A Year Later: Wedding Cake For Two

Eating the top tier of your wedding cake a year after the wedding is a long-honored tradition for good luck. The custom dates back to when weddings were celebrated with liqueur-soaked fruitcakes, which contained natural preservatives. Today, couples who observe this tradition often freeze the top layer of their wedding cake to eat on their first anniversary. However, opinions vary on whether the year-old cake will still taste good. While some say it's safe to eat, others advise against it, suggesting that modern cakes are not made to be frozen for extended periods. Some couples opt for a miniature recreation of their wedding cake on their anniversary instead.

The tradition of eating wedding cake a year later

The tradition of eating your wedding cake a year after the big day is a long-honoured one. It supposedly dates back to a time when weddings were celebrated with liqueur-soaked fruitcakes, which, thanks to their sugar and alcohol content, acted as natural preservatives. These cakes would often then be used to celebrate the christening of the couple's first child.

Today, the tradition is upheld by couples who freeze the top layer of their wedding cake to eat on their first anniversary for good luck. However, this is not without its challenges, as modern sponge cakes and buttercream recipes are not made to be frozen for long periods.

To effectively preserve a wedding cake, it should be wrapped in plastic shrink wrap and tin foil, sealed inside an airtight container, and placed in the refrigerator as soon as possible. Oil-based cakes are thought to last longer than butter-based ones, and chocolate cakes may fare better than vanilla.

Even when properly preserved, the quality of the cake will likely suffer, and the flavour will be impacted. However, experts agree that eating year-old wedding cake is relatively harmless and mostly safe, as long as the cake is frozen at a constant food-safe temperature.

Some couples choose to forego the tradition of eating frozen wedding cake and instead opt for a miniature recreation of their original cake on their first anniversary, ensuring a fresh and delicious experience.

How to preserve your wedding cake for a year

Preserving your wedding cake for a year can be a challenging task. Traditionally, wedding cakes were fruit cakes, which were much easier to preserve due to their ingredients. However, modern sponge cakes and buttercream recipes are not designed to be frozen for long periods. Here are some tips to help you preserve your wedding cake for a year:

Start with refrigeration:

Get your cake into the refrigerator as soon as possible after your wedding. This will help to chill the cake and harden the icing, making it easier to prepare for freezing.

Remove decorations:

Take off all flowers and other adornments from the cake. This is especially important for fresh flowers but also applies to sugar or fondant flowers, which can spoil quickly.

Wrap the cake:

Once the cake is chilled, wrap it gently but tightly with plastic cling film or Saran/Cling Wrap in three separate layers. This will help protect the cake from freezer burn and prevent the plastic wrap from sticking to the icing.

Use an airtight container:

Place the wrapped cake inside an airtight container or a freezer bag. Make sure the container is narrow enough to fit in your freezer and allows some room for gentle handling. Commercial food containers are a good option.

Label and freeze:

Label the cake with the date and any other relevant information. Place the container in your freezer, making sure it is set to the correct temperature.

Thawing and serving:

When you are ready to eat the cake after a year, take it out of the freezer and place it in the refrigerator for about 24 hours to thaw. Then, remove the cake from its packaging, take off the plastic wrap, and let it sit at room temperature for a few hours before serving.

It is important to note that even with proper preservation, your cake will likely be stale after a year. Certain types of cakes, like chocolate, almond, or carrot, will last longer and taste better than white, fruit-filled, or whipped cream-topped cakes. Additionally, consider asking your baker for advice, as some bakeries offer to remake the top tier of your wedding cake for your anniversary.

Is it safe to eat a year-old wedding cake?

The tradition of saving the top tier of a wedding cake to eat on a couple's first anniversary is a long-honoured one. It is believed to bring good luck and is symbolic of a couple's love, commitment, and fortune. However, the question of whether it is safe to eat a year-old wedding cake is a different matter.

Firstly, it is important to note that the tradition of saving wedding cakes originated when weddings were celebrated with liqueur-soaked fruitcakes. Sugar and alcohol are natural preservatives, so these cakes could be safely consumed after a long period of time. Modern sponge cakes and buttercream recipes, however, are not made to be frozen for any period of time.

That being said, many couples today still choose to save their wedding cake, and some report that it tasted fine a year later. It is generally agreed that freezing cake for a year is relatively harmless, as long as the cake is preserved properly. It should be wrapped tightly to prevent freezer burn and stored at a constant food-safe temperature.

However, there are some risks associated with consuming aged cake. The texture and flavour may change, with cakes becoming dry, crumbly, and stale. There is also a chance of food poisoning if the cake was not stored properly, as bacteria can grow, especially at warm temperatures.

Therefore, if you are considering eating a year-old wedding cake, it is important to inspect it carefully for any signs of spoilage. Look for mold, unusual colours, or off-odors. If the cake passes this test, you can proceed with a taste test, but be prepared for a bite that may not be as delicious as you remember.

Alternatives to eating year-old wedding cake

While the tradition of eating a year-old wedding cake is long-honoured, it is not without its risks. The cake must be carefully preserved, and even then, it may not taste as good as it did on the wedding day. Instead of eating year-old cake, couples can opt for alternative celebratory treats that are safer and potentially more enjoyable.

One alternative is to order a replica of the wedding cake from the baker. Many bakers offer to create a fresh, miniature version of the top tier of the wedding cake for the couple's anniversary. This way, they can relive their wedding dessert without compromising taste or taking up freezer space.

Another option is to explore modern twists on traditional wedding desserts. Cupcakes, for instance, offer a fun and individualised option that can be customised to match the wedding theme or flavours. Pies are another great choice, bringing a comforting and homely feel to the celebration. Flavours like apple, berry, or pecan can remind guests of cherished family moments.

For a unique twist, couples can opt for a dessert bar with a variety of treats such as donuts, strudels, macarons, or cookies. Donuts, in particular, offer a versatile option with countless flavours and the potential to create a beautiful display. Strudels, on the other hand, provide a delightful texture and can be filled with fruits or nuts for a sweet and nutty experience.

Couples who want to stick with the cake theme but are hesitant to eat year-old cake can consider making a small, fresh cake in the same flavour as their wedding cake. This way, they can still enjoy the taste of their special day without worrying about food safety or diminished quality.

In conclusion, while eating a year-old wedding cake is a cherished tradition, there are several alternatives that couples can explore to commemorate their first anniversary. From fresh replicas of the wedding cake to a diverse array of desserts, these options offer a safer and potentially more enjoyable way to celebrate this special occasion.

People's experiences of eating their wedding cake a year later

Eating the top tier of a wedding cake on a couple's first anniversary is a long-standing tradition. The practice dates back to ancient Rome, when couples ate wedding cake for good luck. In the 19th century, couples would save the top layer of their cake to eat on the day of their first child's christening.

Today, the tradition is a symbol of celebrating the love and togetherness of the couple. While some people still follow this custom, others are put off by the idea of eating year-old cake.

Some people who have tried their wedding cake a year later report that it tasted fine, while others say it was inedible or even caused food poisoning. It seems that the success of this tradition depends on how well the cake was wrapped and stored.

"My husband and I saved our cake and it tasted just fine. I only ate a bite, but my husband ate the remaining part of the cake over a course of several days."

"We saved ours in the freezer and ate some on our 1st anniversary. Actually double-sealed what was left and put it back. Was in the freezer for 16 years until we came back from vacation once to find the refrigerator had died. Threw it out. Not sure what we would have done with it anyway..."

"We saved ours. The trick is you have to wrap it really well to prevent freezer burn. Ours tasted amazing even after being frozen for a year."

"We saved the top tier (about 6-8 inches in diameter) of our wedding cake in our freezer for a year and each had a bite on our one-year anniversary. It tasted terrible by that point, but it was fun to do and a great memory all these years later."

"We saved our top tier, in the original take-out box the caterer gave it to us in, and never bothered to seal it or wrap it. On our first anniversary, it tasted like milk that had gone rancid."

"We did this (had our top tier professionally wrapped to save in the freezer), and I would not recommend it. We took it out after 3 months because we were running out of freezer space and it was not good. I can't imagine what it would have tasted like after a full year."

"We stored our cake in the freezer. One year later, we thawed it for our anniversary. It tasted fresh and delicious!"

"We followed our baker's advice. Our cake remained moist and flavorful after a year. It became a cherished memory."

"We celebrated our first anniversary with a small cake-cutting ceremony. The cake brought back all the joyful memories of our wedding day."

Frequently asked questions