Asking Your Best Man: How Far Ahead Is Too Far?

When it comes to popping the question to your best man, timing is everything. While there's no one-size-fits-all answer, the general consensus is that it's best to wait until you have a date and venue secured. Asking too far in advance can be tricky, as people's finances and availability may change. It's also a good idea to give your best man and groomsmen a heads-up about a year before the wedding – this gives them ample time to plan the bachelor party and get their suits sorted. However, it's worth noting that relationships can evolve, so some suggest waiting until 6-9 months before the wedding to extend the invitation.

Timing: 8-10 months before the wedding is ideal

Asking your best man 8-10 months in advance of your wedding is ideal. This gives your best man plenty of time to get everything in order for your big day, from making sure he has his suit to planning and booking your bachelor party. It also gives you time to plan the honeymoon and purchase your wedding band.

Before you ask, it's important to consider who you're asking, what you're expecting from them, and whether they're the right person for the job. For example, if you expect your best man to spend weekends helping you choose a wedding venue or negotiate with vendors, you might not want to ask your best friend who just had a new baby.

When you ask someone to be your best man, you're saying, "You're important to me, and I want you with me throughout this entire process." They're the person who's going to support you during wedding planning, throw your bachelor party, and stand next to you when you say your wedding vows.

It's also important to choose groomsmen who have been in your life for a long time. In the space between wedding planning and the wedding day, a budding friendship could go in many uncertain directions.

There are many ways to ask your best man. You can make it a personal and emotional conversation, or you can ask through a card, which can be a great keepsake. You can also give them a gift, such as a personalised coffee mug or a bottle of their favourite booze with a funny or sentimental note attached.

Who to ask: Choose carefully, considering availability and expectations

When deciding who to ask to be your best man, it's important to choose carefully. One of the key considerations is availability – will they have the time and energy to commit to the role? For example, if you expect your best man to spend weekends helping you choose a wedding venue or negotiate with vendors, you might not want to ask a friend who has just had a baby.

It's also important to manage your expectations. If you have your heart set on someone who you know has limited availability, you could still ask them, but be prepared to lower your expectations in terms of what they can do. For instance, they might not be able to run lots of wedding-related errands, but they may be open to meeting up occasionally to discuss logistics and see how they can help.

Another factor to consider is the nature of your relationship with your chosen best man. If you have a large family, you may feel obliged to choose a relative, but it's important to remember that every wedding is different, and there are no rules. It's perfectly valid to opt for a close friend instead if that's what you would prefer.

It's also worth bearing in mind that relationships can change over time, so it's generally advisable to ask around eight months to one year in advance. This gives you a better sense of who is likely to remain important to you in the long term, reducing the risk of choosing someone you later drift apart from.

Finally, it's worth noting that your best man doesn't have to be male. You can ask a female friend or family member to be your "best woman" or "groomslady". Ultimately, it's about choosing the most important people in your life, regardless of their gender.

In-person: Make it formal, but lighthearted

When it comes to popping the question to your best man, it's important to consider the timing. While there's no one-size-fits-all answer, most sources suggest asking around eight months to one year in advance. This gives your best man and groomsmen enough time to prepare, from sorting their attire to planning your bachelor party. Asking too early can lead to awkward situations if relationships change, but asking too late may not give your best man enough time to fulfil his duties.

Now, for the fun part: how to ask your best friend to be your best man in person, with a touch of formality and a dash of lightheartedness.

Asking your best friend to be your best man is a special moment, so it's worth making it a little formal. But that doesn't mean you can't keep things lighthearted and fun. Here's a step-by-step guide to pulling off this delicate balance:

• Choose a suitable location: Select a place that holds meaning for both of you. It could be your favourite bar, a golf course, or even your living room if you're planning a quiet night in. The key is to create a comfortable and familiar atmosphere.
• Set the mood: While you want to maintain a degree of formality, it's essential to keep the mood light and cheerful. You could organise a group outing with your potential groomsmen, creating a relaxed environment for the big ask. Alternatively, take your best friend out for a burger and a beer, or invite them over for dinner and games.
• Prepare a thoughtful gift: A well-chosen gift can enhance your proposal and make it more memorable. Consider a "groomsman starter pack" with items like a shaving kit, cufflinks, tie bar, or a personalised flask. If you want to be playful, send them a bouquet of roses with a note asking them to be your best man.
• Pop the question: When the moment is right, present your gift and ask the question. You can keep it simple with a straightforward request or add a touch of humour with a playful card or note. For example, instead of a traditional "Will you be my best man?" card, opt for something like, "She said 'yes,' now it's your turn" or "Your service as a groomsman is required."
• Make it official: Include a space for them to sign their name on the card or note, signifying their acceptance of this honourable role. This adds a touch of formality to the occasion and makes it feel like an "official" commitment.
• Discuss the details: Once they've said yes, take some time to talk about the responsibilities and expectations of the role. Be clear about what you expect from them, whether it's attending pre-wedding events, planning the bachelor party, or simply providing moral support.

Remember, the key to making this moment special is combining a touch of formality with a healthy dose of fun. By choosing a suitable location, setting the right mood, and presenting a thoughtful gift, you'll create a memorable and lighthearted experience for both of you.

Gift ideas: Bro-posal kits, personalised items, and more

There are a variety of factors to consider when deciding how far in advance of your wedding to ask your best man. While there is no one-size-fits-all answer, it is generally recommended to wait until you are within a year of your wedding date. This gives you and your partner time to consider your closest friends and family members and ensure that those you choose to be in your wedding party are still people you want standing by your side on your big day. Asking too early could lead to an awkward situation if relationships change.

Now, onto the fun part—choosing a gift to accompany your "bro-posal"! Here are some unique and personalised gift ideas to make your "bro-posal" extra special:

Bro-posal Kits

These ready-made kits can be a fun and convenient way to pop the question to your best man. The BroBasket, for example, offers a range of alcohol-themed gift baskets that you can customise with liquor, accessories, snacks, mixers, and more. You can even include an engraved liquor bottle for a personalised touch.

Personalised Items

Adding a personalised touch to your gift can make it even more meaningful and memorable. Consider items like:

• A custom-engraved wallet, money clip, or set of cufflinks
• A monogrammed duffle bag, weekender bag, or toiletry bag
• A personalised watch, or a monogrammed travel watch roll if your best man is a collector
• An engraved knife or multi-tool for a more utilitarian option
• A custom-engraved whiskey decanter set or other barware
• A sentimental plaque or sign with a personalised message

Other Gift Ideas

If you're looking for something beyond the typical gift options, here are some unique ideas:

• A portable grill or BBQ kit for the culinary-minded brother
• A pair of tickets to a sporting event or concert for a shared experience
• A subscription box or service that aligns with their interests
• A high-quality pair of shoes or a stylish hoodie for the fashion-conscious brother
• Tech gadgets like Bluetooth speakers, smart mugs, or a portable grill

Group outing: Plan an activity to pop the question

It is generally advised to wait until your wedding date is set before asking your best man. This is because people's finances and availability can change over time, and they may not be able to commit to an event without knowing the date. It is also recommended to wait until at least a year, or 6-9 months, before the wedding to give your wedding party time to prepare. This also allows for any potential changes in your relationships.

Now, here are some ideas for a group outing to pop the question to your best man:

• Organize a casual get-together: Invite your prospective best man and a few close friends to a low-key gathering, such as a lunch, a hangout at your favourite pub, or a weekend trip. Make the situation as informal or formal as you like. You can even book an event or space that commemorates a special milestone in your friendship. During the outing, pop the question in a lighthearted manner.
• Give them a starter kit: Prepare a starter pack for your prospective best man and other groomsmen that includes essentials such as cufflinks, a bow tie or printed tie, and a small bottle of their favourite drink. You can also include a personalised note or invitation card in the pack. The moment you give them the gift will be unexpected, but when they open the contents, they will understand the hint.
• Host a group activity: Plan an enjoyable group activity that your prospective best man and other groomsmen will appreciate. This could be something like a sporting event, a beer tasting, or a concert. During the activity, find an opportune moment to ask your question. The shared experience will make the occasion more memorable.
• Send them on a scavenger hunt: Create a fun scavenger hunt for your prospective best man and other groomsmen, with the final clue leading them to a location where you will be waiting to pop the question. This adds an element of surprise and interactivity to the occasion.
• Go for a meal: Invite your prospective best man and the other groomsmen to a nice dinner or lunch. You can even make it a group brunch or a fun picnic. During the meal, casually bring up the topic of your wedding and pop the question. This approach combines a enjoyable shared meal with a meaningful conversation.

Frequently asked questions