Objections: Can They Really Stop A Wedding?

The dramatic wedding objection, a staple of romantic comedies and pop culture, is rarely seen in real life. The tradition of soliciting objections during wedding ceremonies originated in the 12th century with the Catholic Church, which allowed people to object to a marriage before or during the ceremony. This was done to uncover any reasons why the marriage would be unlawful, such as one of the parties already being married or the couple being too closely related. However, in modern times, any potential issues are usually resolved when the couple secures a marriage license before the ceremony. While it is uncommon for wedding guests to object during a ceremony, if someone does object, the officiant typically has the option to either halt the proceedings and discuss the objection privately or to ignore it and continue with the wedding.

What to do if someone objects during the ceremony?

Although it is uncommon for someone to object during a wedding ceremony, it is still a possibility. If someone does object, it is up to the officiant to decide how to handle the situation. Here are some options on what to do if someone objects during the ceremony:

Pause the ceremony and address the objection

The officiant may choose to pause the ceremony and give the objector an opportunity to speak privately. This can be done by taking the objector aside and discussing the reason for the objection without an audience. This option is often chosen to understand the objection and determine if there is a legal or valid reason for the objection.

Make light of the situation

In some cases, the officiant may prefer to make light of the situation and downplay the objection. This approach aims to minimise disruption and avoid drawing attention to the objection. A skilled officiant may use humour or a light-hearted comment to diffuse any tension and continue with the ceremony as planned.

Involve the couple in deciding the next steps

If an objection occurs, the officiant can involve the couple in deciding how to proceed. The couple may wish to take a moment to gather themselves before deciding whether to pause the ceremony or continue. It is essential to respect their wishes and ensure they feel comfortable with the chosen course of action.

Rely on the wedding guests to intervene

In some instances, the wedding guests may take it upon themselves to intervene and address the objection. This could involve encouraging the objector to leave the ceremony or providing support to the couple. It is important to note that the guests' actions should not escalate the situation and should aim to maintain a peaceful environment for the couple and other attendees.

Be prepared and discuss tactics in advance

If the couple or officiant anticipates a potential objection, it is beneficial to discuss tactics beforehand. This includes deciding how to respond, whether to pause the ceremony, and how to handle the objector. Being prepared can help minimise disruption and ensure the ceremony proceeds smoothly.

It is important to remember that any objection should be handled with sensitivity and respect for all parties involved. While objections are rare, it is within the officiant's authority to decide how to proceed, ensuring the couple's wishes are prioritised.

What happens if the officiant doesn't ask for objections?

The tradition of asking for objections during a wedding ceremony is becoming obsolete. This is because no legitimate grounds remain for objecting to a wedding. Any potential problems are usually resolved when the couple is securing a marriage license, which is typically done before the wedding ceremony. As such, most officiants do not see the point of creating an awkward silence and choose to omit the "speak now or forever hold your peace" line.

However, if the officiant does not ask for objections and someone still objects, the ceremony will be interrupted. At this point, it is up to the officiant to decide how to proceed. They may pause the ceremony to address the objection or continue with the ceremony, especially if the objection is minor and holds no legal merit.

If the objection is based on a legal issue, the officiant may pause the ceremony to discuss the matter with the couple and the objector in private. If the objection is emotional in nature, the officiant may try to downplay the situation and continue with the ceremony as planned. Ultimately, it is the officiant's prerogative to decide how to handle an objection, and it is advisable for the couple to discuss tactics with the officiant beforehand if they anticipate any outbursts.

What are the origins of the phrase speak now or forever hold your peace?

The phrase "speak now or forever hold your peace" originates from the marriage liturgy section of the Book of Common Prayer. The book, first published in 1549, provides guidelines for religious services, customs, and worship in the Church of England, or Anglican Church. The phrase is a shortened version of a longer sentence: "Should anyone present know of any reason that this couple should not be joined in holy matrimony, speak now or forever hold your peace."

The tradition of soliciting objections during wedding ceremonies began in the 12th century when the Catholic Church used it as a way to uncover any reasons why it would be unlawful for a couple to marry. This included cases where the groom had another wife or if the couple was related.

In medieval times, with slow and complicated communication between areas and disorganized record-keeping, the Christian church established this phrase to allow time for any legal issues in the marriage to come to light. News of the wedding was publicly posted for a few weeks to allow word to travel to outlying areas. The "speak now or forever hold your peace" portion of the ceremony gave people a final chance to voice any objections before the marriage became legally binding.

Today, the phrase is considered obsolete by many officiants and is often omitted from modern weddings. Any potential issues are typically resolved when the couple secures a marriage license before the ceremony. However, some Christian denominations, such as the Episcopal Church, still incorporate this tradition into their wedding ceremonies.

What are valid reasons for objecting?

The tradition of objecting at weddings was introduced by the Catholic Church in the 12th century to ensure the legality of a union before making it official. Back then, it was much harder to check the marital status of people from other towns, their ages, or whether they were related.

Today, the only valid reasons for objecting are those with a legal basis. This could include one of the parties already being married, being underage, being too closely related, or being forced into the marriage.

It's worth noting that in modern times, most legal issues are brought up before the couple applies for their marriage license, so it's very unlikely that an objection would be raised during the wedding ceremony.

What happens to the person who objects?

While it is uncommon for wedding guests to object during a ceremony, it is still possible. If someone does object, it is up to the couple and the objector to decide what happens next. The objector could remain for the rest of the ceremony (an awkward choice), leave of their own accord, or be escorted out of the ceremony at the couple's request.

If the objection is serious, the officiant may pause the ceremony to discuss the objection with the objector in private. If the objection is not a legal reason for the couple not to wed, the ceremony will likely continue as planned. However, if the objection is a legitimate legal reason, the officiant would be obliged to defer the wedding and investigate the claim.

In most cases, objections are made in jest, and the ceremony continues with some light-hearted comments to defuse the situation.

Frequently asked questions