Deborah Chan
Creeping Charlie, also known as ground ivy, is a weed with round, dark green leaves and purple flowers that bloom in the spring. It thrives in moist, shady areas and can quickly take over a lawn, forming thick mats that choke out other plant life. While some people have had success controlling Creeping Charlie with products like Weed B Gon and Weedfree Zone, others have turned to Scotts Turf Builder Weed and Feed 3 for help. But does Scotts Weed and Feed kill Creeping Charlie?
| Characteristics | Values |
|---|---|
| Common names | Creeping Charlie, Ground Ivy |
| Appearance | Round, dark green leaves with scalloped edges and small purple flowers in the spring |
| Habitat | Thrives in moist, shady areas and bare spots |
| Treatment | Scotts Weed and Feed, Weed B Gon, TZone, Dicamba, Speedzone, Tenacity, 2-4-D |
| Notes | Scotts Weed and Feed may not be effective against Creeping Charlie; check the label before use. |
Explore related products
$26.49 $32.99
$76.97 $90.99
What You'll Learn
Scotts Weed and Feed may not be effective
Creeping Charlie, also known as ground ivy, is a stubborn weed with round, dark green leaves and small purple flowers that bloom in spring. While Scotts Weed and Feed is a popular product for lawn care, it may not be effective in killing Creeping Charlie. Here are several reasons why:
Scotts Weed and Feed May Not Be Formulated to Kill Creeping Charlie
The Scotts Weed and Feed product line offers various solutions for different types of weeds and grasses. However, not all formulations are created equal, and some may not be designed to target Creeping Charlie specifically. Before purchasing or applying any weed killer, it is essential to read the label and ensure that it is specifically formulated to control Creeping Charlie.
Timing of Application Matters
The effectiveness of weed control products, including Scotts Weed and Feed, can be influenced by the timing of application. Creeping Charlie is a perennial weed that thrives in specific seasons. Applying weed killer during its active growing season, usually spring and fall, when it is most vulnerable, will yield better results. Summer, for instance, is not an ideal time as the heat can stress and damage your grass instead.
Creeping Charlie's Resilience
Creeping Charlie is known for its tenacity and ability to survive despite control efforts. It often requires multiple applications of herbicide, spaced several days apart, to achieve effective control. Some sources suggest that alternative products like Weed B Gon, combined with Weedfree Zone, TZone, or Dicamba, may be more successful in controlling Creeping Charlie.
Lawn Care Practices
A well-maintained lawn is the best defence against weeds. Proper feeding, mowing, and watering practices can help crowd out weeds and prevent their establishment. Scotts, for example, recommends using their Turf Builder Lawn Food to promote a thick, healthy lawn that can outcompete weeds. However, overwatering or fertilizing can also create favourable conditions for Creeping Charlie, so a balanced approach is necessary.
In summary, while Scotts Weed and Feed may be effective against some weeds, it may not be sufficient for controlling Creeping Charlie. For successful management, a combination of proper lawn care practices, timely herbicide applications, and, in some cases, alternative products may be required.
Glassware for Wedding Bouquets: What We Provide
You may want to see also
Explore related products
Weed B Gon and Weedfree Zone work
Creeping Charlie is a stubborn, perennial weed that can be challenging to eradicate. While some people have tried various methods to get rid of it, it often requires multiple applications of herbicide and persistent efforts to achieve success.
Weed B Gon
Ortho Weed B Gon is a lawn weed killer that targets common lawn weeds, including crabgrass, dandelions, chickweed, clover, and foxtail, among others. It is designed to kill weeds to the root without harming the grass when used as directed. The product is suitable for specific grass types, such as Bermudagrass, Kentucky Bluegrass, and Ryegrass. It is recommended to apply Weed B Gon when weeds are young and actively growing, with daytime temperatures between 45°F and 90°F. The manufacturer provides a battery-powered Comfort Wand for easy application, allowing users to spot-treat weeds with a continuous stream. However, some online reviews claim that Weed B Gon kills grass along with weeds, particularly St. Augustine grass, which may be due to the product's active ingredient, quinclorac.
Weedfree Zone
Ferti-lome Weed Free Zone is a versatile herbicide used for lawn care and vegetation management. It is effective against various broadleaf weeds and crabgrass in residential lawns. The product is easy to mix, and the amount required depends on the square footage of the treatment area. For cool-season grasses, a higher concentration is recommended, while for warm-season grasses, a lower concentration is suggested. While Weedfree Zone can be effective, it is important to delay mowing one to two days before and after application to ensure optimal results.
Combining the use of Weed B Gon and Weedfree Zone can be a powerful approach to tackling challenging weeds like Creeping Charlie. Applying these herbicides during the spring or fall, when temperatures are lower, is generally recommended to avoid stressing the grass. Additionally, applying herbicides early in the morning can improve their effectiveness.
Expressing Gratitude: Wedding Thank Yous for Parents
You may want to see also
Explore related products
$36.77 $39.49
Dicamba, Speedzone, and TZone are effective
Creeping Charlie is a stubborn weed that can be challenging to eradicate. It often requires multiple rounds of treatment to achieve full elimination. Small surviving pieces of root or stem left in the ground will regrow, so persistence is key. Dicamba, SpeedZone, and TZone are effective herbicides for tackling this weed.
Dicamba has been described as working "incredibly well" by some users. It is a broadleaf herbicide that can be used in combination with Triclopyr and 2,4-D. Dicamba is most effective when applied early in the morning when weeds intake weed control better due to lower temperatures.
SpeedZone is another effective herbicide for controlling Creeping Charlie. It contains 2,4-D and has a good reputation for getting rid of this weed. It is best used in early spring or fall, avoiding the hot summer months to prevent stressing and frying grass.
TZone is a potent herbicide that contains Triclopyr, Dicamba, and 2,4-D. It is recommended to be applied at full strength in two applications, 10-14 days apart. TZone can be harsh on turfgrass, especially during the summer heat, so caution is advised. It is important to ensure the grass is 100% healthy before application to reduce the risk of discoloration and potential die-off.
Combining these herbicides with other methods, such as dethatching and aeration, can also improve results. Dethatching helps pull up Creeping Charlie, but it should be done carefully as it can spread fragments and make the problem worse. Aeration can also help prevent the growth of Creeping Charlie by improving soil conditions.
Overall, Dicamba, SpeedZone, and TZone are all effective tools in the battle against Creeping Charlie. Each has its advantages and considerations, and users should choose the one that best suits their needs, keeping in mind the health and condition of their lawn.
Family-only kids: Wedding no-kid rules and exceptions
You may want to see also
Explore related products
$12.56 $13.99
2-4-D is the standard for broadleaf weeds
Creeping Charlie is an evergreen perennial creeper that thrives in moist, shady areas and can form thick mats in the lawn. It is a stubborn weed that is hard to kill. While there are many methods and products that claim to be effective in killing Creeping Charlie, one product that is often recommended is 2,4-D.
The chemical name for 2,4-D is 2,4-Dichlorophenoxyacetic acid, and it is an organic compound with the chemical formula C8H6Cl2O3. It is a systemic herbicide that is highly effective in killing most broadleaf weeds, including dandelion, clover, crabgrass, and other invasive grassy and broadleaf weed species. It is important to note that 2,4-D does not harm grasses, cereals, lawn turf, or grassland as it specifically targets broadleaf weeds. This makes it ideal for use in lawns and gardens, as it will not kill the grass along with the weeds.
The mechanism by which 2,4-D kills broadleaf weeds is by causing uncontrolled growth, which ultimately leads to the destruction of the weed's vital tissues. This is because broadleaf weeds have their growing point at the tips of the leaves, while grasses grow from the base. This selective action of 2,4-D makes it a valuable tool in weed control. It is widely used in agriculture to control broadleaf weeds in crops such as corn, oats, rice, and wheat, and it has been used for this purpose since 1945. It is also used in forestry, along roadways and power lines, and in waterways to control aquatic weeds.
2,4-D is one of the oldest and most widely available herbicides globally, with over 1,500 herbicide products containing it as an active ingredient. It has been commercially available since 1945 and is produced by numerous chemical companies. Its effectiveness in killing broadleaf weeds, availability, and affordability have made it the standard for broadleaf weed control. When using 2,4-D, it is important to follow safety guidelines and wear proper protective equipment.
Harry's Wedding: A Priestly Affair
You may want to see also
Explore related products
A well-fed lawn is the best defence
Creeping Charlie, or ground ivy, is a weed that can quickly take over a lawn. It has round, dark green leaves with scalloped edges and small purple flowers in the spring. It thrives in moist, shady areas and can form thick mats in the lawn, choking the life out of it. While some people have had success killing Creeping Charlie with products like Weed B Gon and Dicamba, others have found that Scotts Weed and Feed does not work for them. In fact, one user on a lawn care forum specifically asked if Scotts Weed and Feed kills Creeping Charlie, indicating that the product description does not mention this particular weed.
In addition to using Scotts products, there are other ways to prevent and kill Creeping Charlie. One user on Reddit recommended attacking the weed in the spring, when it starts to bloom, and applying Weed B Gon once a week for the first month. They also suggested using Weedfree Zone, but warned that it can leave bare spots in the lawn. Another user recommended TZone full-strength applications 10-14 days apart, as well as Dicamba, which worked "incredibly well" for them. Dethatching with a sunjoe dethatcher can also help, but it's important to be careful as it can spread fragments of the weed around.
When using herbicides like Scotts Weed and Feed, it's important to follow the instructions on the label. The lawn should be wet before applying the herbicide so that the granules can stick to the plants. It's also recommended to apply weed control products when the temperature is lower, as weeds intake weed control better at lower temperatures. While some people may be tempted to fertilize their lawns throughout the season, this is unnecessary as grass rarely needs to be fertilized. Fertilizing once or twice in early spring should be enough to keep the lawn healthy for the rest of the year.
Stern's Wedding Woes
You may want to see also
Frequently asked questions
It is unclear whether Scotts Weed and Feed kills creeping Charlie. Some sources suggest that it does not, while others recommend giving it a week to see if it is effective. It is important to note that Scotts is overpriced and generic brands are just as good or better.
The best way to kill creeping Charlie is to use a product like Weed B Gon or Weedfree Zone, which is specifically designed to kill weeds. It is recommended to apply these products in the spring or fall when the temperature is lower, as weeds intake weed control better in cooler temperatures.
In addition to using herbicide products, you can use a sunjoe dethatcher to help pull up creeping Charlie. However, dethatching can make the problem worse by spreading fragments around. Another option is to use a product like Scotts® Turf Builder® Lawn Food to promote a thick lawn, which can help crowd out weeds.
