Wedding Cake Conundrum: Why Are They Often Dry?

Wedding cakes have a reputation for being dry and tasteless. While this isn't always the case, there are several reasons why this misconception may exist. Firstly, wedding cakes are often made in advance, which can lead to dryness if not properly stored. Additionally, the type of cake and ingredients used can impact moisture levels—sponge cakes, for instance, tend to dry out faster. Fondant icing, while aesthetically pleasing, can also be off-putting to some, and certain cake designs may prioritise appearance over taste. Furthermore, cakes baked with too much flour, at the wrong temperature, or for too long may also contribute to dryness.

Wedding cakes are made in advance

Wedding cakes are often made a few days in advance to allow time for decoration and transportation to the venue. This also gives the baker some flexibility in case they need to start over. However, making a wedding cake in advance can be challenging, as cakes are best served fresh, and there is a risk of them drying out.

A common misconception is that wedding cakes are dry because they are made a few days ahead of the event. While this is a logical assumption, it is not always true. The coating applied to the cake, such as buttercream or chocolate ganache, seals in moisture and acts as a tight wrap. Fondant icing can further preserve freshness by completely coating the cake and providing an additional layer of protection.

To ensure that a wedding cake made in advance remains moist, bakers may use a simple syrup to soak the cake layers. This technique, known as "soaking a cake," not only adds moisture but can also enhance the flavour. For example, a lemon syrup can be used to complement a lemon drizzle sponge cake. However, adding moisture to a cake through soaking can reduce its shelf life and may not be suitable for all cake designs, especially those with intricate decorations.

When making a wedding cake in advance, proper storage is crucial. Once the cake layers are baked and cooled, they should be wrapped and stored at room temperature until they are filled and coated. After the initial coating is applied, the cake should be refrigerated to maintain freshness. It is also essential to keep buttercream out of the fridge to prevent it from becoming too solid, making it difficult to rewhip for frosting.

Fondant can seal in moisture

Fondant can be a great way to seal in moisture and keep your wedding cake fresh. While some people dislike the taste or texture of fondant, a skilled cake designer can roll it out thinly so that it's barely noticeable. Fondant also opens up more design options, such as clean stencilling, hand-painted messages, and marble cakes.

Fondant is especially useful for wedding cakes, as it can help to seal in moisture and keep the cake fresh for longer. This is important, as wedding cakes are often made a few days in advance and need to stay moist until they are served. Fondant acts as a tight wrap, completely coating the cake and preventing it from drying out.

In addition to fondant, the coating of buttercream or chocolate ganache that is typically applied to a cake first also helps to seal in moisture. This combination of fondant and a buttercream or ganache coating can ensure that your wedding cake stays moist and delicious.

To avoid dry and crumbly fondant, there are several things you can do:

• Knead the fondant well before rolling it out to make it more pliable and reduce the chances of it drying out.
• When rolling out the fondant, use a light dusting of powdered sugar or cornstarch to prevent sticking, but avoid using too much as it can dry out the fondant.
• Store your fondant properly in an airtight container or wrapped tightly in plastic wrap to prevent exposure to air, which can quickly dry it out.
• Avoid exposing fondant to direct sunlight or warm environments, as it is sensitive to heat and can dry out and crack.
• If your fondant starts to dry out while you're working with it, lightly dampen a clean cloth with water and gently rub it over the surface to rehydrate it.
• If your fondant is dry, you can add a small amount of glycerin or vegetable shortening to it gradually, being careful not to add too much as it can make the fondant too soft.
• Work quickly when rolling out and covering your cake with fondant to minimise exposure to air and reduce the chances of it drying out.
• Consider the humidity levels in your environment and adjust accordingly. In dry climates, you might need to add a little extra moisture to the fondant, while in humid climates, you may need to use less liquid and dust your work surface with powdered sugar instead of cornstarch to prevent sticking.

Too much flour can be used

Wedding cakes, or any cakes for that matter, can become dry due to a number of reasons, one of the most common being the use of too much flour. This can happen when a measuring cup is used instead of a scale, resulting in up to 20% more flour than required. The imbalance of flour and liquid in the cake batter affects the outcome, and too much flour absorbs too much moisture, leading to a dry, crumbly, and dense cake.

To avoid this, it is recommended to weigh the flour on a scale, as done by most professional bakers. However, if a scale is not available, there is a specific technique to use a measuring cup. First, gather your flour, a handled scoop or tablespoon, and the measuring cup. Open the bag of flour wide for easy access. Use the spoon or scoop to transfer flour into the measuring cup, being careful not to pack the flour down and allowing it to cascade in a mound. Use a knife or the handle of the spoon to level the flour.

Additionally, the type of flour used matters. Cake flour, with its fine grind and higher starch content, absorbs and retains more liquid than all-purpose flour, resulting in a softer and moister cake. Substituting all-purpose flour for cake flour or whole wheat flour in a recipe can lead to a drier cake.

Furthermore, the ratio of wet to dry ingredients is crucial. If there is too much flour and not enough butter or oil, the cake will taste dry. On the other hand, too much milk and not enough flour will make the cake too wet. Finding the right balance is essential for a moist and fluffy cake.

In summary, to prevent a dry wedding cake, it is important to accurately measure the flour, use the appropriate type of flour, and maintain the correct ratio of wet to dry ingredients. These steps will help ensure a moist and delicious cake.

Cakes are stored in the fridge

While storing cakes in the fridge might seem like a good idea, it can actually cause them to dry out and go stale faster. This is due to the way starch molecules in the flour absorb water and then recrystallize as the cake cools, forcing the water out and to the surface of the cake, where it evaporates.

So, what's the best way to store cakes? Well, if you're planning to eat your cake within three days of baking, it's best to keep it at room temperature, away from heat and direct sunlight. If it's in a bakery box, you can leave it in there, and if you plan to eat it within 24 hours, no additional wrapping is needed.

If you want to store it for longer than three days, you have a few options. You can either wrap the box in plastic wrap, which will keep the cake from drying out for up to three days, or use an acrylic cake lid or a plastic cake storage container. These options will protect your cake from dust and other airborne particles while keeping it fresh.

If you need to store your cake for an even longer period, freezing is a great option. Unlike refrigeration, freezing can keep your cake fresh for longer periods, and it works for both unfrosted and frosted cakes. Simply wrap the bakery box in two layers of plastic wrap and store it in the freezer.

Additionally, if you've baked a cake and want to store it for a few days before frosting and decorating, freezing is ideal. Cool the individual layers, then double-wrap them in plastic before placing them in the freezer. They'll stay fresh for several weeks to a few months, depending on the type of cake.

Remember, when it comes to cakes, refrigeration should be avoided unless your kitchen gets very hot, the cake has perishable ingredients, or it won't be served for more than three days. By following these storage tips, you can ensure your cakes stay moist and delicious!

Oven temperatures vary

Additionally, the type of pan you use can also impact the baking time and temperature. Metal pans, especially dark ones, conduct heat better than glass or light-coloured stoneware pans. So, if you're using a different pan from the one specified in the recipe, you may need to adjust the baking time and temperature accordingly.

Furthermore, it's crucial to monitor your cake throughout the baking process. Check on it regularly and make adjustments as needed. Don't rely solely on the timer, as even a couple of extra minutes in the oven can make the difference between a moist and dry cake.

Another factor to consider is the recipe itself. Some cakes, like angel food cake or genoise, are meant to be on the drier side. These cakes are designed to be rolled, stacked, or filled with creamy fillings without becoming soggy. So, if you're aiming for a moist cake, choose a recipe that doesn't call for a dry texture.

Lastly, the ingredients you use can also impact the moisture content of your cake. For instance, using butter instead of vegetable oil can result in a drier cake since butter has a lower fat content. Similarly, using too much flour can lead to a dry and crumbly texture as it absorbs too much moisture from the batter.

Frequently asked questions