The Sweet Tradition Of Eating Wedding Cake A Year Later

Eating your wedding cake a year after your wedding is a tradition that dates back to the 18th or 19th century in Great Britain. The top tier of the cake was saved and consumed a year later for good luck. This was usually done during the christening of the couple's first child, which typically occurred within the first year of marriage. However, in modern times, this tradition has evolved, and couples may choose to eat the saved cake on their one-year anniversary. While some people report positive experiences with the taste of their year-old cake, others find it inedible or stale. To improve the chances of the cake remaining edible, proper preservation methods, such as freezing, are recommended.

Wedding cake freezing tips

If you want to stick to the tradition of eating your wedding cake a year later, you'll need to know how to preserve it properly. Here are some tips to help you freeze your wedding cake and increase the chances of it tasting good a year later.

Firstly, it's important to know your cake. Some cakes are more delicate and likely to become stale during freezing, such as angel food cake. Heartier cakes like chocolate, carrot, hazelnut, and almond cakes will withstand freezing better. If your cake has custard or fresh fruit fillings, be aware that these might not maintain their original texture.

Before you wrap the cake, place it in the freezer until the icing hardens. If your cake has sugar flowers or other decorations, it's best to remove them first. Then, remove the cake from the freezer and wrap it loosely in several layers of plastic wrap. Do not use aluminium foil, as this could lead to freezer burn. If you're using a box, wrap it in plastic wrap as well, or place the cake in an airtight container.

When it's time to defrost the cake, take it out of the freezer and remove the wrapping. Allow the cake to thaw for 24 to 48 hours in the refrigerator, and then let it come to room temperature for 2 to 3 hours before serving.

It's worth noting that freezing a wedding cake for a whole year may not yield the best results in terms of taste and texture. Some couples choose to order a replica of their wedding cake for their anniversary, ensuring a fresh and tasty dessert while still evoking fond memories of their wedding day.

Additionally, it's crucial to follow food safety guidelines. Bacteria and mould can be a concern, especially if the cake has been exposed to room temperature for a prolonged period during the event. Proper wrapping and freezing can help mitigate these issues, but it's essential to exercise caution.

If you're unsure about freezing your wedding cake, consider saving a few slices of each tier or asking your baker to create a smaller replica for your anniversary. This way, you can still enjoy a taste of your wedding cake without committing to freezing an entire tier for a year.

The history of the tradition

The tradition of eating your wedding cake one year later has its roots in 18th-century Great Britain. Back then, wedding cakes were typically made with preserved fruit or chocolate, giving them a much longer shelf life than modern cakes. Couples would save the top tier of their wedding cake, which was then served when their first child was born or at the child's christening. This typically occurred within the first year of marriage.

Over time, the tradition evolved, and the saved cake became a symbol of the couple's love and their exchanged vows. Eating the saved cake became a way to celebrate the couple's one-year anniversary and to symbolically renew their vows.

Today, the tradition of saving and eating wedding cake is no longer limited to fruit or chocolate cakes. Couples may choose to save a slice, a mini-cake, or the top tier of any type of cake, including cupcakes, doughnuts, or even DIY s'mores bars. Some couples opt to skip the tradition altogether, choosing instead to have their baker make a smaller version of their wedding cake for their anniversary or to simply enjoy looking at photos of the cake.

While the tradition has evolved to include a variety of cake options, the method of preservation has also changed. Freezing is now the preferred method for keeping the cake fresh, with bakers offering tips and recommendations for proper preservation. However, opinions vary on whether the year-old cake is still tasty, with some reporting that it was delicious, while others found it inedible or stale.

Is it common in your area?

I live in the UK, and while I have never personally come across this tradition, it seems to be somewhat common in certain areas. According to sources, the tradition of saving the top tier of a wedding cake to eat a year later stems from a British convention dating back to the 18th or 19th century. At the time, wedding cakes were primarily fruit or chocolate cakes, which have a much longer shelf life than modern cakes. The cake was typically served at the christening of the couple's first child, usually within a year of marriage.

Nowadays, the tradition has evolved, and the cake is often eaten on the couple's one-year anniversary. However, it seems that this tradition is more prevalent in certain regions of the US, particularly the northern half of the country, including states like New Jersey, Wisconsin, Indiana, and Connecticut. Some sources mention that it is also observed in other parts of the country, such as Virginia, Maryland, and Florida.

In terms of my personal experience, I have not encountered this tradition at weddings I have attended in the UK. It seems that the practice of saving and eating wedding cake a year later is not as widespread in my area, at least not in recent times. While it may have originated in Britain, it appears to have evolved and gained more traction in certain parts of the US.

Alternatives to eating year-old cake

The tradition of eating your wedding cake one year later is a well-known ritual, with nearly 46% of couples who married in 2019 saving or planning to save their cake. However, many people are hesitant to consume year-old cake due to concerns about taste, texture, and food safety. Here are some alternatives to consider:

• Order a fresh cake: Some couples opt to order a fresh cake from their baker on their first anniversary. This ensures that the cake is delicious and safe to eat, while still allowing them to participate in the tradition.
• Get a replicated top tier: Many bakers offer to replicate the top tier of the wedding cake for the couple's first anniversary. This option provides a fresh cake that resembles the original, making it a nostalgic and tasty treat.
• Preserve the cake differently: Instead of freezing the entire cake, consider preserving it through professional photography or by creating a cake replica using non-edible materials. This way, you can still cherish the memory of your wedding cake without worrying about eating stale cake.
• Celebrate with other treats: Couples can choose to forgo the tradition of eating year-old cake altogether and instead indulge in other commemorative treats on their first anniversary. This could include desserts such as cupcakes, doughnuts, or pies that are either freshly made or don't require freezing for long periods.
• Adjust the timing: If you still want to eat your wedding cake but are hesitant to wait a full year, you can enjoy it earlier. Some couples choose to savour their preserved cake on their one-month, three-month, or six-month anniversary, ensuring a fresher taste.

Remember, the choice is entirely up to you and your partner. You can adapt the tradition to fit your unique tastes and preferences.

Is it safe to eat?

Eating wedding cake a year after the wedding is considered safe, but it depends on how the cake was stored. The tradition of saving the top layer of the wedding cake and eating it on the first anniversary for good luck dates back to a time when weddings were celebrated with liqueur-soaked fruitcakes, which acted as natural preservatives.

Today, the tradition is considered a fun ritual, but many newlyweds are unsure about the safety of eating year-old cake. Experts agree that eating frozen wedding cake is generally safe but not risk-free. The biggest concern is the quality of the cake, which will likely have deteriorated, impacting the flavour and texture.

To ensure safety, it is crucial to preserve the cake properly. Newlyweds should wrap the top layer of their cake in plastic shrink wrap and tin foil, seal it inside an airtight container, and place it in the refrigerator as soon as possible after the wedding. When it's time to eat the cake, thaw it in the fridge for around 24 hours and then let it sit at room temperature for about an hour.

It's important to check for any signs of spoilage before consuming the cake. Look for mold, unusual colours, off odours, or changes in texture. Even with proper storage, the cake may still experience flavour deterioration, dryness, and crumbly structure.

Some couples opt to forgo the tradition of eating year-old cake and instead order a fresh replica of their wedding cake or bake a smaller version at home. This ensures a more delicious experience, although it may not carry the same symbolic significance.

Frequently asked questions