A Wedding, An Objection: What Now?

The dramatic wedding objection, a staple of romantic comedies and soap operas, is a rare occurrence in real life. But what happens if someone does object during a wedding ceremony?

The tradition of soliciting objections during a wedding ceremony dates back to the 12th century when the Catholic Church introduced it as a way to ensure the legality of a union before making it official. At the time, people relied on word-of-mouth and individual knowledge to determine whether a couple was eligible to wed. Grounds for objection included factors like a party already being married, close blood relations, or being underage without parental consent.

In modern times, with easily accessible legal records, the tradition has become mostly obsolete. However, the phrase speak now or forever hold your peace still persists in some wedding ceremonies, usually as a nod to tradition rather than an actual invitation for objections.

If someone does object during a wedding, the officiant typically has two options. They can either take the objecting person to another room to privately discuss their reasons or choose to ignore the objection and continue with the ceremony as normal. In most cases, the wedding can indeed go on if someone objects, assuming the couple wishes to finish the ceremony.

The officiant pauses the ceremony and decides how to proceed

If someone objects during a wedding ceremony, the officiant may pause the ceremony and decide how to proceed. This is a very uncommon situation, and there are no official rules dictating what the officiant should do. However, they typically have two options.

The first option is for the officiant to take the objecting person aside to a private room and allow them to explain their reason for the objection. The couple may then join them to discuss the issue further. If the objection is minor and holds no legal merit, the officiant can choose to resume the ceremony as normal. However, if the objection is significant and raises legal concerns, the officiant may need to postpone the wedding to allow for further investigation.

The second option is for the officiant to ignore the objection and continue with the ceremony. In this case, the wedding guests usually take the initiative to deal with the objecting person and encourage them to leave.

It is important to note that wedding objections are intended for legal issues rather than emotional ones. In most cases, an emotional objection, such as a declaration of love from an ex-partner, would not be sufficient to stop the wedding.

The officiant may take the objector aside to understand their reason

If someone objects during a wedding ceremony, the officiant has two options. They can either take the objector aside to understand their reason for objecting, or they can ignore the objection and continue with the wedding as planned.

If the officiant chooses to take the objector aside, this conversation should take place in a private setting to avoid inflaming the situation further. The officiant can then assess the validity of the objection.

Historically, objections were made on legal grounds, such as one party already being married, the couple being too closely related, or one party being underage. In modern times, it is much rarer for an objection to have legal merit, as most legalities of the marriage are established when applying for a marriage license.

If the officiant determines that the objection is not based on a valid legal reason, they can proceed with the wedding. They may first ask the couple if they are happy to continue and then attempt to minimise disruption by briefly apologising for the interruption and thanking everyone for their support.

If the objection is based on a legitimate legal concern, the officiant must discontinue the ceremony. This would only be necessary in extreme circumstances, as emotional objections do not hold any legal weight and cannot prevent a wedding from taking place.

The couple may choose to continue with the ceremony

If the couple is certain that there are no legal grounds for the objection, they may choose to continue with the ceremony. In this case, the officiant would simply acknowledge the objection and proceed with the wedding.

It is important to note that wedding objections are meant for legal issues, not emotional ones. Therefore, unless the objection has a valid legal basis, it does not have any bearing on the wedding itself.

If the couple decides to continue, the officiant may first ask them if they are happy to proceed. This gives the couple an opportunity to take a break or consider not moving forward. However, if the couple is confident in their decision, they can pick up where they left off and continue with the ceremony.

In some cases, the officiant may choose to ignore the objection and continue with the wedding as if nothing happened. While this may be a bit awkward, it ensures that the couple's special moment is not overshadowed by the objection.

To prevent any unwanted objections, the couple can also choose to skip the "speak now or forever hold your peace" part of the ceremony altogether. This is especially relevant for non-religious ceremonies, as there is no religious obligation to include this tradition.

The officiant may ignore the objection and continue with the wedding

While it is uncommon for someone to object during a wedding ceremony, it can happen. If someone does object, the officiant has two options. They can either take the objector to another room to privately discuss their reasons for objecting, or they can ignore the objection and continue with the wedding. If the officiant chooses the latter option, the wedding guests will usually deal with the objector and encourage them to leave.

If the officiant chooses to ignore the objection, it is important to remember that wedding objections are only for legal issues, not emotional ones. No one can stop a wedding unless they have a valid legal reason for doing so. Objections that are based on emotional or moral grounds are not sufficient to prevent a wedding from taking place.

In most cases, any legal issues that could prevent a wedding from taking place would be identified before the wedding day. For example, when a couple gives notice of their intention to marry, their details are checked against records to ensure that they are not already married, too closely related, or underage. Therefore, it is unlikely that an objection raised on the wedding day would have valid legal grounds.

If the officiant ignores the objection and continues with the wedding, they may try to use humour to diffuse the situation and move on. They may also check in with the couple to ensure they are okay with proceeding and may apologise for the interruption before continuing with the ceremony.

The couple may decide to not move forward with the ceremony

• They are not ready to get married and need more time to consider their decision.
• They have differing views on important issues that have not been resolved.
• There are legal reasons that prevent the marriage from taking place, such as one of them being already married or being too closely related.
• They feel that the objection has raised valid concerns that need to be addressed before they can continue with the ceremony.
• They are no longer sure about their relationship and need time to re-evaluate their feelings for each other.

In such cases, it is important for the couple to take the time they need to make an informed decision. They should not feel pressured to continue with the ceremony if they are not ready or if there are valid reasons for objection. It is better to postpone or cancel the wedding than to go through with a marriage that may not be legal or that one or both partners have doubts about.

Frequently asked questions