Gay Weddings: First United Methodist Church's Celebration

The United Methodist Church's stance on homosexuality has been a highly contested issue within the church for decades. While the church has historically held that homosexuality is incompatible with Christian teaching and banned same-sex marriages, recent developments have challenged this position. In 2024, the church's General Conference voted to repeal the ban on LGBTQ clergy and same-sex marriages, allowing each region to determine its own standards. This has sparked debate and division between progressive and conservative factions, with some churches choosing to leave the denomination over these issues. The United Methodist Church now finds itself at a crossroads, struggling to balance its commitment to inclusivity with the diverse viewpoints of its global congregation.

The United Methodist Church's position on homosexuality

However, there have been strong voices within the church pushing for greater LGBTQ+ inclusion and acceptance. In May 2024, the United Methodist Church voted to lift its ban on LGBTQ+ members serving in the clergy, allowing them to be ordained. Additionally, clergy and churches can no longer be penalised for holding same-sex weddings, and restrictions on funding efforts to promote the acceptance of homosexuality have been removed. These changes reflect a shift towards a more permissive sexual ethic, with the church claiming a "neutral" stance on homosexuality.

Despite these changes, the United Methodist Church still does not officially recognise or perform same-sex marriages, and individual churches and clergy are not required to conduct or host such ceremonies. The church continues to support laws that define marriage as a union between one man and one woman.

The United Methodist Church's stance on same-sex marriage

The United Methodist Church's (UMC) stance on same-sex marriage has been a contentious issue within the denomination, with a history of debates, schisms, and changing policies. While the UMC has traditionally held conservative views on homosexuality, there have been shifts towards greater inclusion in recent years. Here is an overview of the UMC's stance on same-sex marriage:

• Historical Perspective: The UMC has its roots in the Methodist movement founded by Anglican priest John Wesley and his brother Charles in the 18th century. The modern UMC was formed in 1968 through the merger of the Methodist Church and the Evangelical United Brethren Church.
• Previous Stance: The UMC has traditionally taken a conservative position on same-sex marriage, considering it incompatible with Christian teaching. The church's Book of Discipline, which outlines church law, previously included language stating that "the practice of homosexuality is incompatible with Christian teaching." It also banned clergy from officiating at same-sex weddings and prohibited the ordination of "self-avowed practicing homosexuals."
• Recent Shifts: In recent years, there has been a push for greater inclusion of LGBTQ+ individuals within the UMC. In 2019, the denomination created the Commission on a Way Forward to re-examine paragraphs in the Book of Discipline concerning human sexuality.
• 2024 General Conference: The UMC's 2024 General Conference, the denomination's legislative body, brought significant changes. Delegates voted to remove the language from the Book of Discipline that deemed homosexuality incompatible with Christian teaching. They also repealed the ban on LGBTQ+ clergy and lifted prohibitions on clergy officiating at same-sex weddings. These changes effectively left the decision to perform same-sex marriages to the discretion of individual clergy and churches.
• Regional Differences: It is important to note that the UMC has a global presence, and regional conferences outside the United States have the autonomy to set their own rules. Churches in more conservative regions, such as Africa, may retain more traditional views on same-sex marriage and continue to prohibit LGBTQ+ clergy and weddings.
• Ongoing Debate: While the 2024 General Conference marked a significant shift towards inclusion, the UMC's stance on same-sex marriage remains a divisive issue. Some conservatives within the denomination have expressed disagreement with the changes and may consider further actions, including potential departures from the church.

The United Methodist Church's approach to LGBTQ+ clergy

The church's Book of Discipline, which details church law, previously included language that restricted and singled out non-heterosexual people for disparate treatment. It stated that "the practice of homosexuality is incompatible with Christian teaching" and prohibited clergy from being "self-avowed practising homosexual[s]". However, in 2024, the church's General Conference voted to remove this restrictive language, allowing for a more neutral stance on homosexuality. This change lifted mandatory prohibitions on LGBTQ+ clergy, giving them the freedom to preside over same-sex marriages and lifting restrictions on their ordination.

Despite these changes, the United Methodist Church's approach is not uniformly supportive of LGBTQ+ clergy. The church continues to assert that it does not "actively approve homosexual relations" and maintains that its stance is neutral. Additionally, individual churches and clergy are not required to perform same-sex marriages or ordain LGBTQ+ individuals.

The United Methodist Church's position has evolved over time, with increasing support for LGBTQ+ inclusion. In 2012, efforts for legislative change gained momentum, and by 2016, the General Conference voted to defer action on LGBTQ+ issues pending further study. This led to the creation of the Commission on a Way Forward, which examined and revised paragraphs of the Book of Discipline concerning human sexuality. However, in 2019, the church reaffirmed its ban on LGBTQ+ clergy and same-sex marriages, prompting an exodus of progressive congregations and a decline in membership.

While the United Methodist Church's official policies have historically been strongly against the LGBTQ+ community, many church leaders and local pastors have welcomed and supported LGBTQ+ individuals, recognising their "sacred worth" and basic human rights.

The United Methodist Church's disciplinary action against LGBTQ+ members

The United Methodist Church's Book of Discipline previously stated that "the practice of homosexuality is incompatible with Christian teaching" and that ceremonies celebrating homosexual unions should not be conducted by ministers or within their churches. The Book of Discipline also prohibited the ordination of "self-avowed, practicing" gay, lesbian, and bisexual persons.

In May 2024, the United Methodist Church voted to repeal its ban on the ordination of LGBTQ+ clergy and the celebration of same-sex weddings. The church's General Conference, which meets every four years to set church policy, voted to remove language from the Book of Discipline that restricted and singled out non-heterosexual people for disparate treatment.

Despite these changes, the United Methodist Church's position on LGBTQ+ issues remains complex and divided. While some clergy and individual churches have chosen to celebrate same-sex weddings, others continue to uphold the traditional teachings on homosexuality.

The United Methodist Church's current Social Principles recognize the sacred worth of all persons but maintain that the practice of homosexuality is incompatible with Christian teaching. The church also continues to support laws that define marriage as a union between one man and one woman.

The church's disciplinary actions against LGBTQ+ members have evolved over time. As of 2024, the chargeable offenses for clergy being found to be "self-avowed practicing homosexual" or for presiding over a same-sex wedding have been removed. However, it is important to note that the United Methodist Church does not require clergy to preside at same-sex weddings or local churches to allow such ceremonies on their property. The decision is left to the discretion of individual clergy and churches.

In the past, disciplinary actions for violating the church's teachings on homosexuality included suspension and removal from ministry for ministers who performed same-sex weddings. For example, the "Traditionalist Plan" approved by delegates in 2019 enacted standards for punishing ministers who perform same-sex weddings, including a minimum one-year suspension without pay for the first wedding and permanent removal from ministry for the second.

While the United Methodist Church has taken steps towards inclusion and lifted mandatory prohibitions, there is still a lack of uniformity in the church's approach to LGBTQ+ issues. The church's Social Principles continue to include an incompatibility clause, stating that the practice of homosexuality is incompatible with Christian teaching.

It is important to note that the United Methodist Church is a global denomination with varying regional attitudes towards LGBTQ+ issues. The church has approved a regionalization plan that grants different regions autonomy in adapting rules on issues, including sexuality. This plan aims to diffuse tensions between the progressive American church and more conservative international factions.

The United Methodist Church's global structure and regional differences

The United Methodist Church (UMC) has a global structure that mirrors the US government, with judicial, executive, and legislative branches. The legislative branch, the General Conference, meets every four years to set church policy. It consists of around 1,000 delegates, half of whom are lay leaders and the other half, clergy. The General Conference is the only body that can speak officially for the UMC.

The UMC is divided into conferences, with the highest level being the General Conference. The church is further divided into jurisdictional and central conferences, which meet every four years, and annual conferences, which are the basic unit of organisation within the UMC. The annual conferences are further divided into districts.

The UMC's global structure has led to regional differences, with the church's worldwide growth moving it "in a more traditionalist and orthodox direction". The UMC has around 12.5 million members worldwide, with 7 million in the US. In 2020, the US accounted for 6,268,310 members and 30,543 churches, while outside the US, the church had 6,464,127 members and 12,866 churches.

In 2024, the UMC's branch in the Ivory Coast, with 1.2 million members, left the church in response to the General Conference's decision to allow same-sex marriages and gay clergy. The Romania-Bulgaria Conference has also left the UMC, and conferences in Nigeria, Slovakia, Bulgaria, Croatia, and the Philippines have expressed intentions to disaffiliate.

The UMC's global structure and regional differences have been highlighted by the debate around LGBTQ+ inclusion. While the UMC does not recognise or perform same-sex marriages, and has policies that are strongly against the LGBTQ+ community, many church leaders, including local pastors, welcome and support gays and lesbians as church members.

In 2024, the UMC General Conference voted to repeal bans on LGBTQ+ clergy and same-sex marriage. However, prior to this, the UMC had rules prohibiting same-sex unions and the ordination of non-celibate homosexuals, found in the Book of Discipline. The UMC's global structure and regional differences were evident in the lead-up to this vote, with conservative congregations departing the church, particularly in Texas, and liberal activists looking forward to new majorities supporting their agenda.

The regional differences within the UMC have led to a schism, with the formation of the Global Methodist Church (GMC) in 2022. Congregations that joined the GMC opposed the recognition of same-sex marriage and the ordination of non-celibate gay clergy. The GMC has a presence in the US and internationally, with nearly 4,500 congregations and a similar number of pastors as of 2024.

Frequently asked questions