Uscis: Can They Uncover Nikah Weddings?

The Nikah is an Islamic marriage ceremony, which is performed in the presence of an Islamic priest and witnesses. While the Nikah is a legally valid marriage in many countries, it is not always recognised as such in the US. In the US, a marriage certificate is required to prove a legally valid marriage. This certificate is issued by the county or city where the marriage is performed. While the Nikah ceremony can be integrated into the legal administrative government marriage, the marriage certificate is what is required for immigration purposes. Therefore, USCIS will only be able to find out about a Nikah wedding if it has been registered and a marriage certificate has been issued.

USCIS requirements for a marriage to be valid

The USCIS has several requirements that must be met for a marriage to be considered valid.

Firstly, the marriage must be established as valid by the applicant. The "place-of-celebration rule" determines the legal validity of a marriage, meaning that a marriage is valid for immigration purposes if it is valid in the jurisdiction in which it was performed. A marriage certificate is usually sufficient evidence that a marriage was legally performed.

However, the USCIS does not recognize certain relationships as marriages, even if they are considered valid in the place of celebration. These include:

• Polygamous marriages
• Marriages that violate the strong public policy of the state of residence of the couple
• Civil unions, domestic partnerships, or other such relationships not recognized as marriages in the place of celebration
• Proxy marriages, where one party is not present during the ceremony, unless the marriage has been consummated
• Relationships entered into for the purpose of evading U.S. immigration laws

Same-sex marriages are also recognized by the USCIS, provided they are valid in the jurisdiction in which they were celebrated. This is in accordance with the Supreme Court's 2013 decision in United States v. Windsor, which struck down the Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA) that had previously defined marriage as between a man and a woman.

In addition to having a valid marriage, there are other requirements that must be met for a foreign-born person to qualify for a U.S. green card or naturalization. These include:

• The marriage must be bona fide, meaning that it is not entered into for the sole or primary purpose of obtaining a green card
• At least one spouse must be a U.S. citizen or lawful permanent resident
• The marriage must be the only current marriage for both spouses; any previous marriages must have been legally terminated
• The applicant must be at least 18 years old and a lawfully admitted permanent resident of the U.S. for at least three years before filing Form N-400
• The applicant must have lived in marital union with their U.S. citizen spouse for at least three years before filing their application and must continue to do so until they take the Oath of Allegiance
• The applicant must have lived for at least three months in a state or USCIS district with jurisdiction over their place of residence
• The applicant must have continuous residence in the U.S. as a lawful permanent resident for at least three years before filing their application and must reside continuously in the U.S. until they naturalize
• The applicant must be physically present in the U.S. for at least 18 months out of the three years before filing their application
• The applicant must be able to read, write, and speak English and have knowledge of U.S. history, principles, and form of government
• The applicant must be of good moral character, attached to the principles of the U.S. Constitution, and well-disposed to the good order and happiness of the U.S. for at least three years before filing Form N-400 and until they take the Oath of Allegiance

What constitutes a bona fide marriage

To obtain a green card through marriage, a couple must prove that they have a bona fide relationship. A bona fide marriage is a legitimate marriage between two people, rather than a sham marriage entered into solely for immigration purposes. The US Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) requires proof that a marriage is bona fide before approving permanent residency. While there are no strict rules regarding the evidence required, the more evidence presented to USCIS, the better. Here are some examples of documents that can be used to prove a bona fide marriage:

• Marriage certificate
• Rental agreements, leases, or title documents evidencing joint residency
• Copies of joint utility bills
• Copies of joint bank account statements
• Copies of joint income tax returns
• Copies of love letters, emails, phone records, greeting cards, restaurant receipts, and affidavits from friends and family
• Photographs of the couple together
• Copies of travel documents
• Affidavits from friends and family
• Insurance policies reflecting spouses as beneficiaries
• Automobile registration under both names
• Trusts, wills, and other estate documentation

A bona fide marriage is one that is entered into in good faith and for legitimate reasons. It is important to note that a marriage certificate alone does not prove that a marriage is bona fide. USCIS will also consider other factors, such as evidence of cohabitation, raising children together, joint finances, and the overall relationship between the couple.

In the context of "niksh weddings," it is important to note that USCIS may investigate whether a marriage is bona fide if there are concerns about immigration fraud. While I cannot find specific information about "niksh weddings," it is safe to assume that USCIS will examine the same types of evidence and apply the same criteria to determine whether the marriage is legitimate.

To establish a bona fide marriage, it is essential to provide as much documentation as possible to prove the validity and authenticity of the relationship. This may include evidence of cohabitation, joint finances, raising children together, and other aspects of a genuine marital relationship.

Proving a bona fide marriage

To prove a bona fide marriage, couples must show that their marriage is legitimate and was entered into for the right reasons. The U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) wants to prevent non-citizens from entering into fraudulent or "sham" marriages for the sake of obtaining citizenship or evading U.S. immigration laws.

Proof of Joint Finances, Assets, and Welfare:

• Evidence of joint bank accounts, investment accounts, and credit card statements.
• Proof of joint income tax returns, loans, or lines of credit for major purchases.
• Wire or bank transfers between spouses.
• Life, auto, home, or renter's insurance statements.
• Evidence that one spouse is the beneficiary of the other's retirement account or insurance policy.

Proof of Joint Ownership of Property and Assets:

• Lease agreements, mortgages, or letters from a landlord confirming cohabitation.
• Copies of utility bills, auto registrations, driver's licenses, or postmarked letters showing a shared address.

Proof of Relationship and Shared Activities:

• Evidence of trips or vacations together, such as hotel stays, vehicle rentals, plane tickets, or photographs.
• Correspondence between spouses, including birthday cards, holiday cards, emails, and social media activity.
• Gift receipts or invoices listing one spouse as the "bill to" name and the other as the "ship to" or "recipient" name.
• Wedding photos, invitations, bills, invoices, and other relevant items.
• Photographs reflecting different stages of the relationship, preferably with family and friends.

Affidavits from Friends and Family:

Letters or affidavits from third parties, such as friends, family, religious leaders, or neighbours, attesting to their knowledge of the marriage and providing anecdotes or experiences that demonstrate the bona fides of the marital relationship.

It is important to note that the more evidence provided, the stronger the case for a bona fide marriage. Additionally, some forms of evidence are considered stronger than others. For example, joint bank accounts, life insurance, wills, and joint leases are considered stronger evidence than cards, affidavits from friends and family, or single travel itineraries.

Red flags that may trigger further scrutiny

The United States Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) scrutinizes each case meticulously to ensure that the relationship is genuine and not just a means to obtain immigration benefits. USCIS officers are trained to identify red flags that may cast doubt on the authenticity of a marriage or engagement. Here are some red flags that may trigger further scrutiny:

Secret Relationship

While there may be valid reasons for not involving loved ones, a secret relationship can be a red flag for USCIS. They have a Fraud Investigation Unit that conducts fieldwork and interviews with acquaintances to determine if they are aware of your relationship.

Short Relationship Duration

Falling in love and getting married quickly can be suspicious for immigration purposes. USCIS may question the authenticity of a relationship that has developed over a very short period, especially if there are looming visa deadlines. While there is no fixed duration required, be prepared to explain the circumstances surrounding a short-duration relationship.

Significant Age Gap

While USCIS does not specify a precise age difference that constitutes a red flag, a substantial age gap between spouses can draw extra scrutiny. Be prepared to provide evidence to prove the authenticity of your relationship if there is a significant age difference.

Limited Relationship Evidence

Insufficient relationship evidence can be a significant red flag. When submitting your application, provide a variety of convincing evidence of your genuine relationship, such as text messages, joint bills, records of shared activities, and trips, rather than just photos and letters of support.

Different Addresses

USCIS will check your address history and expects spouses to live under the same roof most of the time. Having different addresses on IDs or living apart can be a huge red flag and trigger further scrutiny.

No Shared Language

If the couple cannot communicate effectively due to a language barrier, USCIS may question how they can build a shared life together. Demonstrating that you are taking steps to learn each other's language or find other ways to communicate can help address this red flag.

Difference in Religion, Social Class, Cultural Background, or Race

While people from different backgrounds and beliefs can certainly get married, the U.S. government will be curious about how these differences may impact your relationship and whether the marriage is based on true love. Providing indications of shared values, commonalities, and steps taken to understand each other's beliefs and backgrounds can help address these concerns.

Unequal Educational Background

Educational disparities between spouses, especially when combined with other red flags, may raise questions about the authenticity of the relationship. It is important to emphasize shared interests, commonalities, and other factors beyond educational degrees when addressing this red flag.

All-too-Convenient Timing of Marriage

If the marriage occurs after deportation proceedings begin or just before a nonimmigrant visa is set to expire, it may raise suspicions about the timing being influenced by immigration status rather than genuine romantic intentions. Be prepared to explain why the marriage occurred at that specific time.

History of Sponsoring Other Spousal Immigrants

If the U.S. citizen or permanent resident has a history of sponsoring other spousal immigrants, it may raise questions about whether previous marriages were genuine or part of a green card scam. Expect heavy questioning and be prepared to provide detailed explanations for previous sponsorships.

Noncitizen from a Country with a History of Immigration Fraud

The U.S. government closely monitors countries with high rates of visa or immigration fraud. Even if it is not the noncitizen spouse's fault, coming from one of these countries will result in extra scrutiny.

Impoverished U.S. Citizen or Resident Petitioner

If the U.S. member of the couple is unemployed or appears to be in dire financial straits, authorities might wonder if they are seeking financial gain through a fraudulent marriage.

History of Crimes, Fraud, or Lies by Either Spouse

A history of illegal acts, especially those motivated by financial gain, may indicate a higher likelihood of marriage fraud. USCIS will carefully review any past illegal activities and may conduct fingerprint checks.

Consummation and its role in validating a marriage

Consummation is a significant aspect of marriage, deeply rooted in various cultures and religions, and holds immense cultural, legal, and personal significance. It refers to the first act of sexual intercourse between a married couple, symbolising the physical and emotional union of the spouses. While some may argue that sex is just one aspect of marriage, consummation is considered essential for a valid marriage in many cultures and religions. Here are some key points highlighting the role of consummation in validating a marriage:

• Legal Requirement: In many countries and some religions, consummation is a legal requirement for a marriage to be recognised as valid. Failure to consummate the marriage can be grounds for annulment or divorce. The relevance of consummation varies by jurisdiction. For example, in England and Wales, non-consummation is a ground for annulment, but only for heterosexual marriages.
• Procreation: In traditional societies, procreation outside of wedlock was frowned upon. Consummation ensures the couple's physical ability to have children and was often linked to the purpose of producing legally recognised descendants.
• Physical and Emotional Connection: Consummation is a physical expression of love, trust, and intimacy between spouses. It helps build and deepen their emotional connection, creating a strong bond.
• Religious Beliefs: In many religions, consummating a marriage is a sacred act that binds two souls together in holy matrimony. Some religious doctrines hold additional requirements, such as prohibiting contraception during the consummation act.
• Social Acceptance: In cultures where sex outside of marriage is considered taboo, consummation serves as an indication of social acceptance and confirmation of the union in the eyes of society.
• Cultural Rituals: Consummation rituals vary across cultures and may include blessings from elders, traditional customs, and confirmation by witnesses. For example, in Hindu culture, newlyweds break a clay pot of milk to symbolise their union.
• Marriage Validation: Consummation plays a crucial role in validating a marriage, especially in cultures where marriage is influenced by religious traditions. It solidifies the couple's commitment and officially completes their union.
• Personal Significance: Consummation can hold great personal significance for couples, symbolising the end of celibacy and the beginning of their physical and emotional connection as husband and wife.
• Impact on Immigration Status: In the context of immigration, consummation can impact the validity of a marriage. For proxy marriages, where one or both individuals are not physically present during the ceremony, consummation is required for the marriage to be recognised by the United States Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS).
• Challenges and Considerations: While consummation is important, it is not without its challenges. Couples may face pressure, personal preferences, health concerns, cultural differences, and performance issues. Consent and mutual respect between partners are essential, and communication plays a vital role in ensuring a positive and meaningful experience.

Frequently asked questions