Catholics Attending Outdoor Protestant Weddings: Is It Allowed?

Catholics may be able to attend a Protestant wedding, but it depends on several factors. If the wedding is between two Protestants, and it is the first marriage for both, and neither are ex-Catholics, then a Catholic can attend. However, if the wedding is between a Catholic and a Protestant, it is more complicated. If the Catholic party has received a dispensation from their Bishop, then a Catholic can attend. If not, they should avoid the wedding, even if the Catholic party is a close relative.

Catholics can attend a Protestant wedding if the couple are both baptised and it is their first marriage

Catholics can attend a Protestant wedding if certain conditions are met. Firstly, the marriage must be recognised as valid by the Catholic Church. In the case of two baptised Protestants, the marriage is considered valid because the sacrament of marriage is made present by the couple giving valid matrimonial consent to each other and consummating the union. Thus, Catholics can attend such weddings without hesitation and share in the couple's joy.

However, there are situations when a Catholic should not attend the wedding of two Protestants. These include when the couple are of the same sex, when either individual is not baptised, or when there are impediments to a valid sacramental marriage, such as a prior marriage bond. Attending such weddings would imply approval and contribution to a public scandal, which is not permitted.

Additionally, when it comes to a wedding between a Catholic and a Protestant, the situation becomes more complex. If the Catholic party has received a dispensation from their Bishop, allowing them to marry outside the Catholic Church, then Catholics can attend without issue. However, if such a dispensation has not been obtained, it is generally advised that Catholics avoid attending, even if the Catholic party is a close relative. This is because the marriage would not be considered valid by the Catholic Church, and attending could imply approval of a union that goes against the Church's teachings.

In summary, Catholics can attend a Protestant wedding if the couple are both baptised and it is their first marriage. However, they should refrain from attending if either party is Catholic and the marriage is taking place outside the Catholic Church without the proper dispensation. The decision to attend or not attend a wedding is a sensitive matter that requires careful discernment, prayer, and, if needed, discussion with a pastor or priest.

If the Catholic party has received a dispensation from their Bishop, they can attend

If a Catholic wishes to attend the wedding of a Catholic being held in a non-Catholic setting, they must first obtain a dispensation from their Bishop. This is because the Catholic Church requires Catholics to marry in a Catholic wedding ceremony, in front of the pastor of the parish, the diocesan Bishop, or a cleric deputed by either of them, and in the presence of two witnesses.

If a Catholic wishes to marry in a non-Catholic ceremony, they can obtain a dispensation from their diocesan Bishop, which will permit them to marry in a non-Catholic ceremony, which will be considered valid in the eyes of the Church. This dispensation is only granted if the Bishop determines that it would lead to "grave difficulties".

If a Catholic has obtained a dispensation from their Bishop, then their Catholic friends and family may attend the wedding. However, if there is a communion service at the ceremony, Catholics may not receive communion in a non-Catholic ceremony.

If a dispensation has not been obtained, then Catholics should avoid such a wedding, even if the Catholic is a close relative. This is because the wedding will not be considered a valid marriage in the eyes of the Catholic Church, and attending would be tantamount to expressing support for something that God hates.

Catholics should not attend a wedding of two ex-Catholics

Attending the wedding of two ex-Catholics is a complex issue for practising Catholics. While there is no explicit Church prohibition, it is a matter that requires prudential judgement, keeping in mind the Catholic understanding of the sanctity of marriage.

Firstly, it is important to understand the difference between "attending" and "assisting" at a wedding. "Assisting" refers specifically to the role of the pastor (or their delegate) who witnesses the marriage, as well as the best man and maid of honour, who are required to sign the official documents. "Attending", on the other hand, simply means being present in the congregation. Canon law does not impede Catholics from "attending" wedding ceremonies or receptions.

However, the question of whether to attend the wedding of two ex-Catholics is a matter of theological and pastoral nature. A true marriage is considered a sacrament in the Catholic Church, and getting married outside the Church is considered a mortal sin for a baptised Catholic. Attending such a wedding could be seen as participating in an imitation-mockery of a sacrament, and by doing so, one may become an accomplice to another's mortal sin through consent, praise, partaking and silence.

Furthermore, if the attendance of a Catholic at this wedding would push the ex-Catholic spouses further away from the Catholic Church, it is advised that they do not attend. However, if their presence might help bring the ex-Catholics closer to the Church, there is a possibility of attending, provided that they speak up about the importance of having the marriage blessed by the Church and putting Christ at the centre of their relationship.

In conclusion, while there is no clear-cut answer, Catholics should carefully consider the potential implications of their attendance at the wedding of two ex-Catholics, weighing the spiritual well-being of the individuals involved and their own commitment to upholding the sanctity of marriage.

Catholics should not attend a wedding of a Catholic and non-Catholic if the dispensation from canonical form has not been granted

The Catholic Church has strict rules about marriage, and these apply to both the couple and their guests. A Catholic is required by law to marry in a Catholic wedding ceremony, and this is only considered valid if it is celebrated by the pastor of the parish, the diocesan Bishop, or a cleric deputed by either of them, and in the presence of two witnesses.

If a Catholic marries in a civil ceremony or in a non-Catholic place of worship, the Church does not recognise it as valid. However, a Catholic can obtain a dispensation from canonical form, which permits them to marry in a non-Catholic ceremony, which would be considered valid in the eyes of the Church. This can be granted by the diocesan bishop if it is determined that a Catholic wedding ceremony would lead to "grave difficulties".

If a Catholic marries a non-Catholic without dispensation from canonical form, the Church does not recognise the union as a valid marriage. In this case, Catholics are advised not to attend the wedding, as there will be no valid sacramental union to celebrate. Attending such a wedding could be seen as turning a blind eye to grave sin and could jeopardise the salvation of the couple.

Therefore, Catholics should not attend the wedding of a Catholic and a non-Catholic if dispensation from canonical form has not been granted. By doing so, they would be contributing to a public scandal and giving their approval and blessing to a union that is not recognised by the Church.

Catholics cannot receive communion at a Protestant service

Catholics are allowed to attend a Protestant wedding, but they cannot receive communion during the service. This is because, for Catholics, the Eucharist is the most intimate expression of their faith. Sharing it with a visitor would be like inviting someone into your bedroom without first entering the living room. The Eucharist is also considered to be the body and blood of Christ, and Catholics believe that it would be dangerous to mess with it without the right preparation.

Catholics believe that the Protestant rituals for making new pastors/ministers (holy orders) are not valid. Only a validly ordained priest can transubstantiate the substances into the Body and Blood of Christ. Thus, Protestants don’t have valid communion. If a Catholic were to receive communion at a Protestant church, they would be mocking the true Holy Eucharist.

Catholics who attend a Protestant wedding service can go up with their arms crossed in an "X" to signify that they would like to receive a blessing instead of communion.

Frequently asked questions