could choose to forgo the tradition altogether and come up with your own unique way to celebrate your first anniversary. The possibilities are endless, and you can create a new tradition that is meaningful to you and your partner.

While freezing your wedding cake is a well-loved tradition, it is not the only option. With a little creativity, you can find an alternative that suits your tastes and ensures you have a sweet and memorable first anniversary.

Frequently asked questions